A courtroom sketch of Erin Patterson.
Share this @internewscast.com
Jurors cannot find mushroom cook Erin Patterson guilty of murdering her lunch guests simply because she admitted telling lies, a judge has warned.

Victorian Supreme Court Justice Christopher Beale provided the caution during the fourth day of his directions to the jury in Patterson’s triple-murder trial.

He noted the lies the 50-year-old has admitted, which include claims she never foraged for wild mushrooms and that she never had a dehydrator.

A courtroom sketch of Erin Patterson.
A courtroom sketch of Erin Patterson. (Anita Lester)

Jurors could use those lies to assess Patterson’s credibility on other statements she made to witnesses or during her evidence, Justice Beale said.

But just because Patterson lied about one thing does not mean she lied about everything, and jurors would need to consider all of the prosecution’s evidence, the judge warned.

“Do not reason that just because she has told a lie about something then she is guilty,” Justice Beale said.

The warning came after he outlined the evidence around Patterson’s alleged fake illness after the death cap mushroom-laced lunch.

Patterson’s former in-laws, Don and Gail Patterson, 70, and Gail’s sister Heather Wilkinson, 66, all died in hospital days after eating the beef Wellingtons prepared by Patterson on July 29, 2023.

Heather’s husband Ian Wilkinson became unwell but was the only lunch guest to survive.

Patterson, who has pleaded not guilty to three counts of murder and one charge of attempted murder, claims she was also unwell after the meal.

Justice Beale outlined the evidence from Patterson herself, where she reported having nausea and explosive diarrhoea for more than a day after the lunch.

The judge also reflected on the evidence from Patterson’s children, ex-husband Simon, doctors and nurses, who at times stated how well she appeared.

Erin Patterson trial
Erin Patterson was accused of more lies on her eighth and final day in the witness box at the Supreme Court in Morwell in regional Victoria. (9News)

Crown prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC claimed Patterson was pretending to be sick because she knew she had not eaten the deadly death cap mushrooms.

Patterson’s barrister Colin Mandy SC argued she was unwell but not as sick as her lunch guests due to the amount of beef Wellington she ate, her age, size and general physical health.

Justice Beale said the evidence around Patterson’s condition after the lunch should be considered in the context of alleged incriminating conduct.

Patterson has admitted some of the conduct, including disposing of the dehydrator at a tip and lying about foraging for wild mushrooms.

Justice Beale said jurors have to consider whether Patterson told the lies because she panicked in fear of being wrongly accused and losing custody of her children.

Patterson has denied lying about feeling unwell and feeding her children leftovers from the beef Wellington lunch.

If the jury found she did engage in the alleged conduct, they must consider whether she did so because she feared being wrongly blamed, the judge said.

“Even if you think that conduct makes her look guilty, that doesn’t mean she is guilty,” Justice Beale said.

He sent the jurors home for the week shortly before 1pm today, advising them his directions should finish before lunch on Monday.

The jury of 14 will then be balloted down to 12, who will be tasked with deciding whether Patterson is guilty or not guilty of each of the charges.

LISTEN NOW: The Mushroom Trial Say Grace is the latest podcast from Nine and The Age. Join journalists Penelope Liersch and Erin Pearson as they take listeners inside the case that’s grabbed global headlines. You can listen on Apple here and Spotify here.
Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Prince Andrew

UK Prime Minister Supports Investigation into Prince Andrew’s Rent-Free Lease at Royal Lodge

UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer has thrown his support behind an inquiry…
People brave the early morning ahead of the record-breaking heat at Rose Bay's Redleaf Pool in Sydney.

Sydney Suburbs Sizzle: Record-Breaking Heat and Fierce Winds Fuel Fire Warnings

Sydney has endured its hottest October day on record, with temperatures climbing…

Louvre Security Lapses Blamed for Daring Jewelry Heist, Says Museum Director

The Louvre’s cameras failed to detect burglars in time to prevent their…
New Zealand primary school teacher Jordan Shallcrass revealed her ultimate art class hack in the Ryobi USB Lithium Power Cutter, available for $89 at Bunnings

School Teacher’s Discovery Turns Bunnings Gadget into Must-Have Item: ‘A True Game Changer

A primary school teacher in New Zealand has uncovered a surprising crafting…
Louvre boss admits failure after jewel heist, says she offered to resign

Louvre Director Acknowledges Shortcomings Following Jewel Heist, Offers Resignation

The director of the Louvre Museum has acknowledged a “terrible failure” at…
Just one month ago, Jenna Ellen had started her first IVF treatment and was optimistic about starting a family with the love of her life

31-Year-Old Jenna’s Journey: Overlooked Cancer Warning Signs Every Young Woman Should Know

Just a month ago, Jenna Ellen embarked on her first IVF journey,…

Sanae Takaichi Breaks Barriers: What Her Historic Achievement Means for Women in Japan

Sanae Takaichi, a staunch conservative who admires Margaret Thatcher, became Japan’s first…
James Vlassakis arrives at the Adelaide Magistrates Court.

Attorney-General Demands Urgent Review: Controversial Parole Decision for Infamous Snowtown Killer Under Scrutiny

The South Australian attorney-general has taken steps to challenge the recent decision…

Why Skipping Travel Insurance Could Cost Australians More Than They Think

The Australian government’s official travel advisory service says taking out travel insurance…
Brittany Higgins has abandoned appeals against her costly defamation battle loss to her former boss, ex-Liberal senator Linda Reynolds.

Stunned by Defamation Defeat: Higgins Drops Appeals Amid Skyrocketing Costs

Brittany Higgins has decided to withdraw her appeals related to the loss…

Australian PM Defends Kevin Rudd’s Gift Choices for Donald Trump Amid Unveilings

Opposition leader Sussan Ley has walked back on calls for Kevin Rudd…

Australian Homeowners Face $42 Billion Financial Burden: What It Means for You

Homeowners in flood zones are paying “a disaster penalty”, with a new…