A Wisconsin man who allegedly told investigators that his wife died in a laundry-room accident nearly two years ago has been charged with her murder after detectives uncovered suspicious online searches, erased text messages and evidence of an alleged affair.
Benjamin Carpenter, 45, was arrested Tuesday and charged with first-degree intentional homicide in the death of Erica Carpenter, 40. Her body was found at the couple’s West Allis, Wisconsin, home on October 13, 2024.
Erica’s parents, Debra and Michael Clarenbach, say the years since their daughter’s death have been marked by grief and uncertainty.
The couple had begun trying to rebuild their lives after losing their only child when the criminal charges reopened their pain. “Erica was one of a kind,” Debra said.
Now, more than two years after her death, the family says it is facing another devastating chapter.
“It was like the wounds were starting to heal, and they ripped the bandage off again,” Michael Clarenbach said.
For months, Carpenter reportedly maintained that Erica had suffered a terrible fall on the stairs.
But a lengthy investigation into the couple’s marriage produced a far more troubling account, including allegations of infidelity, unexplained powder in Erica’s drinking water and internet searches made shortly before her death.
Benjamin Carpenter, 45, was arrested Tuesday and charged with first-degree intentional homicide in connection with the death of his wife, Erica Carpenter, 40
Police went to a West Allis home to conduct a welfare check on Erica Carpenter. Prosecutors said officers found the 40-year-old bleeding from the head and turning blue while her husband, Benjamin Carpenter, performed CPR
Prosecutors said Carpenter told officers that his wife had felt ill and collapsed while the pair were doing laundry in the basement. He said he tried to carry her upstairs, then slipped and fell with her after she struck her head
According to the criminal complaint, emergency responders were called to the home on the night of October 13, 2024, after reports that a woman had fallen and was bleeding from the head.
When officers arrived, they found Carpenter performing CPR on Erica. Her face was reportedly “very blue.”
Carpenter allegedly told police that Erica had not felt well during the day and had spent much of the time sleeping.
He said the couple had been doing laundry when she suddenly collapsed.
The fall was allegedly loud enough to wake the couple’s son, who was upstairs, Carpenter told investigators.
He initially said Erica had hit her head “mildly hard” on the carpet. Instead of immediately calling 911, however, he allegedly tried to carry her upstairs while she was unconscious.
Carpenter then claimed he lost his footing on the staircase, sending both of them tumbling down the steps. Erica allegedly struck her head on a cinder block wall.
Erica was taken to a hospital, where she was pronounced dead at 5:14 a.m. on October 14.
As the investigation continued, police said they learned Carpenter had allegedly been involved with another woman and had planned to tell Erica about the relationship, but she died before that conversation took place
Police said deleted messages showed Erica had questioned her husband about putting powder into her drinks
When detectives asked Carpenter to describe the state of his marriage, he reportedly answered: “It’s (short pause) good.”
He agreed to searches of his three mobile phones and supplied investigators with the passcodes.
Asked if he had deleted anything from the devices during the previous 24 hours, Carpenter allegedly said he had not.
Investigators later found material on the phones that became a key part of the case.
Police began looking more closely at Carpenter’s personal life after a witness contacted them on October 22 and identified a woman, referred to as AMV, who allegedly had been having an affair with him.
According to the witness, AMV believed Carpenter was preparing to divorce Erica and had allegedly promised to ask his wife for a divorce the weekend she died.
Investigators were also told that Carpenter stayed overnight at AMV’s home several days after Erica’s death and discussed introducing her to his son.
At a pub-crawl fundraiser held about a month later in Erica’s memory, surveillance footage allegedly showed Carpenter and AMV acting as a couple.
DON’T MISS: US Military Restores Two-Carrier Presence in Middle East
After Erica Carpenter’s death became known among their social circles, police said a witness came forward on October 22, 2024. The witness said a woman identified as “AMV” had described an affair with Benjamin Carpenter and believed he was in the process of divorcing Erica
A second witness, who had known Carpenter since high school and trained with him in mixed martial arts, allegedly told police that Carpenter had acknowledged the affair.
That witness said Carpenter claimed he had been planning to divorce Erica after she learned about the relationship.
The case took another turn when detectives discovered that Carpenter had received between $220,000 and $230,000 from Erica’s life insurance policy.
A separate joint policy valued at $350,000 had not yet been paid, the complaint stated.
During an interview in December 2024, Carpenter reportedly admitted to the affair but said AMV had refused to pursue a relationship until he was divorced.
Investigators were particularly alarmed by an alleged Google search Carpenter made in September 2024, less than a month before Erica’s death: “Watching someone you love die.”
On October 13, the day Erica died, he allegedly searched: “can I crush pills and take them in water.”
A later search on November 6 directed investigators to a Facebook image stating: “The hardest thing in the world is watching someone you love slowly die right in front of you.”
AMV reportedly told a witness that Benjamin Carpenter had promised to ask Erica Carpenter for a divorce during the same weekend Erica died
Police also found deleted text messages, contradicting Carpenter’s alleged claim that he had not erased anything from his phones.
Some of the most troubling messages were reportedly exchanged by the couple in the weeks before Erica’s death.
On September 18, Erica allegedly confronted Carpenter about an unusual substance she had noticed in her drinking water.
“And what the f*** have you been doing to my water the past few days?!?!?” she reportedly wrote.
She added that she had found “powdery s***” in the water on at least two occasions.
Carpenter allegedly responded that he had been mixing Liquid I.V. into the water for himself and said it was his drink.
An autopsy raised additional questions. Erica had hydrocodone in her system despite having no prescription for the drug, and investigators said it could not be excluded as a possible factor in her death.
Her official cause of death was listed as undetermined. The medical examiner also noted blunt-force injuries to her neck and petechial hemorrhaging, findings that can be linked to asphyxia.
Toxicology testing found insomnia medication and hydrocodone in her system. Although her cause of death was classified as undetermined, the deputy chief medical examiner said asphyxia could not be ruled out and noted a blunt-force injury to her neck
When the medical examiner asked Carpenter to explain how he had held Erica during the alleged fall, his account reportedly did not explain why her heart had stopped.
In May 2025, police were called to the same residence after AMV accused Carpenter of placing his hand around her neck and strangling her.
She allegedly told the Uber driver who came to collect her that Carpenter would be responsible if she died, then showed the driver his contact information on her phone.
Investigators interviewed the couple’s son in October 2025. He reportedly recalled hearing a scream followed by a loud “thud” on the night Erica died.
The boy also told police that his father removed photographs of Erica from the home about four weeks after her death. AMV allegedly moved into the property two or three months later.
Carpenter is being held without bond at the Milwaukee County Jail. His initial court appearance was scheduled for Wednesday.
Michael Clarenbach said the information uncovered during the investigation has transformed the family’s view of the man they once believed they knew.
“Completely blindsided,” he said. “That it seemed like Ben had a dark side that we didn’t know about.”
Our News Outlet has contacted Michael and Debra for comment.