Man arrested for attempted murder on Christmas in Fort White


Suspect Apprehended in Christmas Day Attempted Murder Case in Fort White

A 53-year-old man named Johnny McNutt has been taken into custody following an incident where he allegedly shot another individual in the head, as reported by the Columbia County Sheriff’s Office.

FORT WHITE, Fla. — On Christmas Day, law enforcement officers responded to an emergency call that led to the arrest of McNutt and the hospitalization of a victim, according to the Columbia County Sheriff’s Office.

The deputies were dispatched to a residence on Cullen Avenue, where they discovered a man suffering from a gunshot wound to the head.

While the sheriff’s office has not yet disclosed the victim’s identity or age, they have confirmed he is male. As of the latest update on Friday afternoon, the victim remains in critical condition at the hospital.

After being questioned by authorities, Johnny McNutt confessed to shooting the victim and was subsequently arrested.

The preliminary investigation by the sheriff’s office indicates that earlier in the day, McNutt and the victim were involved in a physical altercation. Following the confrontation, McNutt reportedly retrieved a firearm and approached the victim, who was seated in a chair, and fired a single shot to the head without warning.

McNutt is charged with attempted second-degree murder. 

First Coast News has requested the mugshot and arrest report for additional details.

Anyone with more information regarding this case is asked to contact investigators at 386-719-2005.

You May Also Like

Dem Rep. Pat Ryan silent over rival's claims he sends kids to DC school while calling NY home

Democratic Rep. Pat Ryan Silent on Rival’s Claim His Kids Attend D.C. School While He Calls New York Home

Republican congressional candidate Jackie Auringer is accusing Democratic Rep. Pat Ryan of…
Supreme Court won't hear case of students banned from wearing 'Let's Go Brandon' shirts

Supreme Court Declines Students’ ‘Let’s Go Brandon’ Shirt Ban Case

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear an appeal…
Trump approves firing squad for Fort Hood killer Nidal Hasan's execution after Pete Hegseth's recommendation

Trump Approves Firing Squad for Fort Hood Shooter Nidal Hasan’s Execution After Hegseth Recommendation

President Donald Trump has approved the use of a firing squad to…
US Marine arrested in Japan over suspected killing of woman as Tokyo lodges 'strong protest'

US Marine Arrested in Japan Over Suspected Woman’s Killing as Tokyo Protests

A US Marine stationed in Japan has been arrested on suspicion of…
Elderly cyclist, 71, killed after hitting dog, flipping over handlebars in Central Park

71-Year-Old Cyclist Dies After Hitting Dog, Flipping in Central Park

An elderly bicyclist died Monday morning after colliding with a dog running…
NYC teacher praised Oct. 7 mastermind in Park Slope Food Coop group chat: lawsuit

Suit: NYC Teacher Praised Oct. 7 Mastermind in Park Slope Coop Chat

A Brooklyn teacher wrote “Long live Yahya al-Sinwar” in a group chat,…
Supreme Court weighs whether to limit climate change suits in first case of new term

Supreme Court Considers Limits on Climate Change Lawsuits in First Case of New Term

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court opened its 2026-27 term Monday by hearing…
Mystery death at Russian plague lab triggers sweeping precautions as US watches closely

Mystery Death at Russian Plague Lab Prompts Precautions, US Watches

Rubio says US monitoring Russian plague scare Secretary of State Marco Rubio,…
Supreme Court wrestles with energy companies' bid to block major climate-change lawsuit

Supreme Court Weighs Energy Firms’ Bid to Block Major Climate Suit

Washington — The Supreme Court on Monday wrestled with a complex legal…
Family of California man who jumped from Carnival cruise ship speaks out

Family of California Man Who Jumped Overboard on Carnival Speaks Out

The family of a California father who went overboard from a Carnival…
Accused child rapist looks set to become small town's new police chief

Man Accused of Child Rape Poised to Become Small Town’s Police Chief

A Louisiana man facing allegations that he raped two children could become…
‘First Time in History’: Bessent Says Iran Faces Zero Oil Revenue This Week — Tehran Warns of Economic Crisis

Treasury Secretary Bessent Says Iran Faces Zero Oil Revenue This Week

Iran is on track to have no oil at sea and no…