A Florida man allegedly mailed a peanut butter-smeared envelope to a woman with a severe peanut allergy, triggering a near-fatal medical emergency and leaving her distressed for hours.
Joseph Gerard Cancellare, 68, was arrested on November 13 in Plantation, roughly 30 miles north of Miami. He is accused of sending the woman a card coated with peanut butter.
According to a probable cause affidavit filed November 13 in Broward County and reviewed by Our News Outlet, the woman returned from work on August 14, 2025, and noticed a blue envelope after collecting her mail. She said it appeared greasy and bore handwriting she did not recognize.
The envelope was addressed to the woman, whose name was redacted in the affidavit, and had been sent from an address in Springs, according to the filing.
When she opened it, she allegedly found peanut butter “spread across the inside of the card.”
She immediately recognized the substance, dropped the envelope and rushed inside to wash her hands, the affidavit said.
The woman allegedly developed hives on both arms and experienced tingling in both limbs for six hours, according to investigators.
The legal filing alleges that Cancellare “knew” peanut butter “could be deadly” for the woman. He faces charges of aggravated battery and culpable negligence.
Joseph Gerard Cancellare, 68, was arrested on November 13 and charged with aggravated battery and culpable negligence
A probable cause affidavit filed November 13 and reviewed by Our News Outlet said Cancellare bought two “Forever” stamps used on the envelope at the Davie Post Office, pictured
The affidavit described the victim’s allergy as “severe and widely known amongst her friends and family.”
She reported the incident to Plantation authorities that day. Because the card was allegedly sent through the US Postal Service, police also contacted a postal inspector.
Investigators allegedly traced Cancellare after determining that the two “Forever” stamps in the envelope’s upper-right corner had been purchased from a self-service kiosk at the Davie Post Office. The kiosk captured an image of the purchaser.
The VISA card used to purchase the stamps was also determined to belong to Cancellare, according to the affidavit.
Investigators later interviewed a woman who said she personally knew both Cancellare and the victim, the filing said.
Although portions of the seven-page affidavit were redacted, the woman told authorities that Cancellare had been “contentious” over a divorce, according to the document. The filing provided no further details.
She also told investigators that Cancellare “would absolutely know” about the victim’s allergy because the couples had gone to dinner together countless times.
The victim had to remain vigilant to avoid accidental contact with peanuts, the woman said, according to the affidavit.
Cancellare allegedly used the US Postal Service to mail the envelope covered in peanut butter; USPS vehicles are shown in a file photo
The victim allegedly told investigators that contact with peanuts could be fatal without immediate medical treatment; peanut butter is shown being spread in a file photo
On September 15 of that year, the victim allegedly told police how carefully she had to avoid exposure to peanuts.
She said she could not come into contact with peanuts, peanut oil or items contaminated through cross-contact, the affidavit stated.
Her reaction could be so severe that “without immediate medical intervention she could die,” she told authorities, according to the filing.
The envelope incident allegedly caused her “extreme distress,” which remained visible when she gave her statement more than a year later, according to the affidavit. She also told police she wanted to pursue charges.
The affidavit said Cancellare had exposed “countless other people to peanut butter,” citing the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America’s estimate that about 22 million people in the United States have food allergies.
Cancellare’s bond was set at $20,000—$10,000 for each charge—following his arrest in the 1000 block of NW 86th Avenue.
He posted bond on Monday, according to Broward County court records reviewed by Our News Outlet. As of Tuesday afternoon, no subsequent court date had been scheduled.
Our News Outlet has contacted the Plantation Police Department and the USPS seeking additional comment.
Broward County court records reviewed by Our News Outlet did not identify an attorney representing Cancellare.