A 17-year-old student who died after going over a fourth-floor railing at his Los Angeles high school had punched another student moments earlier, prompting the other teen to strike back, authorities said.
The Los Angeles County Medical Examiner’s Office concluded that Xavier Nungaray-Martinez “intentionally jumped” following the Sept. 30 altercation at Franklin High School, NBC Los Angeles reported.
The coroner’s investigation found that Nungaray-Martinez sustained multiple blunt-force injuries to his head and upper body. Investigators said he hit a classmate first, and that student responded by punching him.
The medical examiner’s report also noted that the high school senior had a history of depression.
Videos recorded on cellphones during the classroom fight circulated widely online after Nungaray-Martinez’s death.
In one clip, a student appears to strike Xavier several times while he is on the floor before a teacher moves between them. The student then retreats briefly, shoves Xavier and delivers another punch that sends him back down. Xavier rises and runs from the classroom as the other student yells at him to “run” while using a racial slur.
A second video appears to show Xavier going over the fourth-floor railing as the student believed to be involved in the fight moves toward him.
Last month, sources told the California Post that LAPD investigators suspected Nungaray-Martinez may have initiated the confrontation—an account that conflicted with claims that he had been bullied.
In October, the LAPD said detectives “have not identified evidence establishing a connection between allegations of bullying and the student’s death.” The department said the investigation is still ongoing.
The latest disclosure came one day after the Los Angeles Unified School District denied a claim for damages submitted by Xavier’s mother, Lilia Nungaray, who has repeatedly said her son was not suicidal.
California law requires families to submit a claim to a public agency such as LAUSD before filing a lawsuit. Following the district’s rejection, Nungaray may now pursue the matter in court.
The claim, filed through the Los Angeles law firm Panish Shea Ravipudi, alleges that a teacher repeatedly shouted for the students to stop but did not physically intervene. It also claims that no school employee followed Xavier after he left the classroom.
The filing further states that Xavier “was not fighting back,” had experienced bullying throughout high school and was left “dazed and disoriented” by the beating before he went over the railing.
“Lilia deserves answers about what happened to her son and why,” Spencer Lucas, an attorney for Nungaray, told The Post last week. “We are committed to uncovering the truth, holding LAUSD accountable for any failures that contributed to this tragedy, and pursuing meaningful changes to help ensure that no other family suffers such a devastating loss.”
“Schools have a fundamental responsibility to protect the children entrusted to their care, and that responsibility cannot be taken lightly,” Lucas added.
Xavier’s parents, who are separated, are filing separate claims against the district. His father, William Amaya, has attributed the death to bullying and said during an October protest that his son was “not suicidal” and “had plans.”
The incident has also renewed debate over the presence of police at LAUSD schools.
In June 2020, following nationwide demonstrations after George Floyd’s murder, the school board voted 4-3 to remove police from campuses and reduce the school police budget by $25 million. Since then, officers have patrolled groups of schools and responded when requested rather than maintaining regular posts on campus.
Within days of Xavier’s death, LAUSD parents gathered outside the district’s downtown Los Angeles headquarters to call for police officers to return to schools. They cited bullying and what they characterized as inadequate campus security.
“We want police inside the schools,” said Diana Guillen, who heads a parent organization focused on school safety. Student advocates opposed the proposal, saying additional counselors and staff trained in de-escalation could be more effective than police in preventing fights.
Amaya, who graduated from Franklin, and other parents have continued to demand a police presence on campus. “Things are worse at Franklin now,” he told The Post.
The Post contacted Nungaray’s attorneys for comment.