Supreme Court revives industry effort to axe California clean car standards 
Share this @internewscast.com


The Supreme Court revived an industry effort to axe California’s stricter vehicle emissions standards on Friday. 

In a 7-2 decision authored by Justice Brett Kavanaugh, the Supreme Court ruled fuel producers have legal standing to sue over California’s clean car standards approved by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), allowing the challenge to continue. 

“This case concerns only standing, not the merits,” Kavanaugh wrote.  “EPA and California may or may not prevail on the merits in defending EPA’s approval of the California regulations. But the justiciability of the fuel producers’ challenge to EPA’s approval of the California regulations is evident.”

Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson, two of the court’s three Democratic-appointed justices, dissented. 

The Clean Air Act generally preempts state laws that regulate motor vehicle emissions, but it allows the EPA to issue a waiver for California and only California. 

The EPA granted such a waiver in 2013, only for the Trump administration to partially withdraw it after taking office. Once former President Biden arrived at the White House, his EPA reinstated the waiver, putting the stricter emissions standards back in play. 

A group of producers of gasoline and other liquid fuels sued, arguing California’s regulations reduce the manufacturing of gas-powered cars, which would cause a hit to the fuel producers’ sales. 

But the EPA and California argue the producers have no legal standing, which requires a showing that a favorable court ruling would redress a plaintiff’s injury. The EPA contended that consumer demand for electric cars would exceed California’s mandate, anyway, so the regulations no longer have impact. 

The Supreme Court’s decision rejects that notion, reversing a decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit that tossed the lawsuit. 

“If invalidating the regulations would change nothing in the market, why are EPA and California enforcing and defending the regulations?” Kavanaugh wrote for the majority. 

“The whole point of the regulations is to increase the number of electric vehicles in the new automobile market beyond what consumers would otherwise demand and what automakers would otherwise manufacture and sell,” he added. 

In separate dissents, Sotomayor and Jackson said they would’ve sided with the EPA and California and noted the case may become moot.

“I see no need to expound on the law of standing in a case where the sole dispute is a factual one not addressed below,” Sotomayor wrote, saying she would’ve sent the case back to the lower court for another look. 

In her separate dissent, Jackson was more forceful, saying her colleagues weren’t applying the courts’ standing doctrine evenhandedly, warning it may contribute to an erosion of public trust in judges. 

“This case gives fodder to the unfortunate perception that moneyed interests enjoy an easier road to relief in this Court than ordinary citizens. Because the Court had ample opportunity to avoid that result, I respectfully dissent,” Jackson wrote. 

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Family of Teen Involved in Polk County Swatting Incident Speaks Out

POLK COUNTY, Fla. (WFLA) — On Thursday, News Channel 8 brought you…

Arizona Local Succumbs to Pneumonic Plague

() A resident in Northern Arizona has died from the pneumonic plague,…

AI Recruiters: The Future of Job Interviews

Wafa Shafiq, a 26-year-old Canadian marketing professional and lifestyle influencer, has been…

Representative Frost Proposes Legislation to Combat High Rental Fees and Prohibit Tenant Credit Checks

ORLANDO, Fla. – Symphony Betters knows all too well the kinds of…

U.S. Prepares for Next Year’s Major Event with Club World Cup Trial

Two of the world’s most renowned soccer teams are set to clash…

Augusta Charter Committee Faces Disagreement on Recommended Changes Requiring Two-Thirds Vote

AUGUSTA, Ga. () – “Because you are in violation of law.” A…

BCSO Apprehends Suspect in Failed Armed Robbery Attempt

BEAUFORT COUNTY, S.C. () — The Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office (BCSO) apprehended…

South Carolina Man Convicted in Connection to 2023 Hotel Shooting Death

AUGUSTA, Ga. () – A South Carolina man was found guilty in…

Barbecue and Country Music Shine at Windy City Smokeout Festival

() Chicago’s award-winning Windy City Smokeout is heating up as performers and…

Utah River Ranger Saves Paddleboarder Caught Beneath Bridge

WASATCH COUNTY, Utah (KTVX) – Body camera footage from a rescue on…

Is Orlando Planning to Build an Underground Transit System? Here’s the Latest Information

ORLANDO, Fla. – Speculation is swirling about a new “Loop” coming to…

Protesters Against ICE Rally at Beaufort County Sheriff’s Office

HILTON HEAD ISLAND, S.C. () — More than a hundred residents of…