Man arrested for attempted murder on Christmas in Fort White


A 53-year-old man named Johnny McNutt has been taken into custody following an incident where he allegedly shot another individual in the head, as reported by the Columbia County Sheriff’s Office.

FORT WHITE, Fla. — On Christmas Day, law enforcement officers responded to an emergency call that led to the arrest of McNutt and the hospitalization of a victim, according to the Columbia County Sheriff’s Office.

The deputies were dispatched to a residence on Cullen Avenue, where they discovered a man suffering from a gunshot wound to the head.

While the sheriff’s office has not yet disclosed the victim’s identity or age, they have confirmed he is male. As of the latest update on Friday afternoon, the victim remains in critical condition at the hospital.

After being questioned by authorities, Johnny McNutt confessed to shooting the victim and was subsequently arrested.

The preliminary investigation by the sheriff’s office indicates that earlier in the day, McNutt and the victim were involved in a physical altercation. Following the confrontation, McNutt reportedly retrieved a firearm and approached the victim, who was seated in a chair, and fired a single shot to the head without warning.

McNutt is charged with attempted second-degree murder. 

First Coast News has requested the mugshot and arrest report for additional details.

Anyone with more information regarding this case is asked to contact investigators at 386-719-2005.

You May Also Like
Sen. Lindsey Graham: "Let's try a diplomatic solution. I think it's going to fail."

Sen. Lindsey Graham Urges Diplomatic Push but Predicts It Will Fall Short

Washington — Sen. Lindsey Graham, a South Carolina Republican, said Sunday that…
South Dakota killer charged in death of girl, 14, after Kristi Noem freed him

South Dakota Man Freed by Kristi Noem Charged in Death of 14-Year-Old Girl

A man previously convicted of killing someone and later released on parole…
Paul Kueker ID'd as beloved dad of 2 who tragically plunged to death at Madison Square Garden concert

Paul Kueker Remembered as Beloved Father of Two After Fatal Fall at Madison Square Garden Concert

A 51-year-old rock music fan who died after falling during a Goose…
EXCLUSIVE: Meet the man Israel chose to be its first-ever ambassador to the Christian world

Israel’s First Ambassador to the Christian World: Meet the Man Behind the Historic Role

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government has created a new diplomatic post aimed…
Serena Williams returns to singles tennis at Wimbledon after accepting wild card invitation

Serena Williams to Make Singles Tennis Comeback at Wimbledon on Wild Card

June 21, 2026 / 3:52 PM EDT / AP Serena Williams is…
Rep. Jason Crow says he's worried "Americans are at risk" with Bill Pulte as acting DNI

Rep. Jason Crow Warns Americans Could Be at Risk Under Acting DNI Bill Pulte

Washington — Democratic Rep. Jason Crow of Colorado said Sunday that he…

Mamdani and House Candidates Draw Scrutiny Over Links to Activist Accused of Hamas Support

Mayor Zohran Mamdani and what critics have dubbed his “Hamas slate” of…

Top Latino Leaders Endorse Adriano Espaillat Over Chevalier in Contentious NYC House Race

A notable bloc of Latino elected officials in New York City released…
Iowa TV anchor gets choked up as he quits job and journalism — and slams his station

Iowa TV Anchor Breaks Down On-Air as He Quits Journalism and Blasts His Station

An Iowa television anchor became emotional during a live broadcast as he…
US military conducts strike on another vessel carrying alleged narco-traffickers, killing 2

US Military Strike on Suspected Drug-Trafficking Vessel Kills 2

The U.S. military said Sunday it carried out a deadly strike on…
Chicago families mark Father's Day with reflection, celebration, community events Sunday

Chicago Families Honor Father’s Day With Celebrations, Reflection and Community Events

CHICAGO (WLS) — Father’s Day was observed in a variety of ways…
Responders put out explosive blaze at fireworks stand in Oklahoma

Firefighters Extinguish Oklahoma Fireworks Stand Blaze After Explosions Reported

Firefighters in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, extinguished a fire at a fireworks stand…