police tape
Share this @internewscast.com


A New York prosecutor said Sunday during a bond hearing that 9-year-old Shalom Guifarro cried out for her mother, Shemene Cato, 48, to help her before the child’s brutal death.

Brooklyn Assistant District Attorney David Ingle provided disturbing case details during a Sunday bond, according to the Brooklyn District Attorney’s Office.

As CrimeOnline previously reported, the incident happened in an apartment above a restaurant off of Lincoln Place in Crown Heights. Patrons at the restaurant below reportedly complained of a foul smell emanating from upstairs, “almost like sewage dripping into the restaurant from the apartment.”

Police arrived at the scene and found Shalom unresponsive after a 911 about the victim bering in distress. Shalom had had bites marks on her body and trauma to her head, police said. Patch reports that police found the little girl was unresponsive after a bed apparently been dropped on her while she was trying to hide from Cato.

“[Cato] lifted the bed and attempted to pull [Shalom] out from under the bed,” the criminal complaint read. “But [Cato] dropped the bed causing the leg to fall off the bed and the bed to fall on the head of Shalom Guifarro.”

Previous Video Coverage 

A medical examiner said the child died from a blunt-force impact that caused internal bleeding.

Shalom lived in the apartment with her mother and a 13-year-old sister. The older sibling reportedly told investigators about the beating carried out by Cato on the day in question.

The sister said that the girl’s mother “spanked” Shalom and put her in a time-out following a temper tantrum. The complaint filed on Tuesday accused Cato of beating the girls over a missing computer tablet. Shalom fled and hid under the bed, which Cato lifted and dropped on her head.

Neighbors told The New York Times that Cato was an “overprotective mother who seemed troubled.” She was said to have been abusive to her children, as well as her two dogs.

“She was crazy,” neighbor Rey Santiago said, adding that he saw the suspect once shove and yell at her daughter at a laundromat.

Cato was arraigned and charged with murder, manslaughter, assault, reckless endangerment of a child, and a weapons charge. She remains behind bars without bail.

For the latest true crime and justice news, subscribe to the ‘Crime Stories with Nancy Grace’ podcast.

Join Nancy Grace for her new online video series designed to help you protect what you love most — your children.

[Featured image: Shutterstock]



Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

Jacksonville Resident Faces Charges in Date Rape Case

Staff report ALACHUA COUNTY, Fla. – Albert Charbine, a 33-year-old resident of…

Desperate Plea: Trump’s Pardon Lawyer Pressures Judges to Halt Bar Investigation

Ed Martin speaks at an event hosted by Rep. Matt Gaetz, R-Fla.,…

Florida Mom Abandons 12-Year-Old at Universal Bar for Refusing Nightclub Outing, Police Report

Inset: Amanda Thorpe (Orange County Jail). Background: Guests cool off under a…

Lawsuit Alleges Staff Negligence in Tragic Incident Involving 8-Year-Old Choking on Pineapple

Left: Amanda Corbala and Cruzito Tank Ruiz pose for a picture (Lawsuit).…

Texas Woman Arrested for Husband’s Murder After Initial Suicide Assumptions

A Texas woman, aged 31, now faces murder charges following an extensive…

Mother Reaches Plea Deal After Walking Away from Burning Home, Resulting in Tragic Death of 7-Year-Old Child

Inset: Kirstin D. Bowers (Shelby County Jail). Background: Bowers’ home after a…

Authorities Renew Search for Gus Lamont 165 Days Post-Disappearance

Authorities are revisiting the isolated South Australian residence of missing four-year-old Gus…

Florida Parents Exploit Fake Cancer Diagnosis: Donations Misused for Personal Gains

In a shocking case from Florida, a couple found themselves in legal…

Tragic Neglect: Son Blames ‘Stubborn’ Mother as She Dies in Squalid Home, Police Report

Background: Bodycam footage taken at the home of Deborah Valentine (Del City…

Police Report: Woman Allegedly Shoots Man 14 Times with Beretta and Another Firearm During Errand for Family

Background: A section of Willowview Avenue in Memphis, Tennessee (Google Maps). Inset…

Tragic Family Strife: Man’s Fatal Actions Leave Children Orphaned After Ex-Girlfriend’s Attempted Escape

Inset: Frances Lucero (GoFundMe). Background: Romier Taguiam Narag, in an orange jumpsuit,…

$250,000 Reward Announced for Information on Triple-Murder Suspect Julian Ingram

Note: This article mentions the name and image of a deceased Indigenous…