Elderly Florida man accused of killing dementia-stricken wife said he'd 'rather go to prison' than care for her

In a chilling incident in Florida, an elderly man allegedly shot and killed his 83-year-old wife, who was suffering from dementia, because he believed serving time in prison would be easier than caring for her, according to authorities.

William Elwood Simmons, aged 80, faces a charge of first-degree murder after he reportedly shot his wife, Nancy, during an argument in their Orlando home. The dispute, which occurred around 5:15 p.m. on Saturday, involved a disagreement about a cruise, as detailed by the Orange County Sheriff’s Office and reported by Fox 35.

Upon arrival, police discovered Nancy lying face down in the kitchen, with blood visible from a head wound.


Mugshot of William Elwood Simmons, an 80-year-old white man with long gray hair and a mustache, wearing a black shirt.
William Elwood Simmons, 80, was arrested and hit with a first-degree murder charge after shooting his wife, Nancy, dead in the kitchen of their Orlando home. Orange County Sheriff

When questioned by officers about the incident, Simmons reportedly confessed, “I do know what happened, I did it,” as stated in an arrest affidavit obtained by the news outlet.

The affidavit further reveals that Simmons claimed he and his wife were in the midst of a heated argument when he retrieved a shotgun, returned to the kitchen, and fired a single shot. He allegedly expressed frustration over her dementia and lamented the loss of the person she once was, stating he preferred prison over dealing with her condition.


A person holding an MRI film showing sagittal views of the brain with frontal lobe atrophy, likely indicating frontotemporal dementia.
The slain wife was pronounced dead at the scene, with the gun and one spent round recovered nearby. Atthapon – stock.adobe.com

Simmons informed authorities that he was neither under the influence of substances nor acting in self-defense at the time of the shooting, according to the report.

The slain wife was pronounced dead at the scene. Cops recovered the gun and one spent round nearby.

Simmons, a former cop, was charged with first-degree murder using a firearm, jail records show.

He is being held without bail at Orange County Jail.

You May Also Like

Brazil Senator Flávio Bolsonaro Flees to US After Election Loss; State Dept Says Visas Will Be Issued

Brazil Senator Flávio Bolsonaro Flees to US After Election Loss; State Dept Says Visas Will Be Issued

Brazilian Sen. Flávio Bolsonaro left the country for the United States on…
Police raid Lambda Chi Alpha, Pi Kappa Alpha houses at West Virginia University in hazing investigation

West Virginia University Police Raid Lambda Chi Alpha and Pi Kappa Alpha Houses in Hazing Investigation

Two West Virginia University fraternity houses were raided amid hazing allegations, with…
US woman who became ISIS teen bride convicted of weapons training with terror group

US woman who became ISIS teen bride convicted of weapons training with terror group

A New York woman whose father took her to Syria as a…
Deadly Spain High-Speed Train Crash Kills at Least 10 People

Deadly Spain High-Speed Train Crash Kills at Least 10 People

At least 10 people were killed Wednesday when a high-speed train crashed…
GOP Ads Miss Women, Independents, Says Political Strategist Heather Higgins

GOP Ads Miss Women, Independents, Says Political Strategist Heather Higgins

Republican candidates are failing to connect with women and independent voters through…
Spain High-Speed Train Collision Kills at Least 64 People

Spain High-Speed Train Collision Kills at Least 64 People

LONDON — At least 64 people died when two trains collided on…
Minnesota Court Restores $7.2M Medicaid Fraud Conviction Judge Tossed

Minnesota Court Restores $7.2M Medicaid Fraud Conviction Judge Tossed

A Minnesota appeals court has reinstated a conviction in a $7.2 million…
Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein, Who Oversaw Trump, Maduro and 9/11 Cases, Dies at 92

Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein, Who Oversaw Trump, Maduro and 9/11 Cases, Dies at 92

NEW YORK — Alvin K. Hellerstein, the longtime Manhattan federal judge who…
Dancing with the Stars Horror Night: 2 Eliminated, Perfect Score

Dancing with the Stars Horror Night: 2 Eliminated, Perfect Score

LOS ANGELES — Halloween week brought a chilling twist to “Dancing with…
FBI Says Violent Crime Arrests Rose 67% Under Trump vs. Biden’s Final Months

FBI Says Violent Crime Arrests Rose 67% Under Trump vs. Biden’s Final Months

The FBI reported substantial gains in its efforts to combat crime and…
Husband Arrested in Wife’s Disappearance After Mystery Texts to Family

Husband Arrested in Wife’s Disappearance After Mystery Texts to Family

A Florida man accused of killing his missing wife allegedly sent her…
Florida Woman Accused of Shooting Rival After Tracking Boyfriend

Florida Woman Accused of Shooting Rival After Tracking Boyfriend

A Florida woman was arrested over the weekend on attempted murder and…