Judge Questions New York AG’s Office in Cornell Sex Assault Case as Former Fraternity Member Seeks Ouster
Judge Questions New York AG’s Office in Cornell Sex Assault Case as Former Fraternity Member Seeks Ouster

A Sullivan County judge heard oral arguments Thursday on whether New York Attorney General Letitia James should be removed as special prosecutor in the reopened criminal investigation into an alleged gang rape at Cornell University.

Judge James Farrell concluded the hearing without issuing an immediate decision.

The hearing followed a challenge brought by defense attorney Andrew Miltenberg, who represents Gillio Lopes, one of the men accused in the case.

Lopes is among seven former Chi Phi fraternity members accused in a lawsuit of drugging and raping a Cornell student at the fraternity house in October 2024.

New York Governor Kathy Hochul and New York Attorney General Letitia James attend a press conference regarding an investigation into alleged sexual assault at Cornell University, in New York City, US, October 2, 2026.

New York Governor Kathy Hochul and New York Attorney General Letitia James attend a press conference regarding an investigation into alleged sexual assault at Cornell University, in New York City, US, October 2, 2026. (REUTERS/Jeenah Moon)

Defense attorneys contend that comments James made on social media before her formal appointment show she had already formed an opinion about the case and presumed guilt, compromising the investigation’s neutrality.

“What this young woman has been forced to endure is horrific and unacceptable,” James wrote on social media. “I’m holding her in my heart and in my prayers. To her, and to all survivors: you’re not alone. We stand with you.”

Miltenberg cited those statements in court as evidence that James had demonstrated a predetermined bias.

“Whether it affects all or just one, either the court determines the statements made by AG James take her out of contention to be neutral party reviewing case or not,” Miltenberg argued, describing the early public comments as the case’s “original sin.”

New York Attorney General Letitia James in 2024

New York Attorney General Letitia James holds a press conference in the Manhattan borough of New York City, Feb. 16, 2024. (REUTERS/David Dee Delgado)

A spokesperson for James’ office told Fox News on Thursday that the claims were unfounded. “As indicated in our motion before the court, these claims are without merit. The Office of the Attorney General remains committed to conducting an investigation guided only by the facts, the evidence, and the law.”

Assistant Attorney General Kaitlin Vigars, representing the state, defended Gov. Kathy Hochul’s decision to appoint James. She argued that public comments by themselves do not satisfy the legal standard required to disqualify a prosecutor.

Vigars said removal would require evidence of actual prejudice, not conjecture or unsubstantiated allegations of bias.

The Cornell fraternity house at the center of a rape allegation

The fraternity house at the center of a rape allegation stands on the campus of Cornell University on Oct. 8, 2026, in Ithaca, New York. (Ryan Murphy/Getty Images)

Farrell questioned Vigars about the events surrounding James’ appointment. He asked whether Hochul knew about James’ social media post, whether James and Hochul were together when the governor referred to the “brave young woman,” whether those circumstances raised professional-conduct concerns, and whether avoiding bias was the reason for appointing the attorney general.

The judge also expressed broader concerns about the legal process, including the possibility that separate courts could issue conflicting decisions if challenges to the investigation moved forward in different jurisdictions.

“If multiple judges come down with decisions that’s chaos,” Farrell said from the bench, “and the court should not fashion chaos.”

Hochul appointed James special prosecutor on Oct. 1 after intervening to bypass the local Tompkins County district attorney, who had previously declined to pursue charges.

New York Governor Kathy Hochul and New York Attorney General Letitia James attend a press conference regarding an investigation into alleged sexual assault at Cornell University, in New York City, US, October 2, 2026.

New York Governor Kathy Hochul and New York Attorney General Letitia James attend a press conference regarding an investigation into alleged sexual assault at Cornell University, in New York City, US, October 2, 2026. (REUTERS/Jeenah Moon)

Farrell did not rule at the end of Thursday’s hearing. He is expected to issue a written decision in the coming days determining whether James will continue as special prosecutor or whether the investigation must be reassigned.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Wife and daughter arrested after DNA IDs man whose severed head was found in trash bag

Wife, Daughter Arrested After DNA IDs Man Whose Head Was Found

A California mother and daughter have been arrested more than four years…
Top Oversight Democrat sends letters to 12 people close to Trump ahead of future investigations

Top House Oversight Democrat Targets 12 Trump Allies in New Investigation Letters

Washington — The top House Democrat on the Oversight and Government Reform…
Florida rainfall supercharged by El Niño floods roads and collapses synagogue's roof

El Niño-Fueled Florida Rain Floods Roads, Collapses Synagogue Roof

A slow-moving storm system unleashed torrential rain across South Florida on Wednesday,…
US test launches unarmed ICBM with Trump in Asia

US Launches Unarmed ICBM in Test as Trump Visits Asia

The US military conducted a test launch of an unarmed Minuteman III…
US Army soldiers sign up for unique reenlistment incentive to play GTA 6

US Army Soldiers Reenlist for Rare Chance to Play GTA 6

The U.S. Army is using one of the year’s most eagerly awaited…
China watchdog warns Trump faces ‘2-on-1’ showdown with Xi, Putin as Taiwan risks mount

China Watchdog Warns Trump of Xi-Putin Pressure as Taiwan Tensions Escalate

President Donald Trump could enter a high-risk negotiating environment Thursday, when he…
Japan scrambles fighter jets after Russian aircraft breach airspace amid rising Pacific tensions

Japan Scrambles Jets After Russian Aircraft Breach Its Airspace

Japan scrambled fighter jets early Tuesday after two aircraft believed to be…
Northwestern University students fight off dorm intruder Diaunte Adams

Northwestern University Students Fight Off Dorm Intruder Diaunte Adams

A Chicago-area man has been charged after authorities say he bypassed security…
2026 CMA Awards: Full list of winners and nominees from Country Music's Biggest Night | Live updates

2026 CMA Awards: Full Winners List, Nominees and Live Updates

The 2026 CMA Awards have arrived, and this page has the complete…
RFK vows to ‘work to regain’ US measles elimination status after health setback

RFK Jr. Vows to Restore US Measles Elimination Status After Health Setback

Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has pledged to “protect American families”…
Former Penn State frat brother indicted by federal grand jury in cocaine trafficking scheme

Former Penn State Fraternity Member Indicted in Federal Cocaine Trafficking Case

A federal grand jury has indicted the alleged leader of a cocaine-trafficking…
Susan Smith's ex-husband wants her ‘in prison until she dies’ after killing sons in alleged bid to win lover

Susan Smith’s Ex-Husband Wants Her Jailed for Life Over Sons’ Murders

Susan Smith’s former husband says she should spend the rest of her…