Share this @internewscast.com

WASHINGTON — When anti-abortion activists drafted a lawsuit seeking to overturn federal approval of the abortion pill mifepristone, they filed it in a court in Texas where they were guaranteed a judge who they thought would be friendly to their point of view.

That judge, Amarillo-based Matthew Kacsmaryk who was once a conservative legal activist and was appointed by former President Donald Trump, subsequently ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, prompting outcry and further litigation. The case is now before the Supreme Court.

The approach that the lawyers at the Christian conservative Alliance Defending Freedom took in that case, known as “judge-shopping,” will be harder to pull off following a policy change made Tuesday by the federal judiciary.

The U.S. Judicial Conference at its biannual meeting approved a new policy that would ensure that any cases seeking to block state or federal policies in federal district courts would be assigned randomly from a larger pool of judges.

The move was welcomed by Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., who had previously complained about the issue.

“The practice of judge shopping has given MAGA-right plaintiffs the ability to hijack and circumvent our federal judiciary by targeting courts that would all but guarantee a handpicked MAGA-right judge who would rule in their favor,” he said in a statement.

Cases like the mifepristone challenge showed how lawyers could take advantage of anomalies in how judges in the 94 federal districts are assigned cases.

While cases are assigned randomly in each district, some districts have smaller sub-divisions where in some instances there is only one judge to choose from. The Amarillo division where Kacsmaryk sits in the Northern District of Texas is one example.

That lawyers can sometimes pick the judge of their choosing has long been a concern, dating back to at least the 1990s, but the increase in nationwide injunctions being issued in recent years has renewed focus on the phenomenon.

Starting during the Obama administration and continuing through the Trump and Biden administrations it has now become a regular occurrence for an individual district court judge to freeze a nationwide policy on issues ranging from immigration to Covid-19 vaccine mandates.

During the Biden administration, many such cases have been filed in Texas.

The Justice Department declined to comment on the new policy.

Judge Jeffrey Sutton, who serves on the Cincinnati-based 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and is chair of the Judicial Conference’s executive committee, told reporters there were originally good reasons for having single-judge divisions.

It means that local judges could preside over local cases, he said.

But when the case is a challenge to a national or statewide policy “the stakes of the case go beyond that small town or division,” he added.

In that situation, “it makes a lot more sense” to randomly assign a judge from a larger pool, Sutton said.

The Judicial Conference said the policy “applies to cases involving state or federal laws, rules, regulations, policies, or executive branch orders.”

Judges will receive guidance on how cases should be assigned, the conference said.

The policy would not prevent lawsuits from being filed in districts where the judicial approach of the judges as a whole tilts one way or another. For example, in the Northern District of Texas, most of the judges are Republican appointees and their decisions are reviewed by the conservative-majority 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
Back to the Future for the GOP, Part II: The Trump Tariffs Are Helping the GOP

GOP Turns to Trump-Era Tariffs for Renewed Economic Strategy

In an unusual and bold step, Ontario’s provincial government has stepped into…
'Dancing with the Stars' week 7: Halloween night scares up shocking injury and another emotional elimination

Spine-Chilling Twists on ‘Dancing with the Stars’ Halloween Night: Unexpected Injury and Heartfelt Farewell

The atmosphere in the “Dancing with the Stars” ballroom was chilling on…
NYC Gambino family mobster tied to alleged rigged NBA poker scheme denied bail over witness tampering fears

NYC Gambino Mobster Denied Bail Amid Allegations of NBA Poker Scheme and Witness Tampering Fears

A man allegedly associated with a scheme involving rigged card games connected…
Bill Gates pivots climate strategy to focus on poverty over carbon emissions reduction

Bill Gates Shifts Climate Focus: Prioritizing Poverty Alleviation Over Carbon Emissions Reduction

Bill Gates is advocating for a strategic shift in addressing climate change…
Florida man executed for the 1998 rape and murder of his neighbor

Florida Man Faces Execution for 1998 Neighbor’s Tragic Death

STARKE, Fla. (AP) — In an unprecedented move, Florida carried out its…
Jaguars' Arik Armstead hosts dozens of local kids for a career camp

Jaguars’ Arik Armstead Inspires Future Generations with Career Camp for Local Youth

The Armstead Academic Project is actively organizing events for young people in…
Fugitive dad looked daughter in eye as he allegedly fled after mom’s murder, aunt says

Fugitive Father Allegedly Escapes After Murder, Leaving Daughter Devastated, Says Aunt

EXCLUSIVE DETAILS: In a chilling turn of events, Massachusetts father Aaron Pennington…
Jamaica Hurricane Melissa update: Romeoville, Illinois couple stranded as Category 5 Hurricane brings flooding, catastrophic winds

Update on Hurricane Melissa in Jamaica: Romeoville, Illinois Couple Stranded Amidst Category 5 Storm’s Devastating Floods and Winds

Residents of Jamaica, speaking with ABC7, have expressed that while they have…
Lawsuit accusing Mayor Adams of anti-Muslim bias reveals heated debate inside City Hall after Oct. 7

Controversy Erupts in City Hall: Mayor Adams Faces Allegations of Anti-Muslim Bias Post October 7

Following the Hamas terror attack on Israel on October 7, 2023, Mayor…
The East Wing demolition was 'jarring.' But a White House history buff sees a silver lining

White House East Wing Demolition: A History Buff’s Unexpected Silver Lining

Stewart McLaurin had been anticipating the changes. An entire section of the…
'Predator: Badlands' director Dan Trachtenberg wanted to "force" classic movie monster "through a gauntlet"

Director Dan Trachtenberg Challenges Classic Movie Monster in ‘Predator: Badlands’ Showdown

Director Dan Trachtenberg takes audiences to new heights of danger with “Predator:…
Woodfield Mall fire: Navy Sailor William Thompson helps rescue man from burning car at Macy's store parking garage in Schaumburg

Heroic Navy Sailor Saves Man from Fiery Car at Woodfield Mall Parking Garage

A Navy Sailor was among the brave individuals who sprang into action…