NY Town of Chester Highway Superintendent John J. Reilly III arrested for shooting DoorDash driver

An official from a New York town is accused of shooting at a DoorDash driver who was lost and had rung his doorbell seeking directions during a night delivery on May 2.

According to the New York State Police, John J. Reilly III, the Town of Chester Highway Superintendent, fired several shots at the 24-year-old delivery driver, hitting him in the back as he approached Reilly’s home in Chester, NY.

The driver, whose identity has not been disclosed, was carrying out a delivery for the well-known food delivery service in the wooded Valerie Drive neighborhood when he became disoriented with his navigation and went to multiple homes asking for help with directions.

“I need help,” the West Africa-native cried out in a neighbor’s doorbell camera video, according to WABC.

Reilly was inside his Orange County home, about 60 miles north of Manhattan, when the driver approached the house at 9:50 p.m.

The town official warned the driver to get off his property before he drew his gun and shot at the stranger several times, police said

The worker was hit once in the back as he attempted to leave the residential neighborhood in his car.

The driver’s family recalled the harrowing encounter he had with Reilly.

“He asked the guy, ‘Is this your order?’ The guy said, ‘No,’ and proceeds to say, ‘Get off my property.’ He walks away, he’s going about his day, going to his car, and the guy tries to murder him,” one relative of driver told the outlet. “He just started shooting at him and he thought his life was over.”

Police ruled the driver wasn’t doing anything suspicious. and was “just out there doing his job.”

“There’s nothing to indicate the victim had any nefarious intentions, he’s just out there doing his job, trying to make a food delivery,” New York State Police Capt. Joseph Kolek told reporters.

Not knowing what to do, the driver drove back to his home in nearby Middletown before going to the hospital.

The man’s wounds were listed as serious but non-fatal, police said.

The driver had recently moved to the US from his native Guinea-Bissau to live with his family and was working for DoorDash to earn money.

“No one should ever fear for their safety just for trying to make deliveries in their neighborhood,” a spokesperson told the outlet. “We’re devastated by this senseless act of violence.”

The Post has reached out to DoorDash.

Officials were alerted to the gunshot wound by hospital staff and arrested Reilly on May 3.

Reilly, a federally licensed firearm dealer, was charged with first-degree assault, second-degree criminal possession of a weapon and criminal possession of a firearm.

He was booked into Orange County Jail on a $500,000 bond and is scheduled to appear in court on May 9.

The driver’s family found consolation knowing their loved one wasn’t killed.

“We’re not a hateful family, or anything. Yes, the situation makes us angry, but we’re just very grateful that he’s alive, and we want this guy to get the punishment he deserves because he tried to kill him,” the relative added.

Town of Chester Supervisor Brandon Holdridge said he wouldn’t take a position on the case during the investigation, adding Reilly is “innocent until proven guilty.”

“The Town Board and I are aware of the ongoing situation concerning Highway Superintendent John Reilly. We are deeply troubled by what has been reported so far. We hope the person who was injured in the incident makes a full and healthy recovery,” Holdridge said.

New York State Troop F took over the investigation after the Chester Police Department recused itself from the case.

“As an elected official, the Town Board does not have control over Mr. Reilly’s future as Highway Superintendent,” Holdridge added.

He said the town will continue to run regular operations despite the investigation.

You May Also Like
Explosive confidential letter reveals why LAUSD chief Alberto Carvalho suddenly resigned

Confidential Letter Reveals Why LAUSD Superintendent Alberto Carvalho Abruptly Resigned

A private letter delivered to Los Angeles Unified School District Superintendent Alberto…
France skydiving crash: Plane crashes near Nancy-Essey airfield, killing all 11 people on board in Nancy

France Skydiving Plane Crash Near Nancy-Essey Airfield Kills All 11 On Board

NANCY, France — A plane carrying skydivers crashed Sunday in northeastern France,…
OC couple tries to save man killed by crocodile in Puerto Vallarta

Orange County Couple Tried to Save Man After Fatal Crocodile Attack in Puerto Vallarta

A 28-year-old man died Friday evening after being attacked by a crocodile…
Chicago heat wave: Chicago weather tomorrow includes Extreme Heat Warning, Heat Advisory for high heat index values

Chicago Heat Wave: Extreme Heat Warning and Heat Advisory in Effect Tomorrow as Heat Index Climbs

CHICAGO (WLS) — Chicago is bracing for a stretch of dangerous heat…
Louisiana detective believes 6-year-old's mother was killed in next room while boy slept

Louisiana Detective Says Mother Was Killed in Next Room as 6-Year-Old Son Slept

This story first aired on April 12, 2025, and was updated on…
Gun-wielding St. Louis couple in viral 2020 BLM standoff speak out after legal saga

St. Louis Couple Armed in Viral 2020 BLM Protest Speaks Out After Legal Battle

A pair of armed homeowners standing outside their St. Louis residence became…
Kash Patel Highlights FBI's Four 'Foreign Transfers of Custody' on Fraud

Kash Patel Spotlights FBI’s Four Foreign Custody Transfers in Fraud Cases

FBI Director Kash Patel said the bureau carried out four separate Foreign…
Dwayne Johnson is "protective" of 'Moana' live-action because "the animated film was so good"

Dwayne Johnson Says He’s Protective of Live-Action Moana After Animated Film’s Success

“To be able to showcase our Polynesian culture in this way has…
Gif of an infant trapped beneath the rubble being rescued

Miracle in Venezuela: American Rescue Teams Find Infant Alive in Earthquake Rubble Days Later

U.S. search-and-rescue crews found a baby alive under debris in Venezuela several…
Did a Louisiana father use his 6-year-old son as an alibi for murder?

Louisiana Father Accused of Using 6-Year-Old Son as Alibi in Murder Case

For more than 20 years, Reginald Reed Jr., known as Reggie, lived…
Chicago shootings this weekend: At least 10 shot, 2 fatally, in gun violence across city, police department says

4 Injured in Portage Police Chase Crash at Willowcreek Road and US 6

PORTAGE, Ind. (WLS) — Four people were hurt Friday afternoon in northwest…
Mystery as US Marine vanishes off massive ship off California coast

U.S. Marine Missing After Disappearing From Ship Off California Coast

A U.S. Marine is missing after disappearing from an amphibious Navy vessel…