Supreme Court rules NJ Transit can be sued in out-of-state courts for injuries caused by system's vehicles

In a landmark decision, the Supreme Court unanimously determined on Wednesday that New Jersey Transit can face lawsuits outside its home state.

This ruling opens the door for individuals from other states to file claims, potentially increasing their chances of success if they suffered injuries while utilizing the transit system, which extends into New York and Pennsylvania.

New Jersey Transit had contended it was entitled to the liability shields provided to state agencies under “sovereign immunity.” This doctrine, rooted in the 11th Amendment, safeguards states from being sued in courts by non-residents or foreign entities without their consent.


A general view of a New Jersey Transit train in Glen Rock, NJ as seen on October 19, 2025.
NJ Transit had argued that it was a government agency entitled to “sovereign immunity.” Christopher Sadowski

Established by the Trenton legislature in 1979, the transit authority operates as a state-owned corporation, with the governor possessing veto power over significant decisions, including the appointment of board members.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor, in her opinion, highlighted that legislators designed NJ Transit as an independent legal entity. The state holds no formal responsibility for the agency’s debts or liabilities, and the governor can only dismiss eight of its 13 board members under specific conditions.

Lawyers representing the plaintiffs, who sustained injuries in accidents involving NJ Transit buses in New York City and Philadelphia, argued that the agency was devised to enjoy the advantages of both a state agency and a corporation, while avoiding the drawbacks of each.

One attorney for the plaintiffs described New Jersey’s characterization of its transportation system as a “sort of a mishmash, you-know-it-when-you-see-it” approach.

“One problem with the States’ position is that it focuses on the label a State places on an entity, rather than assessing whether the State structured the entity as legally separate,” Sotomayor wrote in the 23-page opinion. 

“There is no good reason to believe that the State intended for NJ Transit to be part of the State itself by using the word ‘instrumentality,’ when it simultaneously used the word ‘body corporate,’ a term traditionally understood to create a ‘[s]eparate legal personality,’” she added. 

Sotomayor determined: “The clearest evidence that a State has created a legally separate entity is that it created a corporation with the traditional corporate powers to sue and be sued, hold property, make contracts, and incur debt.”


Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor speaks at the New York Law School's Constitution and Citizen Day Summit, in New York, Tuesday, Sept. 16, 2025.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor pointed out in her opinion, lawmakers “structured NJ Transit as a legally separate entity.” AP

The case, argued in January and has the effect of resolving two separate decisions by state courts.

Plaintiff Jeffrey Colt had been struck by an NJ Transit bus in Manhattan in 2017, while Cedric Galette was a passenger a car that was rammed by an NJ Transit bus in the City of Brotherly Love a year later.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court dismissed Galette’s case, finding that sovereign immunity applied, while the New York Court of Appeals allowed Colt’s suit to proceed. 

During oral arguments, New Jersey Deputy Solicitor General Michael Zuckerman warned that a loss at the Supreme Court could be detrimental to the Garden State’s financing of its public transportation system. 

“NJ Transit looks nothing like a city or town, and little like a private company,” Zuckerman told the high court. “It looks a lot like a New Jersey state agency. That means plaintiffs must sue it where the state has consented — in New Jersey.”

You May Also Like

San Diego votes to suspend 500 Flock license plate readers

San Diego City Council Suspends 500 Flock License Plate Readers

San Diego is shutting down roughly 500 automated license plate readers after…
Skydiving injury leaves 24-year-old tourist Chloe Lowe stranded in Australia on medical no-fly list

Skydiving Injury Leaves British Tourist Chloe Lowe, 24, Stranded in Australia Under No-Fly Order

A 24-year-old tourist says she has been stranded in Australia for weeks…
8-year-old Haitian boy detained by ICE in San Diego released from custody

8-Year-Old Haitian Boy Detained by ICE in San Diego Is Released

An 8-year-old Haitian boy detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement in…
Chicago shootings this weekend: At least 10 shot, 2 fatally, in gun violence across city, police department says

Five Men From Chicago Suburbs Charged in Northbrook Burglary Spree

VERNON HILLS, Ill. — Five men have been charged in connection with…
"No indication" recent outages are related to coordinated cyberattacks, officials say

Officials: No Sign Recent Outages Stem From Coordinated Cyberattacks

Washington — Senior U.S. national security officials told Congress on Wednesday that…
Students at $90K-a-year college forced to fight off dorm intruder accused of grabbing woman by the throat

Students at $90K-a-Year College Fight Off Dorm Intruder Accused of Choking Woman

A man is facing charges after investigators say he bypassed security, followed…
Jewish rights group launches online tool to help students file federal antisemitism complaints

Jewish Rights Group Launches Tool for Federal Antisemitism Complaints

The National Jewish Advocacy Center has launched a new online tool to…
Forget Affordability — Jeffries Vows to 'Immediately' Give Amnesty to Millions of Illegal Aliens

Hakeem Jeffries Vows Immediate Amnesty for Millions of Immigrants

The Democrats campaigned in the 2026 midterm elections on themes of affordability,…
Former Penn State frat brother indicted by federal grand jury in cocaine trafficking scheme

Former Penn State Fraternity Member Indicted in Federal Cocaine Trafficking Case

A federal grand jury has indicted the alleged leader of a cocaine-trafficking…
Anti-Israel activist allegedly destroyed $60 million US military aircraft at Irish airport: feds

Anti-Israel activist accused of damaging $60M US jet in Ireland

An Irish activist opposed to Israel allegedly carried out a carefully planned…
Mother and son use video game to help feds find missing girl allegedly held captive by older man

Mother and Son Use Video Game Clue to Help Federal Agents Find Missing Girl Allegedly Held Captive by Older Man

A Colorado teenager playing a popular video game helped federal investigators locate…
Photos show alleged firework stains in Chris Bosh’s Palisades driveway

Photos Show Alleged Firework Stains on Chris Bosh’s Palisades Driveway

A veteran fire investigator says stains found on NBA legend Chris Bosh’s…