Police officers face court accused of unlawful killing of Melbourne man

Two police officers have faced court accused of unlawfully killing a man who died in hospital following his arrest inside a car park.


Constable Alexander Papanastassis, 29, and Sergeant James Fitzgerald, 49, appeared at Melbourne Magistrates Court this morning for a brief hearing.


They sat together in the front row of the court room, dressed in suits, as their lawyers and the prosecution set dates for the next hearing.

Police officers James Fitzgerald  and Alexander Papanastassis appeared in court after they were charged over the death of a man during an arrest.
Police officers James Fitzgerald and Alexander Papanastassis appeared in court after they were charged over the death of a man during an arrest. (Simon Schluter/The Age)

Police yesterday said the two officers, who have been suspended from duties since the incident, were charged with negligent manslaughter over Luke Briggs’ arrest in July 2024.

However, documents released after their court appearance stated Papanastassis and Fitzgerald are each charged with “unlawfully kill Luke Briggs”.


CCTV and body-worn camera footage has already been collected from Victoria Police, the court was told.


The men are on bail with conditions, including that they notify police within 24 hours of a change of address.


They have both already surrendered their passports to police, a defence lawyer confirmed.


Papanastassis and Fitzgerald left court to an onslaught of awaiting media today.


They will return to court on December 12 for a committal mention.

Luke Briggs, 35, was arrested by police in the carpark of a convenience store on the corner of Heaths and Tarneit Roads at Hoppers Crossing
Luke Briggs died in a hospital’s intensive care unit eight days after his arrest. (Supplied)

It followed a Homicide Squad investigation with oversight from the Professional Standards Command.


Briggs, 35, was arrested in a convenience store car park at Hoppers Crossing, in Melbourne’s south-west, in July 2024.


He allegedly became unresponsive during the arrest and the officers performed CPR before calling for medical assistance, police said last year.


Briggs died in a Melbourne hospital intensive care unit on July 23, eight days after the arrest, surrounded by his family.


Photos at the time showed bruising on his arms as he lay in a hospital bed.


Briggs’ heartbroken loved ones called for answers the day after he died and asked for the police investigation to provide them with answers.


“In his final hours, we shared stories and reminded Luke how much we loved him while his favourite songs played in the background,” they said in a statement in July 2024.

“We will miss you, Luke. We don’t know how we can go on without you.”


Victoria Police Deputy Commissioner Wendy Steendam said the force did not shy away from taking action to uphold the community’s trust in the organisation.


“The overwhelming majority of our police do the right thing day in and day out and provide exemplary service to the community,” she said on Thursday.


“However, it is vital that where incidents such as this occur, they are investigated thoroughly regardless of a police officer’s rank, position or tenure.”

You May Also Like

Mother Sentenced After Waking to Find Child Suffocated Beside Her

Inset: Jaley Bush (Lee County Sheriff’s Office). Background: Bush speaking with law…

Gainesville Man Pleads Guilty to Federal Charge of Producing Child Sexual Abuse Material

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Robert Lee Johnson III, 39, has pleaded…

Man Charged With Sexual Battery After Allegedly Picking Up 14-Year-Old Girl at Gas Station

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Willie Dwayne West IV, 26, is facing…

Toddler Fatally Shoots Baby Sister After Father Leaves Gun Unsecured

Inset: Michael Tejeda (Sedgwick County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The Wichita street where…

Police: Woman Beat 2-Year-Old Son, Sent Videos to Boyfriend

From left: Karina Burns and Colt McNeese (Dakota County Sheriff’s Office). A…

Man Accused of Killing Longtime Bully Who Mocked Him, Police Say

Inset: Marquillo Kelly (Shelby County Sheriff’s Office). Background: Part of the 4100…

Trump Administration Sues Maryland Over Law Restricting ICE Cooperation

President Donald Trump delivers remarks in the Oval Office before signing a…