Lindsay Clancy attorney's appeal to Trump for pardon could hurt his credibility, expert says

A surprise plea from Lindsay Clancy’s criminal defense attorney for President Donald Trump to consider a pardon drew swift skepticism Tuesday, with legal analysts calling the request improbable and questioning the thinking behind it.

“There isn’t going to be a pardon for the simple reason there is no mechanism by law which would allow said pardon,” said Mark Bederow, a New York City criminal defense attorney who has been closely following the case.

Clancy, 36, a former nurse, was charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of her children: 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan. After the children died, she tried to take her own life and was left paralyzed from her injuries. On Friday, Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial after jurors remained deadlocked following a full week of deliberations.

“This is a very credible, skilled lawyer, and these comments, I think, lack credibility,” Bederow told News Outlet. “In some level, they lack seriousness because we know it, it’s not going to happen — so I don’t see the advantage of giving an interview where the only thing people are talking about is Lindsay Clancy’s attorney is seeking a pardon or intervention from the president of the United States in the Massachusetts state case.”

Lindsay Clancy with lawyer

Lindsay Clancy sits next to her defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, during her murder trial at Plymouth Superior Court on Aug. 11, 2026. (Jonathan Wiggs/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

Clancy’s attorney, Kevin Reddington, made the appeal during an interview Tuesday on ABC’s “Good Morning America,” saying his client’s “life was ruined” after she sought help from an inexperienced doctor who prescribed medication for postpartum depression. Asked what comes next for Clancy, Reddington turned his message directly to the president.

“I’d like to say that perhaps Donald Trump, who felt compelled to speak out about this case, may very well — Mr. President, I would hope that you would consider this young lady the type of the person she is, what she’s been through, and consider a pardon,” he said.

Kevin Reddington

Lindsay Clancy’s attorney, Kevin Reddington, speaks outside the courthouse after the third day of deliberations in her murder trial on Aug. 31, 2026. (David McGlynn for News Outlet)

In a separate interview with Massachusetts’ WBZ-TV, Reddington said that while he understands Trump has no grounds to issue a pardon on state charges, he felt that the president could potentially influence the case.

“He certainly has an awful lot of clout, and I’m sure that were he hypothetically to reach out to [Plymouth County District Attorney] Tim Cruz, they’re both Republicans, I don’t know, maybe that would be something that Tim would listen to and consider,” he said. “I think any type of help that we can get is helpful.”

President Donald Trump

Kevin Reddington appealed to President Donald Trump regarding Lindsay Clancy’s case. (Yuri Gripas/CNP/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

The goal could be to gain leverage in potential plea negotiations with Cruz’s office, said Josh Ritter, a Los Angeles-based attorney and Fox News contributor.

“I think he knows that this will publicly agitate this entire case and perhaps be beneficial to him in plea negotiations with the district attorney,” he told News Outlet. “I think he even feels that it benefits him even if Trump doesn’t entertain it — it creates more kind of political pressure for people in the state of Massachusetts who don’t support Trump.”

Three young Clancy children in pajamas sit together on a couch, the smiling baby resting against his older brother, with their sister beside them.

Callan, left, Dawson and Cora Clancy. The three children were killed at their Duxbury, Massachusetts, home in January 2023. (Lindsay Marie Clancy/Facebook)

Reddington, who has been praised by legal analysts for his work on the case, also told GMA he would be open to discussing a potential deal with prosecutors after Clancy’s trial over the deaths of her three young children ended with a deadlocked jury Friday.

He has also said he views his client, a former labor and delivery nurse, like a daughter.

“I think lawyers have to be careful getting too close to a client,” said Donna Rotunno, a Chicago-based criminal defense attorney and Fox News contributor. “It is very clear and admirable in some ways how invested Reddington is in Lindsay Clancy, however, if it starts to affect your professional judgment, it’s time to reevaluate.”

Reddington displaying a photo in court.

Kevin Reddington, an attorney for Lindsay Clancy, speaks to reporters outside Plymouth Superior Court on Sept. 1, 2026. (Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger via AP, Pool)

Reddington did not immediately respond to requests from News Outlet for comment.

The trial centered on whether Clancy was criminally responsible for her actions at the time she strangled each of them with exercise bands in 2023, and the defense argued she wasn’t due to postpartum psychosis.

Split of Donald Trump and Lindsay Clancy

President Donald Trump shares his thoughts on the Lindsay Clancy murder trial, which was ruled a mistrial on Friday, Sept. 4. (Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)

“I would hope that if the prosecution is going to try this again, they would find better experts with the proper expertise and who are willing, assuming there’s a basis to do so, [to] take the defense expert’s testimony and report and explain in English why it lacks any credibility whatsoever,” Bederow told News Outlet. “Because if they go forward, they can’t win unless the defense expert is entirely and thoroughly discredited, given the way the Massachusetts law puts the burden of proof on the prosecution.”

lindsay-clancy-ex-husband-patrick-clancy-new-wife-fox-news_005

Patrick Clancy and Rachel Danis hold hands as they walk through East Midtown in New York City, NY, Wednesday, Sept. 2, 2026.  (Elder Ordonez/InStar for News Outlet)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Ravens Sideline Marlon Humphrey for Saying Baltimore Best at 'Making Criminals'

Ravens Sideline Marlon Humphrey Over ‘Making Criminals’ Comment

Baltimore Ravens head coach Jesse Minter said Thursday that cornerback Marlon Humphrey…
Army delays controlled detonation of unstable bomb-making chemical in Iowa

Army Delays Controlled Detonation of Unstable Bomb-Making Chemical in Iowa

The U.S. Army has postponed Friday’s planned controlled detonation of five tons…
Second judge blocks Trump’s $1B Triumphal Arch project near Arlington: 'Rushed job'

Second Judge Blocks Trump’s $1B Triumphal Arch Near Arlington

A second federal judge moved Friday to halt President Trump’s proposal for…
Judge rejects Alex Murdaugh's push to toss murder indictment over blood and ammo claims

Judge Rejects Alex Murdaugh Bid to Toss Murder Case Over Evidence

Murdaugh defense claims grand jury heard misleading testimony Alex Murdaugh appeared in…
Iran regime's execution spree continues as twins face death penalty, decades in prison after alleged torture

Iran Execution Spree: Twins Face Death, Prison After Torture

Two Iranian twin sisters jailed for taking part in anti-government protests came…
Nearly 10,000 pounds of lead azide to be detonated at Iowa Army plant, causing lead dust plume into Illinois

Iowa Army Plant to Detonate 10,000 Pounds of Lead Azide, Sending Dust Toward Illinois

The U.S. Army has delayed the planned controlled detonation of nearly 10,000…
Actress, tech exec tapped for Nithya Raman’s mayoral transition team

Actress, Tech Executive Join Nithya Raman’s Mayoral Transition Team

Los Angeles Mayor-elect Nithya Raman is turning to prominent figures from Hollywood,…
What autopsy results reveal about Fiona the hippo’s death

Fiona the Hippo’s Autopsy Reveals Cause of Death

An autopsy found that the knitted hat that killed Fiona the hippo…
Woman allegedly torments California family claiming to be toddler who vanished in 1984, refuses basic DNA test

Woman Allegedly Torments Family Claiming Missing 1984 Toddler

Four decades after their 3-year-old daughter disappeared, a Southern California family says…
Texas inmate's execution takes over an hour as prison staff struggle to find suitable veins

Texas Execution Delayed Over an Hour as Staff Struggle to Find Veins

A Texas inmate’s execution took more than an hour Thursday after prison…
Anthropic's 7 co-founders are worth about $20 billion each in record IPO payday. Here's who they are.

Anthropic’s 7 Co-Founders Become $20 Billion Each Richer in Record IPO: Who They Are

Anthropic’s seven co-founders are poised for extraordinary financial windfalls. Based on their…
USDA boss Brooke Rollins barred from sending Christian messages to federal workers

USDA Secretary Brooke Rollins Barred From Sending Christian Messages to Federal Workers

A federal judge on Thursday ordered Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to stop…