Donald Trump has launched a scathing attack on Gavin Newsom after the California governor moved to spare 548 death-row inmates from execution, arguing that the crimes committed by some of the convicted killers make Hannibal Lecter seem “like a nice guy.”
In a furious criticism of the Democratic governor, Trump mocked Newsom as “Gavin Newscum” and challenged the decision to grant clemency to prisoners convicted of horrific offenses, including the abduction and murder of a 12-year-old girl, torture killings and a mass shooting that claimed seven lives.
“Some of the people that Gavin Newscum freed from the Death Penalty, after many years of going through the California ‘Justice’ System, make Hannibal Lecter, of Silence of the Lambs, look like a nice guy!” the President wrote on Truth Social.
Trump’s broadside came as criticism intensified over Newsom’s decision to commute the death sentences of every inmate currently on California’s death row, a move that would effectively eliminate the state’s condemned population.
The prisoners affected include some of California’s most notorious murderers. One is Richard Allen Davis, who kidnapped and killed 12-year-old Polly Klaas during a sleepover at her family’s Petaluma home in October 1993.
Davis entered the house armed with a knife, restrained Polly’s two friends and took the schoolgirl from her bedroom. Her disappearance triggered a massive nationwide search. About two months later, Davis directed investigators to a shallow grave where Polly’s strangled body had been buried.
Donald Trump has sharply criticized Gavin Newsom’s plan to spare hundreds of California’s most notorious killers from execution, saying the crimes of some are so horrifying that they make Hannibal Lecter appear respectable
In a characteristically combative Truth Social post, the President condemned the Democratic governor’s decision to commute the death sentences of inmates linked to some of the country’s darkest crimes
Newsom’s proposal covers a notorious group of convicted murderers, including serial killers, child killers and mass murderers whose crimes devastated the communities where they took place
The case became one of the most infamous child murders in U.S. history and helped build public support for California’s strict Three Strikes law. Following a lengthy and contentious trial, Davis was sentenced to death in 1996.
The list also includes Charles Ng, who was convicted of taking part in the murders of 11 people alongside Leonard Lake during a brutal crime spree in the 1980s.
The two men used a remote property in Calaveras County as the base for their crimes, abducting victims and subjecting them to torture before killing them.
Their victims included men, women and children. Evidence recovered at the property revealed the disturbing extent of the operation. Ng was ultimately convicted of 11 murders and sentenced to death in 1999.
Randy Kraft, known as the “Scorecard Killer,” is another inmate whose sentence would be commuted. He was convicted of killing 16 young men, while investigators connected him to many more suspected murders.
Michael Gargiulo, dubbed the “Hollywood Ripper,” is also covered by the proposal. He was convicted of murdering two women and trying to kill another in attacks that spread fear across Southern California.
Chester Turner, referred to as the “Southside Slayer,” is likewise on the list. Turner was convicted of 14 murders, many involving women whose remains were found in and around Los Angeles.
Newsom’s plan would not release the men from prison. Their death sentences would instead be changed to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole.
Davis entered the Petaluma home in October 1993 while 12-year-old Polly Klaas was attending a sleepover with two friends. Wielding a knife, he tied up the other girls before taking Polly from her bedroom
DISCOVER MORE: Ground Stop Halts Flights, Triggering Widespread Delays
Michael Gargiulo was found guilty of murdering two women and attempting to kill a third in a series of attacks that alarmed Southern California communities
Charles Ng is among the most notorious figures in California’s criminal history. Alongside Leonard Lake, he was involved in a campaign of kidnapping, torture and murder at a remote Calaveras County property during the 1980s
Randy Kraft was convicted of 16 murders. Investigators found a coded list that earned him the nickname “Scorecard Killer” and believe it may refer to as many as 61 or 67 victims in California, Oregon and Michigan
The convictions would not be overturned, and the inmates would remain behind bars. A commutation is neither a pardon nor an acquittal; it reduces or changes a sentence without altering the underlying guilty verdict.
The governor’s announcement has nevertheless drawn intense opposition. Prosecutors have accused Newsom of using poor judgment and of treating cases with vastly different circumstances as if they were all the same.
Newsom also faces a major legal hurdle. Of the 548 inmates, 382 have multiple felony convictions and need a recommendation from the California Supreme Court before their death sentences can be reduced. Prosecutors are supporting a legal challenge to the governor’s blanket policy.
Newsom has defended the decision as a principled rejection of capital punishment, saying California should not execute prisoners on behalf of the state.
“I firmly believe that state-sanctioned killing is incompatible with California’s values, undermines the foundations of our legal system, and diminishes each of us,” he said.
He placed a moratorium on executions in March 2019, shortly after becoming governor. California’s last execution took place in January 2006.
For the families of victims, however, the decision has revived pain surrounding cases that have remained emotionally raw for years.
Marc Klaas, whose daughter Polly was killed by Davis, said Newsom’s announcement felt like “a shiv in my back.”
Marc Klaas, whose daughter Polly was murdered by Davis, denounced Newsom’s decision and said it felt like “a shiv in my back”
Newsom has argued that capital punishment is costly, inconsistently imposed and vulnerable to wrongful convictions. He halted executions in 2019 and later began dismantling California’s traditional death-row facilities
Victims’ rights groups and prosecutors have echoed Klaas’s anger, arguing that the sweeping commutations overlook the suffering of families who spent years or even decades navigating the courts before death sentences were imposed.
Trump’s remarks represent another highly public clash with Newsom, whom he has repeatedly attacked over California’s progressive policies.
Newsom, widely viewed as a potential future Democratic presidential candidate, has frequently been targeted by Trump, who portrays California’s liberal leadership as a symbol of what he considers the Democratic Party’s failures.
While Newsom says he is rejecting government-sanctioned executions, Trump has made clear that he views the governor’s policy as unjustifiable leniency toward prisoners convicted of exceptionally brutal crimes.