Small town dentist facing trial for allegedly poisoning wife's protein shake amid secret affair

A high-profile murder trial is set to commence Monday in Colorado, where prosecutors claim that a local dentist fatally poisoned his wife by contaminating her protein shakes with cyanide – all the while maintaining an affair and planning a new life without her.

James Toliver Craig, aged 47, faces charges of first-degree murder after deliberation pertaining to the March 2023 demise of his wife, Angela Craig, a 43-year-old mother of six.

The high-stakes trial is expected to last approximately three weeks.

James’ trial was delayed in November 2024 when attorney Harvey Steinberg withdrew from the case, just weeks before the trial was set to begin.

Steinberg informed the court that James Craig was adamant about following a legal strategy that Steinberg considered unethical, potentially illegal, or fraudulent.

Due to this last-minute withdrawal, the court granted continuance to allow James to hire new legal counsel and allow the new attorneys time to review the case.

The trial was rescheduled and officially begins with jury selection on Monday, July 14. Proceedings are expected to run through Aug. 1.

You May Also Like
Karmelo Anthony supporter reportedly fired as other backers face backlash over verdict remarks

Karmelo Anthony Backlash Grows as Supporter Is Reportedly Fired Over Verdict Comments

Texas judge defends barring cameras from Karmelo Anthony murder trial Judge John…
Jiffy Lube oil change issues: Chicago area drivers say bad oil changes caused thousands of dollars in damage

Chicago Drivers Blame Jiffy Lube Oil Changes for Costly Engine Damage

CHICAGO (WLS) — The I-Team continues to hear from drivers facing repair…
Record-breaking daredevil who performed at Super Bowl with Madonna dies in BASE jumping tragedy

Record-Breaking Stunt Performer Who Appeared at Super Bowl With Madonna Dies in BASE Jumping Accident

A record-setting extreme athlete who once appeared with Madonna during the Super…
Mango clothing tycoon’s son named suspect in death of billionaire whose brand stretches across US

Mango Billionaire’s Son Tearfully Told 911 His Father Had Fallen Into a Ravine

A newly released 911 call captures the son of a billionaire fashion…
The Grammys add five new categories, adjust rules for 2027 Grammy Awards

2027 Grammys Add 5 New Categories and Update Key Award Rules

The Grammy Awards are expanding again, adding five new categories and revising…
Yum! Brands sells struggling Pizza Hut in $2.7 billion deal

Yum! Brands Strikes $2.7 Billion Deal to Sell Struggling Pizza Hut Unit

Yum! Brands announced Tuesday that it has agreed to sell Pizza Hut…
NYC elementary students make Broadway debut with a little magic from Disney Theatrical Group

NYC Elementary Students Make Broadway Debut With Support From Disney Theatrical Group

NEW YORK — Elementary school students got a chance to make their…
Uptown shooting: Chicago police shooting near Clark and Argyle injures suspect in fatal Ravenswood shooting of condo board pres.

Uptown Police Shooting Near Clark & Argyle: Suspect in Fatal Ravenswood Condo Board President Murder Injured

CHICAGO (WLS) — A condominium board president was shot and killed in…
Vance: Iran Will Destroy Nuclear Dust, Will Get 'Benefits' if They End Enrichment, Allow Strong Inspections

Vance Says Iran Can Keep Peaceful Nuclear Program—But Must End Enrichment and Accept Tough Inspections

Vice President JD Vance said Monday that any agreement with Iran would…
3 Brazilian men charged after woman tossed from bridge without safety rope

Three Brazilian Men Charged After Woman Thrown From Bridge Without Safety Rope

Three men could face criminal charges after a 21-year-old woman was killed…
Ridglan Farms update: Wisconsin beagle research facility that drew protests is closing as Big Dog Ranch Rescue group takes in dogs

Wisconsin Beagle Research Facility Ridglan Farms to Close as Big Dog Ranch Rescue Takes In Dogs

A controversial beagle breeding and research facility in Wisconsin is shutting down,…
Iran says the deal to end the war with the US requires Israel to withdraw from Lebanon

Iran Says Any US War-Ending Deal Hinges on Israel’s Withdrawal From Lebanon

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — Fresh uncertainty is emerging over the still-unpublished…