She once wore a sparkling diamond engagement ring and changed her name while preparing to marry one of America’s most notorious family killers.
Earlier this year, Our News Outlet reported that former Ohio real estate agent Lizzie Henderson, 39, and Chris Watts, 41, were planning to marry while he served five consecutive life sentences at a maximum-security prison in Wisconsin. Watts was convicted of murdering his pregnant wife and their two young daughters in 2018.
Henderson moved from Ohio and visited Watts dozens of times last year, including on Christmas Day, when the pair were seen kissing and telling each other, “I love you.”
But only weeks after Our News Outlet brought their relationship to public attention, Watts cut contact with Henderson, reportedly after pressure from his mother, Cindy Watts, who opposed the marriage.
Since the relationship ended, claims have also emerged that Watts pursued sexual relationships with male inmates.
Now, hundreds of miles from her home state, Our News Outlet has located Henderson working at a grocery store in Racine, Wisconsin. The customer service job is about a two-hour drive from Watts’ prison, Dodge Correctional Institution.
The engagement ring has disappeared. In its place, a band-shaped tattoo now circles her left ring finger.
Henderson greeted our reporter with a hug and said she was “doing good,” but her friendly demeanor changed when the conversation turned to Watts.
“A lot of stuff happened after,” she said, referring to the publication of their engagement. She appeared reluctant to provide details, adding, “There is so much more to it.”
Our News Outlet located Henderson at a grocery store in Racine, Wisconsin, where she works at the customer service counter about two hours from Dodge Correctional Institution
Henderson greeted our reporter with a hug and said she was “doing good,” but became less comfortable when asked about Watts
The ring visible on her finger over the summer was gone, replaced by a band tattoo with what appeared to be a diamond design
“I don’t want to talk about anything related to that because it put me in a really bad light,” she said.
At points during the conversation, Henderson’s answers were difficult to follow.
When asked whether she remained in contact with Watts, she replied, “The reason why I do anything I do is for God—100 percent—no matter who it is.”
She appeared to suggest that she still felt compassion for the convicted killer.
“I am always going to do the right thing if anybody needs me in a spiritual capacity, because at the end of the day, I need God to see my heart… 100 percent. If I can help someone who is ever in need.”
Henderson said the criticism she faced after being identified as Watts’ fiancée had been more frightening than becoming engaged to an imprisoned killer responsible for the deaths of four family members.
“Talking to someone about God was not a danger to me—what happened was a danger to me,” she said.
“The kind of things I received would have frightened the average person. My belief in God is that strong.”
She also indicated that the publicity surrounding the relationship had caused divisions within her family.
In a phone interview with Our News Outlet in August, Henderson described the Watts murders as “something harsh for anyone to experience.”
This week, she objected to the suggestion that her comments had shown a lack of empathy.
“I am very aware; I just don’t want to offend anybody,” she said, arguing that her remarks had been interpreted in a way she did not intend.
Henderson, pictured in August, was romantically involved with Watts earlier this year before he ended the relationship
Watts was having an affair with coworker Nichol Kessinger when he killed his family in August 2018
FIND OUT MORE: Inside Ariana Grande’s Quiet New Life Away From the Spotlight
Records indicate that Henderson worked as a real estate agent in Ohio before moving to Wisconsin in 2024.
She first lived in Sturtevant, a small town about one hour and 43 minutes from Dodge Correctional, before moving to the Concord Apartments complex in Racine in late August 2025.
Prison records show that she made at least 20 additional visits to Watts that year.
By New Year’s Day, however, Henderson had been evicted from the Concord Apartments, according to the rental company’s attorney. Her current address is unclear.
Henderson continues to hold an active real estate license with a prominent nationwide company in Wisconsin.
However, when Our News Outlet visited the company’s Racine offices, employees could not confirm that she worked there. One employee said records for former staff members typically extend back only about six months.
During our interview last week, Henderson strongly denied that she had moved her life to Wisconsin for Watts.
“I chose to work here; I did not come out here for Chris,” she said. “I got a promotion to come out here.” She did not provide further details.
Our News Outlet understands that Henderson moved to Wisconsin with her elderly mother, whom she helps care for.
Asked whether the publicity had affected her grocery store job, she said it had not.
“I am still cordial with everyone. It made me realize some things are not that important.”
Her coworkers at the grocery chain offered a similar assessment.
One male colleague affectionately called her “customer service Lizzie” and described her as someone who would “hug a guy if you need it.”
Watts killed his wife, Shanann, and their two young daughters before presenting himself to police and local media as a concerned husband
In 2020, Watts was disciplined after guards found underwear, petroleum jelly, baby oil and other personal items inside fellow inmate Dylan Tallman’s cell, pictured
A prison employee said Watts was recently separated from another inmate amid suspicions of an “inappropriate” relationship
In both interviews with Our News Outlet, Henderson repeatedly cited God as the force guiding her work and personal life.
An eyewitness said Watts was holding a Bible while speaking with Henderson during one prison visit. When asked over the summer how their relationship began, Henderson replied, “How things began is between me, him and God.”
But Cherlyn Cadle, Watts’ most prolific prison pen pal, contends that his religious faith is merely a façade.
“He’s a sex addict who uses religion as his front,” said Cadle, a true-crime author who has corresponded with Watts for years and written a book about him.
“He’s pretty gross, and the more that comes out about him, the uglier the things he does become.”
Last week, Our News Outlet reported that Watts had pursued relationships with male inmates while courting Henderson and writing to other women, asking them to send “risqué” photographs.
A prison employee claimed that Watts was recently separated from another inmate because of suspicions about an “inappropriate” relationship. The employee also described younger men competing for Watts’ attention.
According to the employee, Watts gives potential suitors generous gifts purchased through the prison commissary. A former inmate told Our News Outlet that Watts writes lengthy letters to men who are often younger than him.
The former prisoner characterized his own relationship with Watts as “intimate.”
“We were as close as two men can be,” he said. “I’m not saying that nothing happened, but not everything that you probably think.”