Man who allegedly swung 13-year-old with autism off a pier knowing he could not swim will have to face trial

A Wisconsin man is set to stand trial after being deemed competent in a case involving the tragic drowning of a teenager with autism. Tylor Birch, 21, was in court in Marinette County on Thursday, where both his defense team and prosecutors concurred with a psychologist’s assessment affirming his ability to face charges of reckless homicide.

Man found competent to stand trial for homicide charge

Background: Courtroom footage of Tylor Birch”s appearance on April 2 (WBAY). Inset: Jakob Bowerman (Bowerman Funeral Home).

Birch and 16-year-old Peyton Carnot are both facing reckless homicide charges following the death of 13-year-old Jakob Bowerman. As previously reported by Law & Crime, the two allegedly took Bowerman by his hands and feet and hurled him off a pier into a lake, knowing he could not swim, resulting in his drowning.

Local ABC affiliate WBAY reported that Birch had been found competent in an earlier hearing, but his defense had challenged this decision. During Thursday’s session, conducted remotely, both parties agreed to accept the psychologist’s findings regarding Birch’s competency. His next court date is set for April 30.

Carnot, who is being tried as an adult, has a court appearance scheduled for June 4, where a status conference will take place.

According to courtroom reporting by local ABC affiliate WBAY, Birch was found competent at a previous hearing, but the defense contested that finding. Birch appeared remotely for his court appearance, where both sides agreed that the competency report could stand. His next court appearance is scheduled for April 30.

Carnot, who is being tried as an adult, is scheduled to appear in court on June 4 for a status conference.

In a criminal complaint obtained by local Fox affiliate WLUK, Carnot told police that he and Birch had “thrown the victim into the water after the victim has expressed he didn’t want to go in.” After Bowerman landed in the water, he allegedly told Birch and Carnot that he could not swim. The two defendants then reportedly tried to pull Bowerman out of the water, but were unable.

Bowerman was pulled from the water and taken to a hospital, where he spent several days on life support before he died on Aug. 23, 2025. His cause of death was listed as drowning. His mother said her son, who had autism and had a history of being bullied, did not know Birch or Carnot before that fateful day on Government Pier.

You May Also Like

Man accused in dog sitter, college student killings charged with third murder after skeletal remains found

Insets, from left: De’Kendric Crawford (Tuscaloosa police), Jose Felix Alvarez-Duenas and Jazmine…

Police: Man Fatally Shot Sister After Mother Died in Home Hospice

Inset: Richard Timothy Ward (Long Beach Police). Background: Police investigate after two…

Police: Man Chased Down Half Brother, Shot Him Before Newborn

Inset: Demarcus Burke. Background: Atlanta police investigate after Burke allegedly shot his…

Gainesville Woman Arrested After Pouring Honey on Windshield, Throwing Pots at Neighbor’s Door

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Jessica Jenea Chavers, 37, was arrested last…

Police: Dad Playing Overwatch Accused of Killing Crying Infant

Inset: Joshua Kaleolani Agbayani Soto Paiva (Hawaii Police Department). Background: The Hawaii…

Man on Probation Arrested for Stealing Woman’s Wallet From Purse at Walmart

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Elberto “Albert” Orando Robinson, 65, was arrested…

Lawsuit: Student Killed, Another Badly Burned in School Van Fire

Inset: Zer’Real B. Hinds (Belleville-Serenity Memorial Chapel, LLC). Background: The burned-out van…