Share this @internewscast.com

The High Court will not hear an appeal by Victoria Cross recipient, Ben Roberts-Smith, ending a seven-year challenge of news reports that labelled him a war criminal.
The former special forces soldier had appealed his 2023 Federal Court loss after he sued Nine Newspapers for defamation over reports claiming he was complicit in the murder of four unarmed civilians in Afghanistan.
Roberts-Smith disputed Justice Anthony Besanko’s findings that the allegations were substantially true, arguing that was not backed up by sufficient evidence for such serious claims.
On Thursday, Australia’s highest court refused the former soldier’s special leave application to appeal with costs, ending his appeal options.
The recipient of Australia’s highest two military honours — the Victoria Cross and Medal for Gallantry — was ordered to pay a lump sum of Nine’s legal costs for the unsuccessful Federal Court appeal.

The costs of the 110-day trial and the 10-day appeal are estimated to exceed $30 million.

Roberts-Smith’s attempt to take his case to the High Court argued that the Full Court of the Federal Court had mistakenly assumed he admitted to certain allegations, which had not been reconsidered during the appeal process.

What were the claims about Ben Roberts-Smith?

The articles, published in 2018, included claims Roberts-Smith kicked a handcuffed man off a cliff and ordered his execution, and machine-gunned another prisoner.
Besanko found Roberts-Smith machine-gunned an unarmed prisoner in the back during a 2009 raid on a compound codenamed Whiskey 108.

Roberts-Smith also stood silent while a rookie soldier was ordered to execute an elderly Afghan prisoner so he could be “blooded”.

Besanko found one of the newspapers’ central claims — that Roberts-Smith had kicked an unarmed and handcuffed man, Ali Jan, off a 10-metre cliff and then ensured he was shot — was true.
As evidence of his guilt, Roberts-Smith attempted to cover up the unlawful killing at Darwan in September 2012 by removing Jan’s handcuffs and planting a radio alongside his lifeless body before he was photographed.
Roberts-Smith then told fellow SAS soldiers who witnessed the incident to stick to an approved story that Jan was a spotter whom they killed legitimately.
The Full Court of the Federal Court appeal judges firmly rejected the former SAS corporal’s claim that he did not know allegations of murder at a compound known as Whiskey 108 were true.
When dismissing his appeal in May, the Full Court of the Federal Court judges noted there were three eyewitnesses to the murder, which they said was a “problem” for Roberts-Smith.
The alleged war criminal has maintained his innocence and has not been charged with criminal wrongdoing.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

“Unveiling the Depths: Women Trace Historical Whale Migration Routes”

On the NSW Central Coast’s craggy headlands, you hear the gasp before…

Republican Albanese Visits the King Amid Opposition Concerns Over Taxpayer Expenses for UK Trip

King Charles has hosted Anthony Albanese and his fiancée Jodie Haydon at…
Masoud Pezeshkian, the President of Iran, enters a room for a photo opportunity during the United Nations General Assembly at United Nations headquarters, Thursday, Sept. 25, 2025.

Timeline: Key Events Leading to UN’s Response Against Iran Since 1967

The United Nations has reinstated nuclear sanctions on Iran today, intensifying the…
Little Laurie

Council Cuts Bureaucratic Barriers for Tiny Home Residents

A trial of new planning rules for mobile tiny is being launched…

Deadly Drone and Missile Assault by Russia Strikes Kyiv, Killing Four

Ukraine said that Russia had pounded the country with hundreds of drones…

Hamas Reports Losing Communication with Two Hostages Amid Israeli Attack

Hamas’s armed wing has urged the Israeli military to temporarily halt airstrikes…
Daughters hit rock bottom after father and partner murdered in hotel room

Tragic Downfall: Sisters Struggle After Father and Partner Slain in Hotel Room

When Australian businessman David Fisk, his partner Lucita Cortez, and her daughter-in-law…
A painting dedicated to the late daughter of two The Block stars and set to raise money for newborn intensive care has been stolen in a brazen art heist in Melbourne's north.

Artwork Intended for Fundraising for Baby Intensive Care Stolen from Exhibit

A painting honoring the late daughter of two stars from The Block,…
The amount of physical cash circulating in Australia is at a near-record high.

$1.5 Billion Cap on Property Purchases to Be Immediately Removed

The government’s expanded first home deposit scheme, a pivotal promise from their…

Federal Budget Shows Improvement Ahead of Interest Rate Decision

The federal budget is $18 billion better off thanks to a stronger-than-expected…
Detective Inspector Wayne Francis

Man Discovered Deceased Following ‘Brutal and Violent’ Assault at Brisbane Mall

Detectives are investigating the “brutal and violent” death of a man outside…
A close-up shot of an Optus store sign

Massive Optus Outage Affects Thousands Over the Weekend

Multiple people were left unable to contact triple zero after another Optus…