Two New York teens who disappeared last week have been located safely, according to the Suffolk County police.

As CrimeOnline previously reported, Vincent Abolafia and his girlfriend Kaileigh Catalano, both 15, were supposed to board a train at 3:11 p.m. on December 9, from Ronkonkoma to Manhattan. Fox News reports that the pair are from Manorville, which is around a 30-minute drive to Ronkonkoma.

Both teens were reportedly wearing all black when a friend dropped them off at the train station.

On Tuesday, Suffolk County police said both teens were located safely after Kaileigh’s father received a tip. The New York Post reports that Kaileigh’s mother, Ehrin Catalano, confirmed the teens were found at the subway system in Manhattan.

“They were just found,” Ehrin told The Post. “They were in the subway in the city – on a bench in the subway.”

Ehrin Catalano added that she wasn’t sure what the teens did for the few days they were missing. Both appeared dirty but otherwise in good health.

Fox News reports that witnesses spotted the teens at Times Square and other locations in Manhattan. They appear to have voluntarily stayed in the city, according to police. Neither teen has a history of running away from home.

Kaileigh’s dad, Joe Catalano, previously said he was worried about the children in the city since they’re not from the area and were there alone.

“Long Island and the city are two different animals,” he said.

For the latest true crime and justice news, subscribe to the ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ podcast. Here is our latest episode. 

Join Nancy Grace for her new online video series designed to help you protect what you love most – your children.

[Feature Photo: Vincent Abolafia and Kaileigh Catalano/Police Handout]

Source: This post first appeared on

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Mom Pulls .38 on Woman During Elementary School Drop-Off After Alleged Road Rage Incident: Police

Background: Mint Hill Elementary School in Mint Hill, North Carolina (Google Maps).…

Man Killed Father and Son, Then Told Nurse to Let Him Die

Inset: Romi Frentescu (McLennan County Sheriff’s Office). Background: The Bruceville-Eddy, Texas, intersection…

Lyft Driver Stabbed 11 Times During Pickup, Car Stolen: Cops

Inset: Naziyha Weatherall (Greenville County Sheriff’s Office). Background: Officers investigate a reported…

18-Year-Old Arrested on Child Pornography Possession Charge

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Christopher Deon Flintroyal Jr., 18, is facing…

Police: Son Beat Mom With 25-Pound Plate, Then Stabbed Her

Inset: Nathan Lagasse (Penobscot County Sheriff’s Office). Background: Penobscot County Jail in…

Man Arrested in Alleged Rape of Homeless Woman: What to Know

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Richard William Blackwelder, 45, is facing a…

Man Stomped Woman Before Fatally Beating Her With Rock, Police Say

Inset: Steven Black (Tarrant County Jail). Background: The Fort Worth, Texas, pedestrian…

Woman Shot Dead While Fleeing Boyfriend at New Home: Police

Inset: Amir Johnson (Baltimore County Police Department). Background: Authorities investigate a shooting…