Elderly Florida man accused of killing dementia-stricken wife said he'd 'rather go to prison' than care for her

In a chilling incident in Florida, an elderly man allegedly shot and killed his 83-year-old wife, who was suffering from dementia, because he believed serving time in prison would be easier than caring for her, according to authorities.

William Elwood Simmons, aged 80, faces a charge of first-degree murder after he reportedly shot his wife, Nancy, during an argument in their Orlando home. The dispute, which occurred around 5:15 p.m. on Saturday, involved a disagreement about a cruise, as detailed by the Orange County Sheriff’s Office and reported by Fox 35.

Upon arrival, police discovered Nancy lying face down in the kitchen, with blood visible from a head wound.


Mugshot of William Elwood Simmons, an 80-year-old white man with long gray hair and a mustache, wearing a black shirt.
William Elwood Simmons, 80, was arrested and hit with a first-degree murder charge after shooting his wife, Nancy, dead in the kitchen of their Orlando home. Orange County Sheriff

When questioned by officers about the incident, Simmons reportedly confessed, “I do know what happened, I did it,” as stated in an arrest affidavit obtained by the news outlet.

The affidavit further reveals that Simmons claimed he and his wife were in the midst of a heated argument when he retrieved a shotgun, returned to the kitchen, and fired a single shot. He allegedly expressed frustration over her dementia and lamented the loss of the person she once was, stating he preferred prison over dealing with her condition.


A person holding an MRI film showing sagittal views of the brain with frontal lobe atrophy, likely indicating frontotemporal dementia.
The slain wife was pronounced dead at the scene, with the gun and one spent round recovered nearby. Atthapon – stock.adobe.com

Simmons informed authorities that he was neither under the influence of substances nor acting in self-defense at the time of the shooting, according to the report.

The slain wife was pronounced dead at the scene. Cops recovered the gun and one spent round nearby.

Simmons, a former cop, was charged with first-degree murder using a firearm, jail records show.

He is being held without bail at Orange County Jail.

You May Also Like
Man accused of killing two teens claimed he was carjacked — his own dashcam footage shows otherwise: cops

Dashcam Footage Undermines Carjacking Claim by Man Accused of Killing Two Teens, Police Say

A New Jersey man accused of killing two teenage girls claimed to…
HOA threatens American flag-flying homeowners as they fight for Old Glory before nation’s 250th birthday

HOA Threatens Homeowners Over American Flag Display Ahead of U.S. 250th Anniversary

As the United States approaches its 250th anniversary, some homeowners in an…
House GOP agenda stalls over holdouts' insistence on SAVE America Act

House GOP Agenda Hits Roadblock as Holdouts Demand SAVE America Act Vote

Washington — A group of conservative House Republicans is continuing to stall…
Taylor Swift, Travis Kelce reported MSG wedding plans call for 1,000 guests, street closure at MSG: NYPD memo

NYPD Memo Reveals Reported Taylor Swift-Travis Kelce MSG Wedding Plans for 1,000 Guests and Street Closure

NEW YORK — Taylor Swift’s reported wedding to Travis Kelce, the three-time…
NYC's oldest maps blaze paths to the past and future

NYC’s Oldest Maps Reveal the Hidden History Shaping the City’s Future

NEW YORK — Manhattan’s famous skyline is not the only thing that…
Virginia first responders form human chain to rescue driver

Virginia First Responders Create Human Chain to Rescue Stranded Driver

Virginia first responders moved swiftly to save a driver trapped inside a…
Evil torturer learns his fate for heinous killing of beloved California artist after date night

Killer Sentenced in Torture Murder of Beloved California Artist After Date Night

A California man is expected to spend the rest of his life…
Taylor Swift, Travis Kelce reported MSG wedding plans call for 1,000 guests, street closure at MSG: NYPD memo

Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Reportedly Eye MSG Wedding With 1,000 Guests and Street Closure

NEW YORK — Taylor Swift’s reported wedding to three-time Super Bowl champion…
EXCLUSIVE: New York woman who wished 'every day were Oct. 7' charged with funding Palestinian terror group

New York Woman Charged With Funding Palestinian Terror Group After Oct. 7 Comments

Catherine Beth Washburn, a 37-year-old resident of Irondequoit, New York, near Rochester,…
Helicopter reports near miss with RC plane near JFK after JetBlue drone strike

Helicopter Pilot Reports Near Miss With RC Plane Near JFK After JetBlue Drone Strike

A helicopter pilot said he “just almost ran into a gigantic RC…
Postal worker and mom of two killed while delivering mail, leaving kids orphaned after husband's death: cops

Postal Worker Mom Killed on Mail Route, Leaving Two Children Orphaned After Father’s Death, Police Say

A longtime postal employee and mother of two was fatally shot while…
Detroit City Council narrowly votes to renew ShotSpotter gunshot detection contract despite opposition

Detroit City Council Renews ShotSpotter Contract in Tight Vote Amid Privacy and Policing Backlash

The Detroit City Council voted Tuesday to extend the city’s agreement with…