Karen Read defense floats theory that ‘jealous’ Brian Higgins fought John O’Keefe before death

Officer John O’Keefe poses for his official headshot

John O’Keefe (Boston Police Department)

Jackson presented video evidence purportedly capturing Brian Higgins at the Canton Police Department headquarters roughly an hour post the timeframe in which prosecutors allege O’Keefe passed away.

Surveillance footage showed Higgins alongside a group at the Waterfall Bar and Grille, with Read and O’Keefe, on January 28. Higgins later joined an after-party at 34 Fairview Road, a property belonging to another Boston police officer, Brian Albert.

O’Keefe was discovered dead outside the following morning.

Several witnesses have come forward, testifying that they heard Read repeatedly confess, “I hit him,” on the morning when Read and two former friends discovered O’Keefe’s body buried in snow on Albert’s lawn.

Karen Read in court for a retrial for the death of John O’Keefe.

Karen Read sits with her defense team during her trial, May 8, 2025, in Dedham, Mass. (Charles Krupa/AP Pool)

After sending jurors to lunch Monday, Cannone held a quick voir dire hearing and ultimately said she would not allow Jackson to question Bukhenik about what he knew about the relationship between Proctor and relatives of Albert, including one of his brothers, Chris, who was also at the Waterfall on Jan. 28.

Read could face up to life in prison if convicted of the top charge, second-degree murder. She is also accused of manslaughter and leaving the scene of a deadly accident. 

Police have not accused Higgins of a crime, and prosecutors say Read is the only suspect in O’Keefe’s death.

You May Also Like

Here's who could replace alleged rapist Graham Platner in Maine Senate race

Who Could Replace Graham Platner in Maine Senate Race After Rape Allegation

WASHINGTON — Democrats could have as little as two weeks to choose…
Erika Kirk comforts a stranger in tears during hearing for husband's accused assassin Tyler Robinson

Erika Kirk Comforts Tearful Stranger at Hearing for Tyler Robinson, Man Accused in Husband’s Killing

PROVO, Utah — A quiet but emotional moment unfolded Tuesday in a…
Disgruntled son, 26, arrested for stabbing retired corrections officer mom to death in NYC home

26-Year-Old Son Arrested in Fatal Stabbing of Retired Corrections Officer Mother at NYC Home

A Queens man has been arrested after authorities say he fatally stabbed…
Graham Platner trying to put his ‘thumb on the scale’ as Maine Democrats look for replacement Senate candidate, state party claims 

Maine Democrats Accuse Graham Platner of Trying to Sway Search for New Senate Candidate

The Maine Democratic Party’s executive director accused Senate hopeful Graham Platner, whose…
San Diego erupts as invasive plans would see new homes pop-up on their actual doorsteps

San Diego Residents Push Back Against Controversial Plan to Build Homes Near Their Doorsteps

San Diego is moving forward with plans for a major new community…
'Hell on wheels' killer Mackenzie Shirilla poses for prison photoshoot after legal setback

Mackenzie Shirilla Poses for New Prison Photos After Legal Setback

Convicted murderer Mackenzie Shirilla, the Ohio woman whose case drew national attention…
US urges donors to abandon UNRWA funding as UN defends agency's mission

US Presses Donors to Cut UNRWA Funding as UN Defends Gaza Aid Agency’s Lifeline

US envoy: Stop funding UNRWA, back Board of Peace for Gaza Speaking…
USPS to raise the price of a Forever stamp to 82 cents on Sunday. Here's what to know.

USPS Forever Stamp Price Rises to 82 Cents Sunday: What to Know

The U.S. Postal Service will increase the cost of a first-class Forever…
West Virginia town's entire police force fired after ex-sergeant claims evidence room was broken into

Entire West Virginia Police Force Dismissed After Former Sergeant Alleges Evidence Room Break-In

A small town in West Virginia is currently without a functioning police…
DA launches probe into claims Long Island school clerk trashed ballots to help DJ win election

DA Investigates Claims Long Island School Clerk Tossed Ballots to Help DJ Win Election

The Nassau County District Attorney’s Office has opened an investigation into a…
911 audio of DreamDoll Brii's shocked witnesses calling for help after influencer was gunned down

911 Calls Reveal Witnesses’ Panic After Influencer DreamDoll Brii Was Gunned Down

MIAMI – Newly released 911 audio captures the panic and confusion of…
Waymo calls San Mateo, California police on teens for drinking, shooting toy guns from driverless vehicle

Waymo Alerts San Mateo Police After Teens Allegedly Drink and Fire Toy Guns From Driverless Car

SAN MATEO, Calif. — Two 15-year-olds were detained after police said they…