Abrego Garcia's lawyers request Trump admin be sanctioned
Share this @internewscast.com

Left: Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a Salvadoran citizen residing in Maryland who was deported to El Salvador by the Trump administration, converses in a hotel restaurant in San Salvador, El Salvador, on Thursday, April 17, 2025. (Press Office Senator Van Hollen, via AP). Right: President Donald Trump addresses reporters after landing on Air Force One, Tuesday, June 10, 2025, at Joint Base Andrews, Md. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon)

Attorneys for Kilmar Abrego Garcia, the Maryland resident “wrongfully” deported to El Salvador and recently brought back, are urging a federal court to impose sanctions and initiate an investigation into the Trump administration for its “defiance” of court directives related to his return.

In a blistering 33-page filing submitted late Wednesday, Abrego Garcia’s lawyers criticized the federal government for its “delays and obfuscation,” claiming that its actions “harmed” Abrego Garcia and left him “without options.” According to them, the administration, or at least certain officials, “not only ignored the Court’s orders but deliberately attempted to hinder the discovery process” — a precedent they argue could be perilous for future cases.

Love true crime? Sign up for our newsletter, The Law&Crime Docket, to get the latest real-life crime stories delivered right to your inbox.

From Abrego Garcia’s request for discovery sanctions:

The Government’s defiance has not been subtle. It has been vocal and sustained and flagrant. The Defendants’ defiance of judicial orders has been accompanied by misrepresentations, stonewalling, and even questioning of this Court’s authority. The Defendants’ defiance of this Court’s discovery orders, in particular, has been egregious, defined by open refusal to produce any evidence of its professed compliance and the meritless assertion of an array of purported privileges to shield its actions from scrutiny.

Abrego Garcia was returned to the United States from El Salvador on Friday. His sudden return came after months of legal disagreements and public feuding between U.S. lawmakers and officials over his deportation, which the administration admitted was due to an “administrative error” — shining a spotlight on the administration’s deportation process.

Upon his arrival in Tennessee, he was charged in federal court with two counts of illegally transporting undocumented migrants into the country.

U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis had ordered federal officials to “facilitate” the Maryland man’s return from El Salvador, a country to which an immigration judge in 2019 said he could not be deported due to his stated fears of persecution. The definition of “facilitate” was contested — and even brought before the Supreme Court — with the administration arguing it didn’t have the authority to return the deportee and even questioning the Maryland federal judge’s jurisdiction to make such an order.

Wednesday’s filing took aim at the government’s questioning of the court’s authority and alleged lack of providing answers.

“While the Government — not Plaintiffs — bears the ultimate burden to establish its compliance with this Court’s order to facilitate return and has failed to do so, its failure to timely produce relevant information in response to Plaintiffs’ discovery requests allows the Government to present a cherry-picked record of compliance,” Abrego Garcia’s lawyers wrote, adding that “there is a clear and pressing need to deter the Government and other litigants from engaging in similar obstructive tactics.”

The lawyers added: “The lengths the Government has gone to resist discovery relating to these core questions raises a strong inference that the Government is trying to hide its conduct from the scrutiny of this Court, the Plaintiffs, and the public. What the Government improperly seeks to hide must be exposed for all to see.”

U.S. Justice Department attorneys have argued they complied with the court order to return Abrego Garcia, but his lawyers see the monthslong court battle as “willful noncompliance” — either from the administration as a whole or from specific actors, such as Homeland Security General Counsel Joseph Mazzara, who they believe may have lied.

As such, Abrego Garcia’s lawyers are requesting that the court impose sanctions against the administration “for their flagrant, repeated violations of this Court’s discovery orders,” as well as “compel the production of documents previously withheld” or appoint a special master to investigate the extent of the alleged noncompliance.

They made it a point to argue for severe sanctions given how the government “repeatedly thumbed its nose at Plaintiffs and this Court in court filings, hearings, and public statements to the media.” They suggest sanctions ranging from fines and civil contempt to default judgment.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Shocking Allegations: British Man Faces Charges of Drugging and Repeatedly Assaulting Ex-Wife

The British legal system has formally accused a man of systematically drugging…

Police Report: Woman Allegedly Attempts to Stab Walmart Shopper with Pocketknife Through Car Window

Background: The Walmart Supercenter located on South Bishop Avenue in Rolla, Missouri…

Shocking Verdict: Couple’s Attempt to Trade Baby for Beer Unravels at Campground

Inset left to right: Darien Urban and Shalene Ehlers (Benton County Sheriff”s…

Board-Certified Plastic Surgeon Arrested for Allegedly Performing Surgery Under the Influence

Inset: Azul Shirazali Jaffer (Sugar Land Police Department). Background: The Houston-based office…

Shocking Arrest: Bar-Hopping Parents Overlook Baby Left in Car While Jaywalking

Background: Downtown Austin, Texas (Google Maps). Insets (left to right): Jaslyn Tovar,…

Father Accused of Risky Mountain Hike with Kids Opposes Courtroom Cameras for Their Well-being

Inset: Micah Smith and his wife (GoFundMe). Background: The Broads Fork Trail…

Western Sydney Tragedy: Woman Charged in Fatal Stabbing Incident

A 19-year-old woman has been charged with the murder of a 19-year-old…

Tragic Case: Mother Accused of Confining Daughter in Makeshift Closet and Starving Her to Death

Left inset: Andrea Loving being taken into custody for the murder of…

Tragic End to Cross-Country Trip: Mother Arrested After Missing 9-Year-Old Daughter Found Dead

Left: Ashlee Buzzard, in brown. Right: Melodee Buzzard (Santa Barbara County Sheriff”s…

Tragic Dental Procedure Turns Fatal: Family Secures Settlement After Patient’s Brain Injury

Inset: Derek Swanson (Facebook). Background: Scottsdale Facial and Oral Surgery in Arizona,…

Mystery at Sea: FBI Probes Disappearance of Two Lawyers from Abandoned Boat

The mystery surrounding the disappearance of two boaters off Florida’s coast has…

Colorado Mother Returned from UK to Face Charges in Children’s Tragic Deaths

A Colorado woman, accused of the horrific act of drugging and murdering…