NYC 'animal lover' accused of stealing beloved bodega cat furiously claims she was unfairly arrested

The claws are out in a Brooklyn case involving a missing kitten.

A Brooklyn woman accused of taking a beloved cat from a Park Slope bodega was arraigned on petty larceny charges, then angrily maintained Wednesday that she is an “animal lover” who was wrongfully arrested.

“I’m going to sue them for accusing me of stealing,” Mary Sierra told The Post after she was released on her own recognizance.

“I’m an animal lover. I got three rescue dogs,” she said. “I wasn’t supposed to go to jail yesterday for this s—t. I went to jail! They locked me up, they locked me up for this s—t. I did not steal the f—ing cat.”

The three-month-old kitten was taken from 8th St. Mini Mart in Park Slope on Thursday. Surveillance footage showed two people walking away with the animal.

Although Sierra denied guilt, she acknowledged to The Post that she had taken the kitten.

“That store wasn’t open at 7 a.m. I saw the cat four houses away and picked up the cat and I took him home with me,” she said.

Neighbors organized a search for Jabal. Sierra eventually decided to return the kitten to the store, but instead had her stepson bring the cat to the 78th Precinct stationhouse on Tuesday.

Police took Sierra into custody, and she was charged and arraigned later that day on allegations of petty larceny, criminal possession of stolen property and “companion animal stealing,” according to a criminal complaint.

She was released without bail.

Jabal’s owner, Imad “Jimmy” Innab, was overjoyed to have the kitten safely back.

Sierra, however, insists she is being railroaded by the case.

“It’s embarrassing, because everybody knows I didn’t steal the f—ing cat,” she told The Post.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

DCPS: Gun found in new principal's car at Baldwin Middle-Senior High School

Gun Found in New Baldwin School Principal’s Car, DCPS Says

An anonymous tip led authorities to a loaded firearm inside the vehicle…
Florida seductress accused of drugging men she meets out, stealing their watches including nearly $100K Rolex

Florida Woman Accused of Drugging Men, Taking $100K Rolex

A Florida woman allegedly seduced and drugged a man she met at…
Air Force pararescue operators reaching Dude44 Bravo on a mountain ridgeline

US Military Releases Footage of Rescue Mission for Injured Airman in Iran

The U.S. military on Tuesday released dramatic footage from one of the…
3 dead after news helicopter crashes in Chatsworth near site of bus crash

3 Killed in News Helicopter Crash Near Chatsworth Bus Crash Site

At least three people were killed Tuesday evening when a news helicopter…
Senate takes first step to overhaul college sports system

Senate Takes First Step Toward a College Sports Overhaul

The Senate moved closer Tuesday to reshaping the college sports landscape, voting…
Charlie Kirk's family alleges UVU knew of rooftop security risk before his assassination: legal filing

Charlie Kirk Family Alleges UVU Knew Rooftop Risk Before Killing

‘Charlie Kirk: The Last Interview’ Recorded on the morning of Sept. 10,…
Americans' incomes hit a record high in 2025. Now for the bad news.

US Incomes Reach Record High in 2025—But Bad News Looms

U.S. households reached a record median income of $87,460 in 2025, according…
Norway faces backlash over 'deeply racist' proposal to jail citizens for West Bank business

Norway Faces Backlash Over Proposal to Jail Citizens for West Bank Business Ties

Norway is facing criticism over proposed legislation that opponents say unfairly targets…
Golden gun, 42kg of fentanyl and an alligator in a tiny tank found in luxury LA apartment

Golden Gun, 42kg Fentanyl and Alligator Found in LA Apartment

FBI agents uncovered an alligator and a gold-plated handgun during a dramatic…
Florida woman allegedly drugs man she met at club, steals his nearly $100K Rolex: police

Florida Woman Accused of Drugging Club Acquaintance and Stealing Nearly $100K Rolex, Police Say

A woman was arrested after allegedly meeting a man at a South…
Lindsay Clancy juror names indefinitely sealed by judge: 'Real and present risk'

Judge Seals Lindsay Clancy Juror Names Over Safety Fears

A judge has ordered that the identities of jurors in Lindsay Clancy’s…
Seven noncitizens charged in North Texas election-integrity investigation

7 Noncitizens Charged in North Texas Election Integrity Probe

Seven noncitizens are facing federal charges in North Texas as part of…