Gainesville Woman Arrested for Burglary With Battery After “Baby Daddy” Dispute Turns Violent

Staff report

GAINESVILLE, Fla. — A 40-year-old woman was arrested Saturday night after Gainesville police say she forced her way into an apartment and attacked another woman during an argument tied to a “baby daddy” dispute.

According to police, Erica Nichol Williams was taken into custody after the incident at Carver Gardens Apartments, 1101 SE 15th Street. Officers were called to the complex at about 9:20 p.m. on June 13.

The victim told police that Williams had been angry over an encounter earlier in the day at a store, where Williams’ “baby daddy” allegedly held a door open for the victim. Investigators say Williams later went to the victim’s apartment and began banging on the door.

When the victim opened the door slightly to speak with her, Williams allegedly yelled at her, pushed her way inside, grabbed her by the hair, and punched and scratched her in the face, according to the report.

A witness told police she heard the banging and went to see what was happening. She reportedly saw Williams pushing against the victim’s door and swinging at her.

Williams also reportedly said that the victim had entered her apartment during the fight, but the victim denied ever entering Williams’s apartment.

The officer reported that the victim had a scratch on her face, and Williams did not have any visible injuries.

Williams has been charged with burglary with battery and burglary of an occupied dwelling. She has four felony convictions (four violent) and five misdemeanor convictions (three violent); she was arrested in May 2025 for allegedly attacking another woman with a bat, but the charges were later dropped. Judge David Kreider ordered her held without bail pending a hearing on a motion from the State Attorney’s Office to hold her without bail until trial; if the judge denies the motion, bail will be set at that hearing.

Articles about arrests are based on reports from law enforcement agencies. The charges listed are taken from the arrest report and/or court records and are only accusations. All suspects are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. 


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Gainesville Man Arrested After Allegedly Stabbing Girlfriend

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Joshua Anthony Mears, 19, was arrested the…

Mother Accused of Beating 5-Year-Old Son With Belt After He Forgot His Things, Police Say

Inset: Ebony Smith (Alachua County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The Alachua County Jail…

Woman Accused of Abusing Children, Stomping on Their Feet Until They Bled, Police Say

Inset: Raven Isham (Beltrami County Sheriff”s Office). Background: The Beltrami County Adult…

Caregiver Learns Sentence for Abusing Adult With Autism

Inset: Toyo Perez (Rock County District Attorney’s Office). Background: The Rock County…

Construction Worker Arrested for Stealing and Pawning Church Equipment

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Michael Anthony Holmes, 45, was arrested yesterday…

Teen’s Livestreamed Joyride in Stolen Land Rover Kills Woman

Inset: Matthew Papile (Suffolk County District Attorney”s Office). Background: A section of…

Man Pleads Out in Killing of Girlfriend Who Criticized Him

Inset: Raymond Jenkins (Louisa County Sheriff”s Office). Background: The area near the…

Man Who Hunted Down and Shot His Stepson Learns Sentence

Inset left: William Bryan Morgan (Eighth Judicial Circuit Solicitor”s Office). Inset right:…