Donald Trump emerged as the winner of the apparent “handshake battle” after greeting Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping on camera in China, according to a body language expert.
Judi James described the US president’s performance as a “comprehensive slam-dunk,” pointing to what she interpreted as a series of subtle power and status signals during his exchanges with Mr Putin.
The Russian leader approached Mr Trump and warmly shook his hand, with the pair exchanging pleasantries before joining the other leaders for a group photograph.
However, Ms James said Mr Trump remained the dominant figure ahead of the welcome banquet for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (Apec) summit in Shenzhen.
She told Our News Outlet: “When it comes to the unspoken power and status signals between Trump and Putin, this appears to be a comprehensive victory for Trump.
“To begin with, he is the final leader to arrive and be welcomed by Xi, leaving Putin waiting nearby for his own moment. Having to wait can suggest a weaker position in the hierarchy.
“Trump enters like a fully billowing galleon, immediately taking charge and even bending the usual hosting etiquette by initiating the handshake with Xi. He extends his hand, palm facing upwards, with his thumb raised—a gesture that conveys confidence.”
Ms James noted that the host would generally be expected to begin the handshake, but said Mr Trump’s “hand is extended from roughly six feet away, giving Xi no opportunity to make the first move”.
Xi Jinping stands as Donald Trump shakes hands with Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen today
US President Donald Trump greets Russian President Vladimir Putin with a handshake
The leaders at the welcome banquet at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (Apec) summit
Mr Trump then delivered what Ms James called a “firm and unmistakable” handshake with Xi, presenting a notably friendlier image than during his greeting with Putin.
She said: “Trump draws Xi’s hand toward his own body and reaches for the Chinese president’s elbow, adding an emotional gesture that suggests greater closeness.
“He taps Xi’s elbow twice while maintaining strong eye contact and tilting his head to communicate warmth. As he turns toward the cameras with a gracious smile, he gives the elbow another pat.”
Ms James continued: “The confusion that follows, as Trump seems ready to move away while knowing Putin is waiting for the symbolic ‘Three Leaders’ photograph, is almost comical.
“Trump even looks to his right, appearing to disregard Putin standing on his left. That apparent act of ignoring the Russian president gives the exchange the character of a status-lowering ritual.
“When Trump finally appears to notice Putin, he adopts his familiar ‘bullfrog smile’, with a furrowed chin that can look both friendly and slightly patronising.
CONTINUE READING: Devon Tap Water May Be Rationed Under Plans to Avert Day Zero
“Trump’s most significant power gesture comes next. He remains rooted to the spot, making Putin approach him for the greeting.
“He does not step forward or make any effort to meet Putin halfway. Instead, the Russian president has to come all the way toward him, which reads as a deliberate display of control.”
Ms James said Mr Trump did not initiate the handshake at that stage. Rather, she argued, he “makes Putin effectively request the handshake by extending his own hand,” and the contact lacked the same sense of warmth and closeness seen in the greeting with Xi.
Donald Trump puts his hand behind Vladimir Putin as they attend the photo session today
China’s President Xi Jinping welcomes US President Donald Trump in Shenzhen today
Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin pose for a group photo with other leaders today
She added: “Rather than drawing Putin closer, Trump extends his arm and pats the Russian leader’s upper arm from an unusually distant position. His gaze also appears focused on Putin’s hand rather than meeting his eyes during the handshake.
“Putin responds with a pat and squeeze of Trump’s upper arm, but Trump then seems to direct him toward the area prepared for the photograph. That act of guiding Putin reinforces the impression that Trump is controlling the encounter.”
During the official photo line-up, Ms James said Mr Trump positioned himself beside Xi, while Putin stood farther along the row on the other side of Xi’s wife and appeared to converse with someone else.
She said: “Putin seems to have been pushed to the sidelines, and that symbolic reduction in status is reinforced when Trump turns away and walks off with Xi, leaving the Russian leader behind them.”
The meeting took place against the backdrop of the ongoing war and marked the first face-to-face encounter between Mr Trump and Mr Putin since their Russia-US summit in Alaska in August last year.
Earlier in the day, President Xi extended the rare courtesy of personally welcoming Mr Trump on the runway when the US leader arrived at Shenzhen Airport aboard Air Force One.
Mr Trump saluted while standing beside Xi on a red carpet surrounded by flag-waving crowds and people holding pom-poms, before the two presidents shook hands.
The US president has said he intends to discuss nuclear arms controls with Xi and Putin, as well as efforts to bring the war in Ukraine to an end.
Despite comparisons with the historic February 1945 Yalta summit involving the United States, Britain and the Soviet Union, analysts do not anticipate major breakthroughs on the most contentious issues.
At Yalta, held shortly before the end of the Second World War, the leaders agreed on plans for the postwar division and political organisation of Europe.