Conservative professor slams 0 grade for Oklahoma student's biblical essay as punitive: 'very inappropriate'

A conservative professor from the University of Wisconsin system has voiced his opinion regarding the recent uproar involving Samantha Fulnecky, a University of Oklahoma student who was awarded zero out of 25 points on an essay for referencing the Bible.

“Awarding a zero for an assignment like this, particularly given the wording of the assignment, seems punitive, unless there’s an aspect I’m unaware of,” stated Professor Trevor Tomesh from UW-River Falls.

Emphasizing that his views are personal and not representative of his university or the University of Wisconsin system, Tomesh explained that in his classes, a zero is reserved for instances of outright cheating or failing to submit the work.

“This doesn’t merit a zero, certainly not, and based on the rubric provided, I can’t justify deducting so many points. The rubric was quite inadequate,” Tomesh asserted.

UW-River Falls and Trevor Tomesh split

Trevor Tomesh is associated with the University of Wisconsin-River Falls. (Image credits: WolterK/iStock; Trevor Tomesh)

Professor Tomesh also criticized the backlash faced by Fulnecky’s teaching assistant, William “Mel” Curth, describing it as “very inappropriate.”

Fulnecky, a junior at the University of Oklahoma, was flunked by Curth, who uses she/they pronouns, on an assignment that required reading a paper about the results of a study of 84 middle schoolers, and the impact on how binary gender norms impact them.

“I was asked to read an article and give my opinion on the article, and the article was about gender binary and mental health and gender stereotypes, specifically in children, because it’s a lifespan development class,” Fulnecky told Fox News Digital in a Monday interview. “So I was asked to give my opinion and my reaction to the paper.”

The rubric for the assignment, worth 25 points in total, provided three criteria for responding to the paper, which was titled, “Relations Among Gender Typicality, Peer Relations, and Mental Health During Early Adolescence.”

“Does the paper show a clear tie-in to the assigned article?” was the first criterion, worth up to 10 out of the assignment’s 25 total points.

“Does the paper present a thoughtful reaction or response to the article, rather than a summary?” was the second, also worth up to 10 points.

“Is the paper clearly written?” is the last criterion, worth up to five points.

Fulnecky’s essay argued on behalf of traditional gender norms, and cited the Bible as reasoning.

“Gender roles and tendencies should not be considered ‘stereotypes,’” her essay continued. “Women naturally want to do womanly things because God created us with those womanly desires in our hearts. The same goes for men. God created men in the image of His courage and strength, and He created women in the image of His beauty. He intentionally created women differently than men and we should live our lives with that in mind.”

“Society [is] pushing the lie that there are multiple genders and everyone should be whatever they want to be is demonic and severely harms American youth,” the essay said. “I do not want kids to be teased or bullied in school. However, pushing the lie that everyone has their own truth and everyone can do whatever they want and be whoever they want is not biblical whatsoever.”

In response, Curth failed Fulnecky. In an explanation for the zero grade, Curth demanded empirical evidence to back Fulnecky’s grade, despite empirical evidence not being a written requirement for the essay. Curth also described the paper as “highly offensive.”

“Please note that I am not deducting points because you have certain beliefs, but instead I am deducting point [sic] for you posting a reaction paper that does not answer the questions for this assignment, contradicts itself, heavily uses personal ideology over empirical evidence in a scientific class, and is at times offensive,” Curth’s response said.

University of Oklahoma campus.

Samantha Fulnecky, a University of Oklahoma student, received a zero out of 25 on an essay assignment after invoking the Bible. (Brian Bahr/Getty Images)

“You may personally disagree with this, but that doesn’t change the fact that every major psychological, medical, pediatric, and psychiatric association in the United States acknowledges that, biologically and psychologically, sex and gender is neither binary nor fixed,” Curth continued.

Tomesh described the teaching assistant’s response as unusual.

“The language used, where this instructor called a pretty standard view in all of traditional Christianity ‘highly offensive,’ that sort of thing in student feedback — that is very inappropriate,” he said.

Fulnecky told Fox News Digital that she also thought the zero grade was punitive, and that when she petitioned Curth to review the grade, Curth adamantly stuck by the zero. She also said that Curth had given her a five out of 10 on a similar previous assignment. 

She said that the university restored her grade after she filed a discrimination complaint, but that for now, her grade still reflects the zero in the school’s grading system.

In a statement to Fox News Digital, the university said that it is committed to protecting First Amendment rights, including religious liberty, and that it is committed to “fairness, respect and protecting every student’s right to express sincerely held religious beliefs.”

It also further explained the grading process for Fulnecky’s paper, noting that it “acted immediately” to address her concerns. 

“As previously stated, a formal grade appeals process was conducted and completed. The process resulted in steps to ensure no academic harm to the student from the graded assignments,” the school said. “As stated by the student, the two assignments – which together total 35 points out of the entire 1,050 points (3%) for the course – have been excluded from the calculation of her final grade.”

“Second, the student reported filing a claim of illegal discrimination based on religious beliefs to the appropriate university office,” the statement continued. “OU has a clear process for reviewing such claims and it has been activated. The graduate student instructor has been placed on administrative leave pending the finalization of this process. To ensure fairness, a full-time professor is serving as the course instructor for the remainder of the semester.”

Tomesh said that students dispute grades frequently, and described his process for handling those situations.

People walk on the Oval at the University of Oklahoma in Norman, Okla., Tuesday, March 10, 2015. Two students have been expelled from the university following an incident in which members of a fraternity were caught on video chanting a racial slur. (AP Photo/Sue Ogrocki)

People walk on the Oval at the University of Oklahoma in Norman, Okla., Tuesday, March 10, 2015. (AP)

“I usually default by thinking it’s something I missed,” he said. “I don’t turn it around on the student. What I usually do is, I invite the student to … email me and say, ‘Hey, can you tell me precisely where you think that I deducted points where the points should not be deducted?’”

In some cases, Tomesh said he will defend his grade. But if students vigorously disagree, he welcomes them to his office for a discussion.

“I’ve had lots and lots and lots of conversations with students where they sit across the desk from me, and I ask them, ‘Well, justify why you think this grade was not fair,’” he said. “And a lot of times, I do give them the points. I say, ‘Well, you argued it well, so I will give you some points for that.’”

“But maybe I’m too nice,” he concluded.

Curth and the University of Oklahoma did not respond to requests for comment.

You May Also Like

Glenn Close, Ridley Scott and Floyd Norman honored at 2026 Governors Awards in Hollywood

Glenn Close, Ridley Scott, Floyd Norman Honored at Governors Awards

HOLLYWOOD, LOS ANGELES (KABC) — Glenn Close, Ridley Scott, animator Floyd Norman…
DJ's $100K 'impossible to duplicate' record collection destroyed in Brooklyn building collapse

Brooklyn DJ’s $100K ‘Impossible to Duplicate’ Record Collection Destroyed in Building Collapse

A DJ who lost a vast vinyl collection in the deadly collapse…
America hits a tech wall as outages cripple email, ground flights and disrupt major banks

US Technology Outages Disrupt Email, Ground Flights and Hit Major Banks

A cascade of technology failures has disrupted essential services across the United…
FBI investigates who placed bomb near Illinois ethanol plant

FBI Investigates Bomb Found Near Illinois Ethanol Plant

The FBI’s Springfield, Illinois, office is directing the investigation and search for…
NYS Dems win big after changing laws for local elections

New York Democrats Sweep Local Races After Election Law Changes

New York Democrats scored major victories in this year’s elections, benefiting from…
United Airlines experiences ‘widespread system outage’ days after nationwide FAA ground stop

United Airlines Resolves Widespread Technology Outage

Nationwide FAA ground stop strands passengers on planes Fox News contributor Jonathan…
Michael John Roberts, 'BoJack Horseman' animator, has died

BoJack Horseman Animator Michael John Roberts Has Died

Michael John Roberts, the Canadian animator known best for his work on…
Mamdani restructures NYPD’s controversial Strategic Response Group, announces new ‘civilian-led approach’ to protests

NYC Mayor Mamdani Revamps NYPD Protest Unit for Civilian-Led Response

Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced Monday that the NYPD’s controversial Strategic Response Group…
Deputy working security at South Carolina gun show fatally shoots customer who shot at him

South Carolina Deputy Working Gun Show Security Fatally Shoots Customer After Being Fired Upon

A South Carolina sheriff’s deputy working security at a gun and knife…
Fight reportedly breaks out between passengers aboard Chicago-bound flight, FBI responds

Fight Reportedly Breaks Out on Chicago-Bound Flight, FBI Responds

Authorities reportedly responded at Chicago O’Hare International Airport after a physical confrontation…
Bruce Springsteen fan club shut down by admin after becoming torn apart by political fights, El Sayed endorsement

Bruce Springsteen Fan Club Shuts Down After Fight Over Abdul El-Sayed Endorsement

Administrators have shut down a Bruce Springsteen fan club after reaching a…
The 'disease of kings' is making a painful comeback

Gout, Once Known as the ‘Disease of Kings,’ Is Making a Painful Comeback

Gout may have a reputation fit for royalty, but today it is…