'Doomsday Mom' Lori Vallow seeks new murder conspiracy trial, claiming juror misconduct

"Lori Vallow Requests New Trial Over Alleged Juror Misconduct in Murder Conspiracy Case"

So-called “Doomsday Mom” Lori Vallow Daybell is presently requesting a new trial barely under two weeks after a jury reached a verdict that found her guilty of conspiring to murder her fourth husband, Charles Vallow.

Within recently unveiled court documents, Vallow Daybell is alleging that Juror 15 mentioned in a local television interview their awareness of her previous murder convictions in Idaho, though these convictions were not referenced during the trial proceedings.

According to the court documents, during a post-trial interview with the juror, Vallow Daybell, who acted as her own defense, recounted that Juror 15 expressed a reaction to learning of her previous convictions by saying, “You know, I feel sorry for her. Driving home yesterday, I was like, ‘God she’s spending the next three lives in prison in a cell …’”

Vallow Daybell and Chad Daybell were convicted of the 2019 murders of two of Vallow’s children, 7-year-old Joshua “JJ” Vallow and 16-year-old Tylee Ryan. The couple, who believed some people had dark spirits and shared apocalyptic religious beliefs, were also convicted of murdering Chad Daybell’s first wife, Tammy Daybell. They were sentenced to life in prison. 

“All of these comments add up to prosecutorial misconduct.”

Vallow Daybell is scheduled to go on trial in Phoenix in May for an alleged plot to kill her niece’s ex-husband after a judge denied her motion to dismiss the case.

She previously explained to True Crime Arizona that she had been “working on her case for five years” and knows it “better than an attorney can learn it in two years” after making the decision to represent herself. 

Fox News Digital’s Adam Sabes and Audrey Conklin contributed to this report. 

Stepheny Price is a writer for Fox News Digital and Fox Business. She covers topics including missing persons, homicides, national crime cases, illegal immigration, and more. Story tips and ideas can be sent to stepheny.price@fox.com

You May Also Like

Families honor Tristyn Bailey, Trenton Stewart at St. Johns County football game

Families Honor Tristyn Bailey and Trenton Stewart at St. Johns County Football Game

Two St. Johns County families came together at a high school football…
Trump signs Russia sanctions bill championed by Lindsey Graham

Trump Signs Russia Sanctions Bill Backed by Lindsey Graham

Washington — President Trump on Friday signed a sweeping Russia sanctions bill…
California animal rescuer charged after 300 dogs, cats found in filthy home

California Animal Rescuer Charged After 300 Pets Found in Filthy Home

The operator of a Lake Hughes animal rescue where authorities seized more…
West Village claims 4 of NYC’s top 15 first-date restaurants: survey

West Village Dominates NYC’s Best First-Date Restaurants, Survey Finds

New York City offers countless places to spark a romance — but…
University of Texas drops three gender studies majors

University of Texas Eliminates Three Gender Studies Majors

The University of Texas at Austin, the state’s flagship public university, is…
Israeli UN Ambassador Danny Danon criticizes NYC's Mamdani

Israeli UN Ambassador Danny Danon Slams NYC Mayor Eric Adams’ Rival Zohran Mamdani

Israel’s ambassador to the United Nations, Danny Danon, on Friday accused socialist…
NC Democrat candidate Shelly Headen dropped by party after Nazis, MAGA comparison

NC Democrats Drop Shelly Headen After Nazi, MAGA Comparison

A Democratic candidate for the North Carolina legislature remains on the November…
Schools in Oakhurst placed on lockdown after black bear spotted

Oakhurst Schools Lock Down After Black Bear Sighting

Several schools in Northern California were briefly placed under lockdown after a…
ICE officer accused of lying to FBI about Minneapolis shooting pleads not guilty

ICE Officer Pleads Not Guilty to FBI Lies Over Minneapolis Shooting

Judge blocks Minnesota attempt to extradite ICE agent from Texas Fox News…
LaPorte County, Indiana manhunt: Suspect found dead, another in custody after shots fired at Indiana State Police trooper

LaPorte County Manhunt Ends: Suspect Dead, Another Held After Trooper Shooting

LAPORTE COUNTY, Ind. () — Authorities searched Friday for an “armed and…
Trump pardons PGA golf caddy Eric Larson's drug conviction

Trump Pardons PGA Caddie Eric Larson Over Drug Conviction

PGA caddie Eric Larson is finally stepping out of the rough. Larson…
Pentagon releases more UFO files, including documents on secretive military program

Pentagon Releases New UFO Files, Including Secret Military Program Documents

Washington — The Pentagon on Friday published its sixth release of records…