When an image of comedian Bill Burr appeared behind Billy Corgan during a November 2024 podcast interview, the Smashing Pumpkins frontman had plenty of reason to laugh. Fans had spent years remarking on the resemblance between the two bald stars.
Then Corgan revealed a far more startling possibility: Burr could be his half-brother.
Corgan, 59, said the idea was first raised by his stepmother more than a decade earlier. She told him that his father, a traveling musician, may have fathered Burr while touring in the 1960s.
The revelation sent fans searching for evidence. Some compared photographs of the two men, while others watched footage of Corgan’s late father and argued that he, rather than Corgan, bore a striking resemblance to Burr.
Burr has said little publicly about the possibility. Corgan, although he sees his father’s features in the comedian, has also acknowledged that he doubts they are related.
Now, the woman who first introduced the theory has spoken publicly about it. In an exclusive interview with Our News Outlet, Penny Andersen recalled what Corgan’s father allegedly told her about a secret son named Bill.
‘Billy’s dad did tell me all those things, that is true,’ Andersen, Corgan’s stepmother, said when asked about his claims.
Smashing Pumpkins frontman Billy Corgan said his father fathered ‘multiple’ children while working as a traveling musician in the 1960s, and that comedian Bill Burr could be one of them
Stand-up comedian Bill Burr has said little about the possibility that he is related to Corgan
After Andersen separated from Corgan’s father in 1978, she raised Corgan from the age of 11, along with his brother Rick and half-brother Jesse. Corgan’s mother had been absent from his life for years.
Andersen, now 79, first shared her theory about a secret half-brother with Corgan during a family birthday gathering.
She told him that she believed his father, who had played guitar on the road with a band called The Puppets during the 1960s, may have fathered as many as a dozen children outside marriage.
She then asked whether Corgan had ever heard of Bill Burr.
Corgan did not recognize the name, but Andersen suggested the comedian ‘might be one of the children that your father sired in his days being a traveling musician.’
Corgan Sr was based in Chicago during the 1960s, playing guitar with the Midwest group The Puppets and regularly touring the country with other acts. In the fall of 1967, around the time Burr would have been conceived, Burr’s mother was living in the Boston area, almost 1,000 miles from Chicago.
During the 1970s, Corgan Sr played guitar with Crystal, traveling south from Chicago for performances as far away as Florida.
Looking back on that conversation with Corgan, Andersen recalled what his father had supposedly told her privately.
‘His dad told me about this son of his named Bill,’ Andersen, a former flight attendant who later became a family therapist, told Our News Outlet.
‘There is an incredible similarity between the two of them, nobody can deny that.’
Our News Outlet has contacted Corgan and Burr for comment.
William Corgan Sr played guitar with the Midwest band The Puppets in the 1960s and regularly toured the country with other acts (source: Facebook/Billy Corgan)
Corgan and Burr met for the first time on Howie Mandel’s podcast
Penny Andersen, now 79, first raised the theory with her stepson Billy Corgan during a family birthday celebration
Corgan later recalled that on his 18th birthday in 1985, his father told him while they were sitting in an IHOP that he had a half-brother named Bill who would be close to him in age. Burr will turn 59 next year.
Years later, Corgan asked his father to identify the half-brother and explain how he could find him. According to Corgan’s later recollection, his father replied: ‘I’m trying to protect you.’
Corgan’s father died in 2021. Aside from Billy Jr and Jesse, he appeared to keep any possible additional children a secret, including from longtime members of his bands.
‘He never mentioned any other sons to me, and we played together for a good eight years, seven years,’ bassist Nick Fortuna told Our News Outlet.
However, when asked about his former bandmate’s relationships with women, Fortuna suggested that life on the road offered plenty of opportunities.
‘Come on, we’re rock musicians,’ he said.
Fortuna said it ‘wasn’t really hard to do’ for Corgan Sr to meet women while touring during the freewheeling 1960s, adding that the era was no longer as restrictive as the 1950s.
For years, the possibility that Corgan Sr had fathered another son while on the road remained a private family matter.
That changed when Corgan discussed it publicly.
Two months after Corgan raised the sibling theory on Howie Mandel’s podcast, Burr appeared on the show. Midway through the interview, Mandel told him he had arranged a surprise and brought Corgan into the room.
YOU MAY ALSO READ: Russell Brand’s Wife Laura Gallacher Says She Won’t Share More ‘Prison Messages’ After Saying She’s Proud
Burr greeted the rocker before turning to Mandel and saying, ‘You’re an a**hole.’
‘I thought you would be cool with me bringing the family together,’ Mandel responded.
Corgan believed Burr knew he was coming, but the meeting quickly became uncomfortable when Burr challenged him about making the story public.
‘Did you ever think, the fact that I never told that story, that maybe you shouldn’t?’ Burr asked Corgan.
Corgan asked his father who his half-brother was and where he could find him. His father reportedly replied: ‘I’m trying to protect you’
‘Did you ever think, the fact that I never told that story, that maybe you shouldn’t?’ Burr asked Corgan
Burr also poked fun at one detail in Corgan’s account.
‘He had two kids this close together and he gave them the same f**king name?’
He then turned to Mandel and asked, ‘What was supposed to happen? Are we gonna go play catch? We’re both in our 50s.’
Six days later, Burr was still angry, calling Mandel a ‘Hollywood w***e’ during an appearance on The Rich Eisen Show for arranging the unexpected meeting.
Mandel later insisted that he had not intended to put either man in an awkward position.
‘Corgan tapes his own podcast in the same building,’ Mandel told Our News Outlet. Since Burr was already there, he said he simply invited the rocker to stop by.
‘And then I got in trouble for it,’ Mandel said.
‘I was as uncomfortable as anybody else watching. My intention was not to make anybody uncomfortable.’
Asked whether Burr and Corgan might really be half-brothers, Mandel offered a brief response: ‘I don’t know. Like, I just don’t know.’
Professional genealogists who watched the encounter said they understood why viewers noticed a resemblance. However, they emphasized that only DNA testing could determine whether Burr and Corgan share a father.
Sisters Ellen and Elizabeth Driscoll told Our News Outlet that they would begin by measuring the amount of DNA the men share and then comparing their Y chromosomes to determine whether they belong to the same paternal line.
‘Ideally, both would take an autosomal DNA test, along with a Y-DNA test, which could help establish whether they share a common paternal lineage and potentially identify their biological surname,’ they said in an email.
An autosomal test could show whether Burr and Corgan share the level of DNA typically expected between half-brothers. A Y-DNA test would trace their direct male line by comparing the Y chromosome each inherited from his father.
Even if just one of the two men agreed to testing, the results could still provide useful clues.
‘We could then look for common ancestors, identify possible paternal connections, and possibly uncover their biological father’s identity,’ the Driscoll sisters added.
Stephanie Lazazzero-Kelley, a Boston-area genealogist, told Our News Outlet that family accounts such as the one Andersen shared with Corgan can become like a game of ‘telephone,’ with important details shifting as the story is repeated.
Corgan became famous in the 1990s as the singer, guitarist and songwriter behind Smashing Pumpkins hits including 1979 and Tonight, Tonight
She also cautioned that Corgan and Burr should be ready for the possibility of learning things they would rather not know.
‘Someone might be thrilled to find a relative and still feel hurt that they didn’t know about them sooner,’ she said.
‘For someone else, it might explain something they’ve wondered about for years. Others have no interest in learning more, and that’s their choice.’
Fortuna said he could understand why Corgan might want certainty. ‘If I were him, I’d want to know if I had a half-brother out there. But that’s up to him.’
During an appearance on Joe Rogan’s podcast last year, Corgan said he had no interest in taking a DNA test to resolve the question. He also said he was not convinced that he and Burr were related.
‘All I know is…when I look at him he looks just like my father,’ Corgan said, describing the resemblance as ‘freaky.’
Andersen, despite being the first person to suggest that Burr could be connected to her stepson, remains cautious about the consequences of pursuing the truth.
‘Bill Burr has got a nice family and I don’t think we should interrupt that,’ she told Our News Outlet.
‘And if there’s a family secret, then I certainly don’t want to be the one to blow that family secret. And if it’s just gossip, then I don’t want to disturb the family.’