Anger over sentence appeal for 'war zone' attack on former Wallaby and his family
Share this @internewscast.com

A neighbour who helped stop a horror attack on a former Wallabies star’s family wants the justice system overhauled after an appeal over the teen offenders’ “inadequate” sentence failed.

Ben Cannon came to the aid of Toutai Kefu and his family when they were attacked by two 15-year-old boys in August 2021, in a Brisbane home invasion that resembled a “war zone”.

The former Australian and Queensland Reds rugby player suffered a “life-threatening” 25mm liver wound, his wife Rachel remains partially disabled after being cut to the bone by a sickle and two of their children were injured.

The former Australian and Queensland Reds rugby player suffered a “life threatening” 25mm liver wound, his wife Rachel remains partially disabled after being cut to the bone by a sickle and two of their children were injured. (9News)

Cannon tackled one teen and pinned him until police arrived.

One boy was sentenced to eight years and the other seven after pleading guilty to charges including malicious act with intent.

They were only required to serve 50 per cent of their sentences and did not have convictions recorded.

Then attorney-general Yvette D’Ath launched an appeal in 2024  against the “manifestly inadequate” sentences.

But the Court of Appeal today dismissed it after the state failed to prove the sentences were inadequate.

Cannon said it was shocking, but not surprising.

Toutai Kefu on Today.
Toutai Kefu and his family were attacked in their Brisbane home. (Today)

“The news in a sad way, it’s not unexpected,” he said.

“It seems like the system has more tolerance for injustice than it does for justice and it seems to always favour those who commit the crimes.”

The attorney-general needed to persuade the appeal judges the sentences were disproportionate to the offending.

But counsel failed to put forward any comparable cases to provide a yardstick of the appropriate sentencing range, the appeal judges said.

Broadly comparable cases show under 10 years imprisonment was “not out of the range” of sentences that could have been imposed, the appeal judges ruled.

The state government had argued the period of detention ordered for the boys was also manifestly inadequate.

Toutai Kefu in action for the Wallabies in Brisbane in 2003. (Getty)

The sentencing judge had said the teens’ lack of criminal history, rehabilitation efforts and personal circumstances led him to reduce the period of detention from 70 per cent to 50 per cent.

But the appeal judges found the attorney-general failed to establish the sentencing judge made an error in his decision-making.

In not recording a conviction, the sentencing judge used his discretion to consider the nature of the offence, the teen’s age, previous convictions and whether it would impact the chance of rehabilitation or employment.

A 15-year-old teenage boy charged with attempted murder following a bungled burglary that left Wallabies legend Toutai Kefu and his family with serious injuries has this morning faced court.
The sentencing judge had said the teens’ lack of criminal history, rehabilitation efforts and personal circumstances led him to reduce the period of detention from 70 per cent to 50 per cent. (Nine)

The attorney-general needed to establish that the judge was unreasonable and had argued that convictions should have been recorded to reflect the gravity of the offending.

Again, the appeal judges dismissed this, standing by the principle that children are entitled to the benefit of not having a conviction recorded to assist with their rehabilitation.

Cannon said the decision had put a fire in his belly and would inspire him to do more with his advocacy group, Voice for Victims.

“This shows the system needs a total upheaval,” he said.

“We need a system that understands that unless we catch these kids earlier and we steer them in a different direction … then we will end up with more and more victims.”

Asked whether there would have been different sentences if the Liberal National government’s landmark “adult crime, adult time” laws introduced last year had been in effect, Cannon was sceptical.

He said many legal experts – including judges – seemed to be lost in what the “adult crime, adult time” sentencing provisions actually mean.

“Justice shouldn’t be grey. It should be black and white,” he said.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Abrego Garcia Heads to Court to Face Charges: Report

Share copy link Inset: In the background is a clip of President-elect…

Officials Close Washington State’s Wilderness in Manhunt for Escaped Father

Travis Decker is wanted for the murders of his three young daughters…

Police Report: Man with SpongeBob Physique Attempted to Meet Minor for Illegal Purposes

Background: Randolph County Jail in Winchester, Indiana (Google Maps). Inset: James Raber…

Teen’s Family Files Lawsuit Against Grindr After Tragic Encounter with Killer on App

Insets, from left: Steven Gress, Michelle Brandes, and Miranda Corsette (St. Petersburg…

Trump Administration Seeks Supreme Court Permission to Dismiss Government Employees

President Donald Trump boards Air Force One to depart Joint Base Andrews,…

Indiana Woman Faces Charges Half a Year After Accident Leading to Death of 6-Year-Old Boy

An Indiana woman was high on methamphetamines and was doing her makeup…

Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs’ Ex Alleges He Forced Her Into Intimate Acts With Other Men

A woman who dated Sean “Diddy” Combs from 2021 to 2024 testified…

Parents Accused of Neglecting 2 Young Children in ‘Wild Unkept State,’ Fail to Appear in Court

Warrants are out for a couple from Wisconsin who missed their court…

Court Denies CREW’s Attempt to Prevent Closure of FOIA Office

President Donald Trump smiles as he speaks in the Oval Office of…

Duo Detained for Assault on Couple at Royal Park Apartments

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Two women, Nicole Sadie Dix, aged 48,…

Child Resorted to Sleeping on Furniture to Escape Parents’ Messy Home: District Attorney

Insets: Mateo Luna and Stephanie Passley (Butler County). Background: The trailer where…

Father Travis Decker, Suspected of Suffocating Three Kids in Washington, May Be Near Pacific Crest Trail

Police continue their search for Travis Decker, a Washington state man wanted…