Share this @internewscast.com

WASHINGTON — When anti-abortion activists drafted a lawsuit seeking to overturn federal approval of the abortion pill mifepristone, they filed it in a court in Texas where they were guaranteed a judge who they thought would be friendly to their point of view.

That judge, Amarillo-based Matthew Kacsmaryk who was once a conservative legal activist and was appointed by former President Donald Trump, subsequently ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, prompting outcry and further litigation. The case is now before the Supreme Court.

The approach that the lawyers at the Christian conservative Alliance Defending Freedom took in that case, known as “judge-shopping,” will be harder to pull off following a policy change made Tuesday by the federal judiciary.

The U.S. Judicial Conference at its biannual meeting approved a new policy that would ensure that any cases seeking to block state or federal policies in federal district courts would be assigned randomly from a larger pool of judges.

The move was welcomed by Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., who had previously complained about the issue.

“The practice of judge shopping has given MAGA-right plaintiffs the ability to hijack and circumvent our federal judiciary by targeting courts that would all but guarantee a handpicked MAGA-right judge who would rule in their favor,” he said in a statement.

Cases like the mifepristone challenge showed how lawyers could take advantage of anomalies in how judges in the 94 federal districts are assigned cases.

While cases are assigned randomly in each district, some districts have smaller sub-divisions where in some instances there is only one judge to choose from. The Amarillo division where Kacsmaryk sits in the Northern District of Texas is one example.

That lawyers can sometimes pick the judge of their choosing has long been a concern, dating back to at least the 1990s, but the increase in nationwide injunctions being issued in recent years has renewed focus on the phenomenon.

Starting during the Obama administration and continuing through the Trump and Biden administrations it has now become a regular occurrence for an individual district court judge to freeze a nationwide policy on issues ranging from immigration to Covid-19 vaccine mandates.

During the Biden administration, many such cases have been filed in Texas.

The Justice Department declined to comment on the new policy.

Judge Jeffrey Sutton, who serves on the Cincinnati-based 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and is chair of the Judicial Conference’s executive committee, told reporters there were originally good reasons for having single-judge divisions.

It means that local judges could preside over local cases, he said.

But when the case is a challenge to a national or statewide policy “the stakes of the case go beyond that small town or division,” he added.

In that situation, “it makes a lot more sense” to randomly assign a judge from a larger pool, Sutton said.

The Judicial Conference said the policy “applies to cases involving state or federal laws, rules, regulations, policies, or executive branch orders.”

Judges will receive guidance on how cases should be assigned, the conference said.

The policy would not prevent lawsuits from being filed in districts where the judicial approach of the judges as a whole tilts one way or another. For example, in the Northern District of Texas, most of the judges are Republican appointees and their decisions are reviewed by the conservative-majority 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like
US police warn against 'AI Homeless Man' prank

Police Issue Warning Over ‘AI Homeless Man’ Prank Trend

Law enforcement agencies nationwide are encountering a surge in prank calls involving…
Teens who assaulted former DOGE staffer get no jail time with probation-only sentences

Shocking Verdict: Teens Avoid Jail in High-Profile Attack on Ex-DOGE Employee

Ex-DOGE employee recounts DC beatdown Former Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) employee…
House Democrat Makes an Insulting Closing Argument for Jay Jones, and Virginia Voters Shouldn't Buy It

Virginia Voters Urged to Dismiss Divisive Closing Argument by House Democrat Supporting Jay Jones

The political landscape in Virginia is experiencing significant shifts following the controversial…
Putnam 9-year-old arrested, accused of threatening student with knife at school

Putnam County Sheriff Shares Mugshot of 9-Year-Old on Facebook, Sparking Controversy

The Putnam County Sheriff’s Office has ignited a heated debate by sharing…
Putnam County sex offender convicted of capital sexual battery, sentenced to life in prison

Putnam County Justice: Life Sentence for Convicted Capital Sexual Battery Offender

In Palatka, Florida, a man from Putnam County, Lawrence Lacourse, has been…
Jacksonville man pleads guilty to manslaughter in 2019 death of 19-year-old

Jacksonville Resident Admits Guilt in 2019 Manslaughter Case Involving 19-Year-Old

In 2024, Gary Legg faced charges for the fatal shooting of Courtney…
Evergreen Park, Illinois news: 2 injured in shooting inside Walmart store in Evergreen Park at 95th, Western, police say | LIVE

Two Injured in Evergreen Park Walmart Shooting: Latest Updates and Police Response

In Evergreen Park, Illinois, a typical afternoon turned chaotic when a shooting…
Teacher's 23-stab-wound death ruled suicide again despite expert claims of homicide

Teacher’s Death, Initially Ruled Suicide Despite Expert Homicide Claims, Reaffirmed as Self-Inflicted

A long-anticipated reassessment of Philadelphia teacher Ellen Greenberg’s 2011 death, controversially categorized…
Police chase ends with truck explosion and fire in dramatic scene captured on camera

Intense Police Pursuit Culminates in Fiery Truck Explosion Captured on Video

A dramatic low-speed police pursuit near Kansas City, Missouri, concluded with a…
Bodycam shows TikTok influencer Marlena Velez raising her arm during November 2024 arrest in Florida

TikTok Influencer Known for Target Theft Claims Faces Another Arrest

A Florida-based TikTok influencer, known for her engaging lifestyle and fashion content,…
Federal Judge Sara Ellis orders ICE field director Russell Hott to testify, some agents to wear body cams in Chicago area

Judge Mandates ICE Director Testimony and Body Cam Use for Agents in Chicago Area

CHICAGO — A federal judge has summoned the Chicago ICE field director…
Blue city judge cites 'fear or obstruction' in blocking ICE courthouse arrests during court proceedings

Judge Blocks ICE Arrests in Courthouse: Concerns Over Safety and Justice System Integrity

On Wednesday, a judge in Chicago issued a directive preventing Immigration and…