Trump fails to dismiss Central Park 5 defamation lawsuit
Share this @internewscast.com

Inset, from left to right: Yusef Salaam, Antron McCray, Korey Wise, Kevin Richardson, and Raymond Santana feature on CBS Sunday Morning, May 12, 2019 (CBS Sunday Morning). Background: Donald Trump speaks at the annual Road to Majority conference in Washington, DC, June 22, 2024. (Allison Bailey/NurPhoto via AP)

President Donald Trump is standing firm on his assertion that he possesses “absolute immunity” from a defamation lawsuit brought against him by the exonerated members of the Central Park Five, regarding false accusations he made about them during a televised debate with then-Vice President Kamala Harris.

In an 11-page reply filed Wednesday, the president claimed he should be granted an automatic stay in the case while an appellate court decides if he is shielded from litigation under Pennsylvania law. The document argues that the state’s Uniform Public Expression Protection Act (UPEPA) — an anti-SLAPP statute designed to shield defendants from being threatened or silenced by costly lawsuits — is applicable to the case and protects him from the plaintiffs’ allegations.

Trump is contesting an earlier decision by U.S. District Judge Wendy Beetlestone, who dismissed his request to throw out the defamation suit, ruling that the Central Park Five’s claims aren’t precluded by UPEPA, Pennsylvania’s version of an anti-SLAPP law.

“In passing the [UPEPA], the Pennsylvania General Assembly clearly recognized the profound chilling effect that lawsuits targeting public engagement have on constitutionally protected speech. To address these judicial process abuses, the legislature granted defendants substantive immunity from litigation to shield them from the hassle and costs related to baseless lawsuits,” Wednesday’s filing asserts. “Since the record indicates UPEPA immunity was meant to safeguard defendants from litigation burdens, and President Trump’s appeal raises a non-frivolous issue, this Court should order an immediate stay.”

Beetlestone ruled last month that UPEPA does not apply in federal court. On appeal, Trump maintained that the law must be enacted in federal court, thus granting him immunity from the plaintiffs’ lawsuit. The appeal further argued that due to Trump’s alleged entitlement to immunity, the court is “mandated” to provide his request for a stay pending appeal.

Attorneys for the Central Park Five pushed back on Trump’s claim that a stay in the case is mandatory, claiming the president “does not cite any relevant case for this proposition” and is conflating absolute immunity — being immune from litigation — with being statutorily immune from liability.

For example, a sitting president would be immune from litigation if a lawsuit were based on any official acts taken within the scope of presidential duties, regardless of the merits. On the other hand, immunity based on anti-SLAPP statutes typically requires courts to address the merits of the plaintiff’s claims.

Trump on Wednesday argued that plaintiffs’ position “fundamentally misconstrues the statute,” claiming UPEPA “grants defendants an immediate entitlement to avoid the litigation process itself, which cannot be vindicated once Defendant is subjected to the burdens of litigation.”

“UPEPA immunity is, therefore, like that afforded to defendants under the doctrines of absolute and qualified immunity, and the Court should stay the proceedings in this case as it would in cases where such immunities are invoked,” the filing says.

The president further asserted that refusing his request to stay the proceedings while the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals would establish a precedent allowing lawsuits to be filed against citizens “for merely voicing their opinions in quintessentially political discussions.”

The wrongly accused quintet sued Trump for false statements he made during last year’s presidential debate with Kamala Harris in which he said the plaintiffs “pled guilty” to the horrific 1989 attack on a Manhattan jogger and “ultimately killed a person.”

Antron McCray, Korey Wise, Kevin Richardson, and Raymond Santana gave police coerced confessions, but never pleaded guilty while Yusef Salaam did not confess or plead guilty. Additionally, no one died in the attack, which was later conclusively proven to have been committed by a man named Matias Reyes.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

McDonald’s Worker Allegedly Brandishes Gun Following Threatening Encounter: Police Report

Background: Surveillance video from the McDonald’s where Yoan Soto (far left) allegedly…

Tragic Airbnb Fire Highlights Critical Need for Smoke Detectors, Lawsuit Claims

Inset: Stephen Kuehl, his wife Stella Kuehl and their three children (GoFundMe).…

Justice Served: Man Sentenced for Attempted Murder of Ex-Partner in Front of Children

Inset: Garrett S. Headrick (Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The area in…

Vigilantes Detained: Deputies Intervene After Community Takes Action Against Predator

Background: A man collapses and hits his head after several men reportedly…

Authorities Launch Search for Suspect in War Memorial Vandalism Incident

Sydney’s police force is currently on the hunt for an unidentified individual…

Police Uncover Neglect Case: Daughter Accused of Abandoning Mother with Dementia Amid Growing Caregiver Strain

Inset: Janet Edwards (Miami Dade Corrections & Rehabilitation Center). Background: The Florida…

Man Detained for Playing Darth Vader’s Theme Near Military Personnel Files Lawsuit

FILE – People talk with National Guard soldiers on the Ellipse, with…

Tragic Collision: Three High School Football Stars Killed as Racing Sisters Cause Fatal Crash

A courtroom appearance on Wednesday marked the next chapter for one of…

Florida Woman Arrested for Alleged Neglect and Abuse of Elderly Disabled Mother

A woman from Florida faces charges of neglecting an elderly or disabled…

FBI Suspects Additional Victims in Child Sex Crime Case Involving Long-Serving School Resource Officer

Authorities suspect that a Colorado school resource officer, recently charged with sexual…

Storm of Controversy Erupts Over Trump’s National Guard Authority

President Donald Trump holds an artist rendering of interior of the new…

Police Report Teacher Discharged 21 Rounds Towards Brother in Shooting Incident

Background: The 3000 block of Heber Springs Road North in Cleburne County,…