A New Hampshire family court judge is facing misconduct charges after allegedly humiliating a mother during a guardianship proceeding.
Judge Todd Prevett, who sits on the New Hampshire 9th Circuit Court in Milford, is accused of violating six judicial conduct rules. The Judicial Conduct Committee (JCC) filed its formal statement of charges on October 15.
According to JCC documents, Prevett rejected a mother’s petition to regain her parental rights.
At a court hearing, the judge referred to ‘five criminal cases against the mother that were more than ten years old’ in New Hampshire and Massachusetts as part of what the committee described as a ‘highly critical assessment.’
The JCC said Prevett independently examined the woman’s criminal record using information that had not been introduced as evidence during the hearing.
The documents also stated that he failed to explain how those decades-old cases were relevant to the mother’s effort to reestablish contact with her child.
In his ruling, Prevett evaluated the mother’s ‘tone, demeanor, and presentation’ while she testified. He reportedly described her as displaying an ‘unabashed sense of entitlement in expecting to show up after a 10-year absence,’ according to the charges.
The JCC said the court’s language conveyed ‘hostility’ and ‘disdain’ toward the mother, and alleged that Prevett did not carry out his judicial responsibilities fairly, impartially and without bias.
Judge Todd Prevett of the New Hampshire 9th Circuit Court faces allegations that he violated six judicial conduct rules after the Judicial Conduct Committee filed charges against him on October 15
JCC documents say Prevett rejected a mother’s request to restore her parental rights during a December 2024 hearing. Pictured: the New Hampshire 9th Circuit Court in Milford
The mother appealed the decision, and in July 2025 the New Hampshire Supreme Court removed Prevett from the matter, ordering that it ‘be considered by a different circuit court judge.’
ALSO READ: Animal Rights Activist Jailed Over False Rodeo Shooting Report
The ruling was subsequently overturned. In its decision, the Supreme Court questioned whether Prevett had handled the case in a fair, impartial and unbiased manner.
Our News Outlet has contacted the New Hampshire 9th Circuit Court for comment on Prevett’s behalf.
The Supreme Court wrote: ‘An objective, disinterested observer, fully informed of the facts, would have significant doubt that justice would be done in this case.’
Prevett submitted his own explanations and reasoning for the ruling to the JCC in August 2025. The committee later opened its investigation into his conduct.
Carol Erskine, a retired Massachusetts juvenile court judge, told News 9 that the decision to overturn the ruling and remove Prevett from the case was highly unusual.
‘It’s exceptionally rare for an appellate decision from a state Supreme Court to overturn a judge with an order to assign a new judge based on bias and [partiality],’ Erskine told the outlet.
‘The JCC complaint is exceptionally well laid out, and I think it will be difficult for the judge to survive the process without some significant level of discipline if the allegations are supported,’ Erskine added.
Prevett was given 30 days to respond to the allegations, with November 15 set as the deadline.
Carol Erskine, left, a retired Massachusetts juvenile court judge, described the overturned ruling as unusual in an interview with News 9. Source: Carolerskine.com
Our News Outlet has contacted the Judicial Conduct Committee to confirm whether Prevett submitted a response to the formal charges.
Prevett previously faced allegations that he misused his judicial position to request a ‘favor’ and gain entry to a closed courthouse so he could file documents in his own guardianship case in 2024.
He acknowledged the allegations and was reprimanded. News 9 reported that he was also ordered to receive mentoring from a senior circuit court judge.
SEE ALSO: Sydney mum Sammi reunites with cruise lover after fiancée reveal