Judge refuses to reconsider finding DHS violated court order
Share this @internewscast.com

President Donald Trump boards Air Force One to depart Joint Base Andrews, Md., Friday, May 23, 2025 (AP Photo/Manuel Balce Ceneta).

A judge in Massachusetts has decided not to suspend a recent ruling that found the Trump administration violated a previous court order. The violation occurred when they swiftly deported six migrants to conflict-stricken South Sudan—a nation none of the migrants originate from—without allowing them due process or the chance to raise concerns about potential persecution or torture.

Judge Brian E. Murphy, from the U.S. District Court, has suggested that this violation might lead to charges of criminal contempt of court. On Monday, he criticized the administration for misrepresenting the court’s prior decisions and the arguments made by Department of Justice attorneys during the legal process.

“The Defendants have falsely portrayed this Court’s directive, while simultaneously causing the disorder they criticize,” Judge Murphy stated in his 17-page order. “By rushing to place six class members on a flight to the unstable region of South Sudan, in clear violation of legal standards and this Court’s order, the Defendants forced this Court to conclude they violated the Preliminary Injunction.”

Murphy last month issued a preliminary injunction barring the government from sending migrants to third countries without giving them a “reasonable opportunity” to raise concerns about that country and the possible violence they could face under the Convention Against Torture (CAT). Last week, he called an emergency hearing after the administration removed the six migrants to South Sudan with less than 16 hours of advanced notice, “most of which were non-waking hours, none within the business day.” The detainees also had virtually no means of communication after being informed of their removal.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

During the emergency hearing, the DOJ asserted that administration officials misunderstood Murphy’s injunction because he had not been specific enough regarding what a “reasonable opportunity” to express fear entailed.

The court ordered the administration to keep the detainees onboard the plane in South Sudan until they were provided reasonable fear interviews. The court also imposed a minimum of 10 days for detainees to rase fear-based claims under CAT prior to removals to third countries. At the suggestion of the DOJ, Murphy allowed the government to “keep the individuals out of the country and finish their process abroad.”

The Justice Department responded by claiming the court’s order was “extraordinary” and imposed “highly burdensome requirements” on the government to keep the “dangerous criminals” detained in a “sensitive location” without “clear knowledge of when, how, or where this Court will tolerate their release.”

The DOJ further asserted that Murphy’s order placed “impermissible” constraints on President Donald Trump’s ability to carry out his Article II powers, including “his powers to command the military, manage relations with foreign nations, and execute our nation’s immigration authorities.”

“The Court’s Orders are premised on an erroneous conclusion that Defendants failed to provide ‘meaningful opportunity’ for six class members to assert a claim for protection under CAT, despite having allowed the six class members an opportunity that is eminently reasonable in the removal context,” the DOJ wrote in the motion seeking reconsideration or a stay pending appeal. “Moreover, the Orders impermissibly infringe on the President’s inherent Article II authority to conduct foreign affairs and serve as Commander-in-Chief. The Orders also improperly interfere with the President’s ability to faithfully execute immigration laws.”

But the government’s complaints fell on deaf ears, as Murphy explained that his order never required the government to conduct their proceedings overseas, writing that the administration could “simply return to the status quo of roughly one week ago” by returning the migrants to the U.S. or choose “any other location to complete the required process.”

“It cannot be said enough that this is the result Defendants asked for,” Murphy wrote. “In doing so, the Court offered Defendants a method of compliance that both guaranteed the procedural rights due to the class members but was less exacting than having to turn around a chartered plane. The Court considered Defendants’ prerogative in the sensitive and political areas of immigration and foreign policy and offered Defendants complete discretion to provide these interviews in the time and manner they deemed best.”

The judge continued to criticize the administration for complaining about the “hardship” of having to carry out “impromptu immigration proceedings on foreign soil,” saying “that was — and continues to be — Defendants’ daily choice,” adding, “To say more would be to paint the lily.”

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Man Kept Fiancée’s Body After Murder, Wanted to Be With Her: DA Reports

Inset: William Oddo III (Denton Police Department). Background: The vicinity of the…

Court Rebukes State Attorney General for Ignoring Immigrant Order

Left: A U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement raid in progress (Fox News/YouTube).…

Gainesville Woman Accused of Rape After Persuading Man with Drinks to Visit Her Apartment

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Eryn Michelle Lane, 25, was taken into…

Trump Criticizes Abrego Garcia, Denies Ordering His Return

Main: President Donald Trump talks with reporters while signing executive orders and…

More Charges Filed Against Tesla Driver in Wrong-Way Collision

Left: Keoma Duarte (New Hampshire State Police). Right: Sgt. Jeremy Cole (Endicott…

Fugitive Apprehended Following Alleged Theft and Crash of Vehicle

A prisoner who escaped a facility south of Brisbane last month has…

Police: 3-Year-Old Boy Found Living Alone in Shed by Parents

Left: Joseph Turner. Right: Sarah Pombert (Douglas County Sheriff’s Office). In Georgia,…

Former NFL Player Kelvin Joseph Jr. Charged with DWI After Fatal Motorcycle Accident in Texas

A fatal motorcycle crash in Texas resulted in the loss of a…

Surprising erased images crucial in convicting killer: Jury member

Left: Maxwell Anderson hears his guilty verdict (Law&Crime). Right: Sade Robinson (Milwaukee…

Florida Man Charged with Parents’ Murder and Intimidation of Others

Inset: Nicholas Steven Kirchner (Sumter County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The Largo, Florida…

Man Accused of Shattering Seven Home Windows and Six Car Windows Using Metal Rod

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Anthony Levern Tumblin, 59, was taken into…

Pregnant Woman in West Virginia Allegedly Beaten to Unconsciousness by Boyfriend: Police Report

A pregnant West Virginia mother was brutally beaten and left for dead…