St. Johns rental scam exposes Florida’s growing real estate fraud problem

Scammers are using fake IDs, deepfakes and bogus Sunbiz filings to steal and sell Florida properties before owners even know it’s happening.

ST. JOHNS COUNTY, Fla. — A viewer from First Coast News has recently highlighted a worrisome increase in real estate and identity fraud within Florida.

In a message to the Ask Anthony team, a man named Peter, who had just relocated from another state to St. Johns County, shared his story of being deceived after replying to an online rental listing:

I responded to an advertisement for a rental home. The person claimed to be the owner and provided the code to the lockbox so I could tour the property. I proceeded to send him money for the deposit, the first month’s rent, and additional charges. A few days after moving in, the Sheriff’s office arrived, informing me that the home was actually rented through a property management company.

Unfortunately, Peter’s story isn’t unique.

During Tuesday’s Ask Anthony LIVE streaming show, Anthony Austin spoke with Miami-based attorney Ellen Patterson, who is seeing a growing number of identity and property fraud cases. 

In one case, a scammer posed as an authorized business representative and altered official records on Florida’s Sunbiz.org to sell land he didn’t own. By the time the real owner found out, the sale had already gone through.

In another case, a fraudster used a fake Venezuelan passport and a deepfake-style video call to impersonate an overseas property owner, tricking lenders and buyers before the deception was discovered.

“You can Google what a Venezuelan passport looks like. Fraudsters can take that image off the internet and use it to create the fake passport,” Patterson added.

Patterson urges individuals and business owners to monitor their records closely and verify identities in any real estate transaction.

The full conversation is available on First Coast News+, where viewers can learn how to spot red flags, protect their personal and business information and avoid falling victim to these increasingly sophisticated schemes.

If you’ve got a problem you just can’t solve, email Ask Anthony at AskAnthony@firstcoastnews.com.

You May Also Like
It's About to Go Down: FBI Descends on LA Skid Row Over Potential Voter Fraud/Bribery of Homeless

FBI Investigates Alleged Voter Fraud and Homeless Bribery on Los Angeles Skid Row

In the days following California’s June 2 primary, attention turned to a…
Michigan trio allegedly beat, strangled and gagged man at Las Vegas hotel to collect on gambling debts

Michigan Trio Accused of Brutal Las Vegas Hotel Attack Over Gambling Debt

Three men from Michigan are facing multiple criminal charges after authorities say…
What's open and closed on Juneteenth 2026? Find out if banks, USPS and stores are operating.

Juneteenth 2026: Are Banks, USPS and Stores Open or Closed? What to Know

As Americans mark Juneteenth on Friday, June 19, many workers will get…
George W. Bush gifts Michelle Obama a tin of Altoids at Obama Center opening in an ode to their friendship

George W. Bush Surprises Michelle Obama With Altoids Tin at Obama Center Opening, Highlighting Their Enduring Friendship

The warm friendship between former first lady Michelle Obama and former President…
Becky Hill’s 'disgraceful' comments and book ambitions unraveled Alex Murdaugh's murder conviction: Docs

Former Murdaugh Trial Clerk Seeks Protection From Retaliation Lawsuit After Conviction Challenge

Court overturns Alex Murdaugh’s murder convictions The former South Carolina court clerk…
North Carolina furniture manufacturer allegedly kills business partner hours after losing contract dispute

North Carolina Furniture Manufacturer Accused of Killing Business Partner Hours After Contract Dispute Loss

A North Carolina furniture maker is facing allegations that he killed his…
Family shares heartbreak following Pomona double homicide

Family Speaks Out After Tragic Double Homicide in Pomona

A grieving Southern California family is sharing its pain after learning their…
South Carolina personal trainer goes missing, last spotted walking toward wooded area

South Carolina Fitness Trainer Found Dead After Warning Friend She Feared for Her Life

Authorities confirmed Friday that human remains discovered earlier this week in Lexington…
North Carolina furniture owner Willard Gary Black allegedly killed co owner Robert Arguelles

North Carolina Furniture Store Owner Willard Gary Black Accused in Co-Owner Robert Arguelles’ Killing

A North Carolina furniture maker is accused of fatally shooting his business…
Italian Premier Giorgia Meloni slams Trump's claim she 'begged' for a photo with him, diplomat cancels US trip

Giorgia Meloni Fires Back at Trump’s Photo Claim as Italian Diplomat Cancels US Trip

ROME — Italy’s government rallied behind Premier Giorgia Meloni on Friday, sharply…
Lawsuit filed in Illinois Court of Claims on assaults at Bronzeville facility linked to Department of Children and Family Services

Illinois Court of Claims Lawsuit Targets DCFS Over Assaults at Bronzeville Child Welfare Facility

Attorneys for a woman who says she was sexually assaulted as a…
Fox News True Crime Newsletter: Gilgo sentencing, a warning from 'Happy Face,' Mangione psychs himself out

Fox News True Crime Newsletter: Gilgo Sentencing, a Warning From ‘Happy Face,’ and Mangione’s Mental Spiral

Convicted Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann was transferred out of Long…