President Donald Trump's threat to send National Guard to Chicago raises legal questions

CHICAGO (WLS) — As Chicago anticipates a possible National Guard deployment initiated by President Donald Trump, Democratic leaders are denouncing the plan and raising questions about its legality.

In a united front, local leaders said National Guard troops are not needed in Chicago.

ABC7 Chicago is now streaming 24/7. Click here to watch

Mayor Brandon Johnson and Governor Pritzker said there has been no communication from the White House.

President Trump has issued an executive order designed to form specialized National Guard units focused on managing civil disturbances and ensuring public safety, ready for swift nationwide deployment.

ABC7 data team analysis of Chicago police crime numbers shows overall violent crime and homicides at their lowest level since 2014.

SEE ALSO: Illinois politicians condemn Trump’s threat to deploy National Guard to Chicago

Governor Pritzker said National Guard deployment is unwarranted, while some Republicans believe it could make a difference.

“The president of the United States is doing this for theatrics,” stated the Democratic governor. “This is not because we’ve requested it. It is not because there is some justice that he is going to seek. It is because he wants to create chaos.”

“We should have done this a long time ago so that every neighborhood in Chicago enjoys the same safety and security that we have in the suburbs,” commented Republican state Rep. Martin McLaughlin.

According to constitutional experts, the president can only nationalize the guard in cases of rebellion, foreign invasion, or when it is impossible to enforce federal laws.

“So we’ve had guardsmen in the street before, but they were ordered in by the governor… and traditionally and the statute says the governor has to give the order, which makes sense because guardsmen usually respond to natural disasters like floods, hurricanes, tornadoes, and fires,” explained Chicago Kent College of Law professor Douglas William Godfrey.

Local officials have threatened to take legal action, but that like would come after deployment.

Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul said there challenges with filing a preemptive lawsuit

Copyright © 2025 WLS-TV. All Rights Reserved.

You May Also Like

Loyal dog fetches police to help owner who fell at Kansas home

Loyal Dog Leads Kansas Police to Owner After Fall at Home

A dog in Kansas is being praised by police after leading an…
Christa Pike's question after failed execution: witnesses

What Christa Pike Asked Witnesses After Her Failed Execution

Witnesses to Christa Pike’s failed execution said the convicted killer lifted her…
Organizers of Islamic wellness retreat attended by NYC first lady Rama Duwaji called for destruction of Israel in hateful social media posts

NYC First Lady Rama Duwaji Attended Retreat Run by Anti-Israel Organizers

The organization behind the upscale, Islamic-focused women’s retreat where New York City…
Father-in-law of trans NYT exec admitted killing him, worked 'in concert' with mother-in-law: docs

Father-in-Law Admits Killing Trans NYT Executive With Wife, Docs Say

A California man accused of fatally shooting his transgender son-in-law allegedly confessed…
Trump sends 3rd aircraft carrier to Middle East with 10K more troops — as he weighs post-midterm Iran assault

Trump Sends Third Aircraft Carrier, 10,000 More Troops to Middle East as Iran Strike Looms

WASHINGTON — The Pentagon is sending a third aircraft carrier to the…
Christa Pike's attorneys say botched execution was "cruel," "torturous" and "predictable"

Christa Pike’s Attorneys Call Botched Execution ‘Cruel,’ ‘Torturous’ and Predictable

Attorneys for Tennessee death row inmate Christa Pike are urging the governor…
Billion-dollar power link connecting Israel to Europe hits roadblock in bitter regional feud

Israel-Europe Billion-Dollar Power Link Stalled by Regional Feud

Cyprus Foreign Minister Constantinos Kombos has accused Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan…
Christa Pike likely has 'brain injury' after botched execution — here's what went wrong

Christa Pike May Have Brain Injury After Reported Botched Execution, Experts Say

Tennessee death-row inmate Christa Pike may have suffered brain damage after a…
Former Arizona fraternity leader sentenced to jail time after pledge dies in off-campus hazing

Former Arizona Fraternity Leader Sentenced to Jail After Pledge Dies in Off-Campus Hazing

A former Northern Arizona University fraternity leader was sentenced Wednesday to two…
President Trump to campaign with Bruce Blakeman in upstate New York

Trump to Campaign With Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman in Upstate New York

President Trump is set to hit the campaign trail in upstate New…
Kevin Reddington sets record straight after shock evidence claims at Lindsay Clancy hearing

Kevin Reddington Responds to Shock Evidence Claims at Lindsay Clancy Hearing

Lindsay Clancy’s attorney has clarified his courtroom remarks after appearing to reverse…
Ole Miss vape store clerks jailed, facing federal drug charges

Ole Miss Vape Store Clerks Jailed on Federal Drug Charges

Officials release 911 dispatch call in Ole Miss student death Ole Miss…