Susan Smith, the South Carolina mother convicted of drowning her two young sons, is seeking parole once again, while the children’s father, her former husband, is urging officials to keep her in prison.
Smith, now 55, received a life sentence in 1995 for the deaths of 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander. In 1994, she secured the boys in their car and allowed the vehicle to roll into John D. Long Lake.
The case drew worldwide attention after Smith spent nine days claiming that a Black carjacker had taken her children. She appeared on television pleading for their safe return before eventually admitting the truth.
Prosecutors have maintained that Smith killed the boys after Tom Findlay, the wealthy son of her employer, ended their relationship and told her he did not want to be with a woman who had children.
During Thursday’s hearing before South Carolina’s Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services, Smith appeared by video and asked the board to release her.
She rejected the idea that the murders were driven by the breakup, saying instead that she was experiencing a serious mental health crisis at the time.
‘This did not happen because of a man; that is simply not true. I would never have hurt Michael and Alex for that reason,’ Smith told the board.
David Smith, the boys’ father and Susan’s former husband, wore a pin bearing photographs of his sons. Fighting back tears, he told the board that she had intentionally killed the children and pleaded for her parole request to be rejected.
Susan Smith, 55, said during her parole hearing that the murders were not committed because of a man
She received a life sentence for the 1994 drownings of 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex
David Smith has vowed to oppose his former wife’s release at every future parole hearing
‘The fact that 32 years have passed does not erase what she did to Michael and Alex. She acted deliberately. It was not an accident or a momentary mistake; she made the decision to do it,’ David said.
‘I believe granting her parole would be a profound injustice to Michael and Alex. I ask you to consider their father’s pain and the heartbreak that remains. Is 32 years enough for what she did to them? Please, do not grant her parole.’
The latest hearing comes weeks after Our News Outlet reported that Smith, who has been disciplined twice for having sex with male employees in prison, had also developed a romantic relationship with a female inmate.
Smith is serving her sentence at Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood. She reportedly spends hours speaking by phone with men who are romantically interested in her and sends or receives approximately 15 to 20 text messages each day.
At Smith’s 2024 parole hearing, David promised to continue opposing her release for as long as necessary. ‘She should never get out,’ he told the board.
‘It is not enough,’ he said. ‘I am asking you to deny her parole today and in the future, but especially today.’
Smith’s crimes shocked the United States in 1994. In the days after the boys disappeared, she insisted that a Black man had carjacked her and driven away with them.
ALSO READ: Looksmaxxing Influencer Clavicular Accused of Teen Age Lie Before Assault
Smith was 22 when she began a relationship with Tom Findlay, the son of her employer at Conso Products, a company that manufactured home décor trim.
David Smith wore a pin featuring his sons’ photographs as he tearfully urged the parole board to keep Susan Smith imprisoned
Smith was 22 when she was having an affair with Tom Findlay, the son of her boss at Conso Products
The relationship ended after Findlay saw Smith kiss and touch another man at a nude hot-tub gathering in 1994. He later wrote that he could not continue dating a woman with children. Findlay is now 56.
‘Susan, I could really fall for you,’ Findlay wrote. ‘You have many qualities that draw me to you, and I think you are a wonderful person.’
‘But as I have said before, there are parts of your life that do not work for me, and I am referring to your children. I am sure they are good kids, but that would not change how I feel. The truth is, I do not want children.’
One week later, Smith drove her burgundy Mazda to the lake. She allowed the car to roll down a boat ramp with Michael and 14-month-old Alex still strapped into their seats.
While maintaining that she had been carjacked, Smith and David appeared on television for nine days, appealing to the supposed kidnapper to bring their sons home.
Smith ultimately confessed. A jury convicted her of two counts of first-degree murder but declined to impose the death penalty.
Under South Carolina law at the time, Smith became eligible to seek parole after 30 years in prison. If denied, she can apply again every two years. The parole board unanimously rejected her request in 2024.
Our News Outlet has also reported that Smith engaged in phone sex with a man half her age while incarcerated. He was reportedly one of at least seven men with whom she has had alleged relationships during her imprisonment.
Susan Smith, now 55, was convicted in 1995 of killing her two sons
At the 2024 hearing, David Smith said he would return each time she sought parole and declared: ‘She should never get out’
At her previous parole hearing, Smith acknowledged the severity of her actions.
‘I know what I did was horrible, and I would give anything to undo it,’ she said.
‘God plays a major role in my life. He has forgiven me, and I ask you to show me that same mercy.’
This is a developing story…