Man sentenced for strangling Massachusetts college student to death with tank top in cold case killing

A man who strangled a Massachusetts college student with a tank top nearly 40 years ago received a life sentence on Thursday.

John Carey, age 66, was sentenced after being found guilty on March 3 of first-degree murder in the death of Claire Gravel, a student at Salem State University.

“Claire Gravel’s family has endured a four-decade-long wait for justice,” stated Essex County District Attorney Paul Tucker. “The prosecutors, along with our law enforcement partners, remained committed to Claire’s case. Today, we are gratified that the family has some answers and a measure of closure.”

At the time of his arrest for Gravel’s murder, Carey was already serving a sentence at the Massachusetts Correctional Institution in Concord for an unrelated offense from 2008.

Claire Gravel and an image of a cemetery in Salem.

Claire Gravel, who was only 20, was a Salem State student murdered in June 1986. John Carey received a life sentence for her murder on Thursday. (Getty Images; Essex County District Attorney)

The case dates back to June 29, 1986. Gravel was last seen alive between 1:30 and 1:45 a.m. after visiting Major Magleashes’ Pub in Salem with her softball team. She was dropped off at her Loring Avenue apartment in Salem shortly before she vanished.

Two days later, three workmen discovered her body in the woods.

Salem, Massachusetts graveyard

The cemetery on Bridge Street in Salem, Massachusetts, on March 30, 2011. (Yoon S. Byun/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

The killing went unsolved for decades until investigators linked Carey’s DNA to samples collected from a tank top, the district attorney’s office said.

A wooden gavel resting on a sound block in a courtroom.

Carey was serving time for an unrelated 2008 conviction when he was charged with Gravel’s murder. (iStock)

“What he left behind was his genetic blueprint on the murder weapon,” Deputy First Assistant District Attorney Kim Faitella told jurors during her closing arguments at Carey’s trial.

At the time of his arrest for Gravel’s death, Carey was already serving a prison sentence on charges related to trying to strangle another woman to death.

<!–>

–>

You May Also Like

The Essex Files: They Went to the Moon — Their Example Should Stay With Us

Apollo Astronauts’ Moonshot Courage Still Lights the Way

Reid Wiseman and Victor Glover are moving on from active astronaut duty,…
Lil Durk acquitted in LA murder-for-hire plot that targeted rival rapper Quando Rondo

Lil Durk Acquitted in LA Murder Plot Targeting Quando Rondo

Grammy-winning rapper Lil Durk has been acquitted in a federal murder-for-hire case…
Palm Desert wife, 65, accused of killing husband with flagpole

Palm Desert Woman, 65, Accused of Killing Husband With Flagpole

A 65-year-old California woman has been accused of fatally attacking her husband…
Two people found dead inside Glynn County apartment identified

Authorities Identify Two Found Dead in Glynn County Apartment

Glynn County Police said Celeste Cyan Morgan and Leon Anthony Myers were…
Van Jones: Trump 'Not In Sync with Where the American People Are'

Van Jones Says Trump Is Out of Sync With American Voters

Speaking Thursday on CNN’s “The Source,” political commentator Van Jones argued that…
Family killer North Carolina couple gunned down 2, wounded 2 'very nice people'

North Carolina Couple Among 2 Killed in Family Shooting That Injured 2 Others; Victims Remembered as ‘Very Nice People’

A neighbor of the North Carolina couple dubbed “Bonnie and Clyde” said…
Lil Durk verdict: Federal jury finds rapper not guilty of orchestrating 2022 murder-for-hire plot against Quando Rondo

Lil Durk Found Not Guilty in Federal Murder-for-Hire Case Targeting Quando Rondo

LOS ANGELES (KABC) — Rapper Lil Durk was cleared Friday by a…
DeSantis offers 'asylum' to holdout juror in Lindsay Clancy case

DeSantis Offers Florida Asylum to Lindsay Clancy Holdout Juror

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis weighed in Friday on the fallout from the…
Bill Maher rips media for weak stance on 'terrorism' label on 9/11 anniversary

Bill Maher Slams Media’s Soft Stance on 9/11 Terrorism Label

Comedian and talk-show host Bill Maher sharply criticized media organizations Friday night…
Arizona mom fights off coyote attacking her daughter with a flip-flop

Arizona Mom Saves Daughter From Coyote Attack With Flip-Flop

A mother and daughter in Surprise, Arizona, survived a frightening coyote attack…
Iranians looking to use captured US Navy drone sub as blueprint for their own lethal underwater weapons

Iran Eyes Captured US Navy Drone Sub for Underwater Weapons

Iran may soon be studying a piece of American underwater drone technology…
U.S. women beat Spain 76-66 to reach FIBA World Cup final, setting up Olympic rematch with France

U.S. Women Beat Spain 76-66, Reach FIBA World Cup Final vs. France

September 12, 2026 / 4:41 PM EDT / AP Breanna Stewart scored…