Little SCOTUS can do if Trump defies court
Share this @internewscast.com

Left: Donald Trump speaks at the annual Road to Majority conference in Washington, DC, in June 2024 (Allison Bailey/NurPhoto via AP). Right: Justice Amy Coney Barrett testifies before the Senate Judiciary Committee on the third day of her confirmation hearings on Capitol Hill on October 14, 2020 in Washington, D.C., (Jonathan Ernst-Pool/Getty Images).

During a recent conversation with The New York Times, U.S. Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett acknowledged that the Supreme Court would be powerless to enforce its decisions if the Trump administration chose to disregard rulings that clashed with the president’s political goals.

In a podcast interview with columnist Ross Douthat, she explained, “The court lacks the power of the purse and the power of the sword. We interpret the Constitution, draw on precedents, and tackle structural questions, utilizing the tools available to us.”

This admission followed a broader discussion about how much the justices consider the current legal and political climate when crafting their decisions. Douthat observed that it is quite conceivable for Trump or a future president to effectively say, “Interesting ruling, Justice Barrett. Good luck enforcing it.”

Barrett elaborated, “Just as the court considers the implications for institutional dynamics between current and future presidents, and the balance of power between the executive and legislative branches, these institutional concerns for the long term influence the court’s decisions on separation of powers, as they have always been intertwined with constitutional structure concerns.”

Barrett was nominated to the Supreme Court by President Donald Trump during his first term, following the passing of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, a figure celebrated as a liberal icon. Previously a clerk for Justice Antonin Scalia, Barrett was Trump’s third Supreme Court nominee to be confirmed.

In the discussion, Barrett reaffirmed her belief in “originalism,” a philosophy she shares with Scalia. She described it as the idea that the Constitution should be interpreted in line with the meaning its words held at the time of ratification, emphasizing that this meaning, when clear, is decisive.

While there are numerous interpretations of originalism, a key component of the Scalia-influenced theory espoused by Barrett is that of the “unitary executive,” meaning that the president “has to control the executive branch.”

As Barrett explained, the structural theory behind the unitary executive theory implies “strong presidential power over executive agencies.”

According to Barrett:

There has been a lot of debate and some new originalist scholarship debating right now whether indeed it has sound originalist credentials. But yes, it is one that has traditionally been associated with originalists.

You can see this in debates during the Great Depression and F.D.R. and the New Deal and the explosion of the administrative state. Back then, you had a debate about how much Congress could create administrative agencies that fell outside the president’s control.

And there were some who said: No, the executive branch has to be fully within the executive’s control. And others who favored the New Deal expansion of the administrative state who said: No, Congress can take agencies and make them independent of the president’s control.

Barrett and her five colleagues on the conservative bloc of the court are poised to take several steps toward turning this theory into reality during the court’s latest term, as the court appears likely to overturn longstanding precedents involving the president’s authority to remove members from independent federal agencies without cause as well as the authority to issue line-item vetos, which allow the president to reject particular provisions of a bill, such as refusing to spend money specifically allocated by Congress.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Suspect Caught Red-Handed in UPS Package Phone Theft Spree

In Gainesville, Florida, a man named Kenny Donnell Roberts, aged 42, found…

Man Attempts to Retract Guilty Plea in Jared Bridegan Case, Claims False Testimony Implicates Ex-Wife

In a dramatic turn of events, Henry Tenon, the alleged gunman implicated…

Shocking Crime: High School Wrestler Confesses to Murdering Mother and Hiding Her Body in Recycling Bin

Share A teenager in North Carolina is being charged as an adult…

Mother and Partner Arrested Following Domestic Disturbance Call Revealing Critically Injured Infant

In Virginia, authorities detained a woman and her partner following a domestic…

Tragic Turn: Man Discovered Dead After Tense Hotel Encounter Following Tinder Match, Authorities Report

Background: News footage of the area in Oakbrook Terrace, Ill., where Obaidulla…

States Secure Restraining Order Against Trump Administration’s Proposed Public Health Funding Cuts

President Donald Trump speaks during a lunch with African leaders in the…

Family of D4vd’s Celeste Rivas Challenges Subpoena in Unresolved Teen Homicide Investigation

The family of singer D4vd is reportedly contesting subpoenas from a Los…

Michigan Teen Jade Johnson Remains Missing After Over Two Years

Authorities in Michigan are actively seeking assistance in locating a Detroit teenager…

Police Secure Roadway Adjacent to Nancy Guthrie’s Residence

Law enforcement investigating the disappearance of US Today show host Savannah Guthrie’s…

Florida High School Brawl: Six Students Arrested After Violent Clash Leaves One Seriously Injured

In a troubling event that unfolded last Friday, six students from a…

Wisconsin Woman Discovered Deceased in Michigan; Boyfriend Apprehended in Minnesota

Authorities in Wisconsin have reported the tragic discovery of a missing woman,…

Teen Commits Random Murder During First Period, Returns to Class as if Nothing Happened

Inset: Ethan Goin (Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department). Background: The residential street…