US judge rules DOJ using state voter rolls unconstitutional

A US judge ruled Friday that the Justice Department acted unlawfully when it sought state voter rolls to compare them with a federal immigration database and pressure states to remove voters it considered ineligible.

US District Judge Sparkle Sooknanan’s ruling is the latest setback to President Donald Trump’s effort to increase federal control over election administration ahead of the November 3 midterms, as Republicans seek to retain majorities in both chambers of Congress.

In a 78-page opinion backing a challenge brought by watchdog group Common Cause, Sooknanan said the Justice Department had minimized the danger that its policy could wrongly disenfranchise eligible citizens. She noted that the federal immigration database, known as SAVE, could contain inaccurate information.

US District Judge Sparkle Sooknanan ruled that the Justice Department’s push to obtain state voter rolls to check citizenship status is unconstitutional. Bloomberg via Getty Images

“The challenged policy represents the federal government’s attempt to decide who gets to vote. But Congress has left that authority where our Constitution has always placed it: with the states,” wrote Sooknanan, a Washington-based judge appointed by Democratic President Joe Biden.

Supreme Court Paused Previous Ruling

Ming Cheung, an American Civil Liberties Union lawyer who represented the plaintiffs, said the ruling showed that “the administration cannot use the federal government to disrupt elections.”

A Justice Department spokesperson said the agency was reviewing the decision.

In a separate case, Sooknanan ruled in June that the Trump administration could not use an expanded version of SAVE to verify voter rolls. The US Supreme Court temporarily paused that ruling last month.

Federal law bars systematic voter-roll reviews during the 90 days before a federal election. That restriction could limit the effect of both Sooknanan’s ruling and the Supreme Court’s pause of her earlier order as the midterms approach.

A person casts their vote during early voting at a polling place in Virginia, with voting booths and equipment visible in the room.

The decision is the latest setback for the Trump administration on controlling election administration prior to Election Day. REUTERS

Latest Defeat for Justice Department

Trump, who falsely alleges that voter fraud caused his defeat in the 2020 presidential election, ordered the Justice Department last year to intensify efforts against voting by ineligible people. Multiple state audits and independent studies have found that such fraud is rare.

The Justice Department subsequently ordered nearly all 50 states to submit complete, unredacted voter rolls, including sensitive details such as Social Security numbers and dates of birth.

Eighteen states, most of them led by Republicans, complied. The department then compared the voter data with SAVE and notified states about voters identified as non-citizens so they could consider removing them from the rolls.

Sooknanan said the administration’s expansion of SAVE meant the database now included citizenship information from the Social Security Administration. That information could be outdated, potentially causing immigrants who had since become US citizens to be incorrectly flagged as non-citizens.

The Justice Department sued 30 Democratic- and Republican-led states that refused to provide unredacted voter rolls, along with Washington, DC. It has lost 26 of those cases so far and has not won any.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Scientists Say Anthropic’s Claude AI Solved a Famous Math Problem

An Anthropic employee says he may have used Claude to crack one…

Government Releases Secret Bigfoot Files Detailing Eerie Encounters

A newly released cache of once-classified US government records has brought fresh…

Melania Trump Slams ‘Yes People’ in Trump’s Inner Circle

First Lady Melania Trump has taken a rare swipe at the sycophants…

Thomas Markle Branded ‘Lying, No-Good Coward’ by Son Thomas Jr

Thomas Markle Sr has been called a “lying, no good coward” by…

Mechanic Kills Wife, Three Children and Himself in Murder-Suicide

A Florida father allegedly killed his wife and their three young children…

How an AI Apocalypse Could Destroy Humanity Minute by Minute

The prospect of an AI apocalypse is “exceptionally high”, amid growing fears…

Andrew Neil: Trump Has Given Putin a Seat at the Top Table

For all the ceremony, Thursday’s meeting of the so-called ‘Big Three’ —…

College Freshman Finds Ancient Roman Treasures on First Archaeology Dig

A college freshman made an extraordinary find on her first archaeological excavation,…

How Former NYC Mayor Rudy Giuliani Became ‘America’s Mayor’ After 9/11

To mark our 225th birthday, The New York Post is celebrating the…

Anti-migrant activist Danny Tommo jailed over migrant boat slashing

Anti-migrant campaigner Danny Tommo has been jailed for slashing an inflatable boat…

JD Vance’s GTA VI Meme Featuring Trump Sparks Backlash

JD Vance’s effort to tap into the excitement surrounding the release of…

Brad Pitt’s Upcoming Film Faces Backlash Over AI Blunder

Brad Pitt’s latest film has become the subject of an online backlash,…