Brent Rooker calls out tiebreaker rule after Home Run Derby elimination

Brent Rooker was not happy with the way he was bounced from the MLB Home Run Derby on Monday night. 

Rooker was eliminated in the first round by eventual Derby winner Cal Raleigh, even though both hit the same number of home runs. However, Raleigh’s longest homer was just .08 feet further than Booker’s. 

The A’s slugger expressed frustration that he wasn’t aware of the importance of the distance down to the decimal point until it was too late. 


Brent Rooker swings during the Home Run Derby on July 14, 2025.
Brent Rooker swings during the Home Run Derby on July 14, 2025. Getty Images

Though the scoreboard only showed rounded distances, Major League Baseball utilized the exact figures for official measurements. 

While both hit a max distance of 471, Rooker’s home run measured in at 470.53 feet, while Raleigh’s came in at 470.61 feet. 

“If they’re measuring to the decimal, it should be displayed during the Derby,” Rooker told reporters, “rather than revealing it after the event, as it could be useful.” 

Booker had also said that he only got 38 pitches instead of the 40 because he was told he could take two pitches, but wasn’t aware there were only 40 balls available for him to hit in total. 

“I took two pitches that didn’t count, but when we went to do the round, there was only 38 remaining, so we got down to have two pitches with five seconds left and they’re out of baseballs,” he said. 

Raleigh went on to win the Home Run Derby with his dad throwing to him and his younger brother behind the plate. 


Cal Raleigh reacts during the Home Run Derby on July 14, 2025.
Cal Raleigh reacts during the Home Run Derby on July 14, 2025. Getty Images

Booker still called the experience a “great time” and praised Raleigh.

“Cal’s a great competitor. He put on a good performance too,” he said. “Rules are the rules in terms of what makes up the semifinals.”

You May Also Like

Jack Smith accused of 'corrupt' probe of Trump, Republican lawmakers

Republicans Accuse Special Counsel Jack Smith of ‘Corrupt’ Trump Investigation

WASHINGTON — Former special counsel Jack Smith faced sharp questioning Tuesday from…
At least 40 rescued, 2 dead as boat capsizes after machete fight near Puerto Rico

2 Dead, 40 Rescued After Machete Fight Capsizes Boat Off Puerto Rico

At least 40 people were pulled from the ocean by the U.S.…
Slain NYT exec was transgender targeted by in-law: docs

Court Docs: In-Law Targeted Slain NYT Exec Over Transgender Status

A New York Times technology executive who was allegedly shot and killed…
Say Their Names: Cora, Dawson and Callan — Clancy Jury Holdout Speaks, and It's Beyond Powerful

Clancy Jury Holdout Speaks Out for Cora, Dawson and Callan

The sole holdout juror in the Lindsay Clancy triple-murder trial is speaking…
Cornell attacks gang rape accuser as 'irresponsible' for essay claims while defending how it handled accusations

Cornell University Calls Gang Rape Accuser’s Essay Claims ‘Irresponsible,’ Defends Its Response to Allegations

Cornell University on Monday criticized the woman who says she was the…
Cornell frat bros were 'disgusting, despicable' and immoral — but not clearly criminal, DA insists

DA Says Cornell Fraternity Members’ Conduct Was ‘Disgusting’ but Not Clearly Criminal

The New York prosecutor reviewing allegations that seven Cornell fraternity members gang-raped…
LSU frat pledges allegedly waterboarded, forced to chug milk in hazing rituals: report

LSU Fraternity Pledges Allegedly Waterboarded, Forced to Chug Milk

Louisiana State University has placed two fraternities on interim suspension while officials…
‘Santa Clarita Karen’ forced to apologize as her business implodes

Santa Clarita Woman Apologizes as Business Faces Backlash

A California business owner known online as “Santa Clarita Karen” is speaking…
Parents-in-law arrested after New York Times Games engineering director found fatally shot

Parents-in-Law Arrested After New York Times Games Engineering Director Found Shot Dead

Jonathan McKinsey, a New York Times Games engineering executive, was fatally shot…
Mexico's Baja California braces for major Hurricane Polo as Hurricane Nolo still threatens Hawaii

Baja California Braces for Hurricane Polo as Hurricane Nolo Continues to Threaten Hawaii

Residents across Mexico’s Baja California Sur sealed up their homes Monday as…
Iran under scrutiny after plot foiled near UK base used by US military

Iran Under Scrutiny After Foiled Plot Near UK Base Hosting US Forces

Only days after British Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband met Iran’s foreign minister…
Celebrity publicist rescues unconscious LA surfer from rough surf

Celebrity publicist rescues unconscious surfer from rough Los Angeles surf

A California woman plunged into turbulent ocean water and kept an unconscious…