Alleged stalker detained then released after girls’ hit-and-run deaths, arrested days later: officials

EXCLUSIVE: New Jersey authorities have unveiled 911 call recordings linked to a tragic alleged hit-and-run incident that claimed the lives of two teenage girls.

Isabella Salas and Maria Niotis lost their lives on September 29 while riding an electric bike. A 17-year-old male is accused of striking them with his vehicle around 5:26 p.m. in Cranford, New Jersey, according to the Union County Prosecutor’s Office. Both girls, aged 17, were declared dead shortly thereafter. The suspect’s identity remains confidential as he has not been tried as an adult.

Investigators report the suspect was behind the wheel of a 2021 black Jeep Compass during the incident. He faces charges including two counts of first-degree murder, alongside several traffic-related offenses.

Fox News Digital accessed the 911 audio and police documentation through a FOIA request, revealing that the suspect was released to his father following the alleged crimes. Additionally, records indicate that the father reached out to law enforcement after the hit-and-run took place.

Maria Niotis and Isabella Salas pictured in an edit in front of the crime scene

Following the fatal incident, authorities have accused a 17-year-old boy of being responsible for the deaths of the two teens.

One 911 caller described the suspect’s black SUV as having “flew down the road and hit people,” noting that one victim was found unresponsive.

The same person said there was “someone underneath a car,” adding, “This is really bad.”

“Nobody’s conscious,” said another caller. “Everyone’s stunned, not moving.”

“There’s a girl on the road, and there’s a car! Oh my god, please hurry!” another person said.

A separate caller, asked about the victim who was under the car, said it was “not looking good.”

Memorial for Maria Niotis and Isabella Salas.

A memorial for Maria Niotis and Isabella Salas. (FOX 5)

One of the callers told the 911 operator the suspect “took off” after the incident, headed toward the downtown area.

“It was flying, it was black. That’s all I know,” the caller could be heard saying.

“The car looks like it’s about to catch fire,” another 911 caller said.

In a statement to Fox News Digital, Union County Prosecutor’s Office Public Information Officer Lauren Farinas said the suspect was detained after the incident for questioning and released.

“Shortly after the incident on Monday, Sept. 29, the suspect was detained and questioned by law enforcement officers. The suspect was subsequently released pending further investigation. Officers then arrested the suspect on Wednesday morning, Oct. 1, after complaints were approved for two counts of first-degree murder,” Farinas wrote.

The 17-year-old is currently in custody, she said.

Niotis’ mother, Foulla Niotis, told Fox News in a previous interview that the suspect “planned” the attack and thought he was “untouchable” because he had relatives working in law enforcement.

She said local police didn’t take action when the family reported the suspect to law enforcement after he was allegedly stalking her daughter.

Foulla Niotis cries during an exclusive interview.

Foulla Niotis becomes emotional while speaking about her daughter’s death.  (Fox News)

“They should have done a lot. They didn’t do anything,” Niotis said of local law enforcement. “They didn’t do anything to help my baby.

“I want justice for Maria and Isabella. That’s what I want.”

You May Also Like

Suspect, victim dead after SWAT responds to 'active threat' at office complex near Tampa, Florida

Suspect and Victim Dead After SWAT Responds to Active Threat Near Tampa, Florida

A suspect died after authorities responded to an active shooter report at…
Pete Ricketts wins Nebraska Senate race, making Dan Osborn two-time loser

Pete Ricketts Wins Nebraska Senate Race, Defeats Dan Osborn

WASHINGTON — Sen. Pete Ricketts (R-Neb.) secured a full six-year Senate term…
Pilots' push to level jet may have torn off key piece found miles from Florida crash, former NTSB expert says

Ex-NTSB Expert: Pilots May Have Torn Off Jet Part in Florida Crash

Federal investigators have recovered a critical component from the Learjet 60 that…
Doctor who botched Christa Pike's execution had not placed IV line since 2013: report

Doctor Who Botched Christa Pike Execution Hadn’t Placed IV Since 2013

Dr. Mark Fowler, who supervised Christa Pike’s botched execution and served as…
Bend school district honors slain teacher, praises staff member's courage during attack: ‘Forever grateful’

911 Call Captures Oregon Dad’s Bravery Before He Stopped Elementary School Gunman

Newly released 911 audio captures the moment an Oregon father charged into…
Sean Duffy's son-in-law Michael Alfonso wins Wisconsin seat to become youngest House member

Michael Alfonso, Sean Duffy’s Son-in-Law, Wins Wisconsin House Seat as Youngest Member

Republican Michael Alfonso, the son-in-law of Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, won Wisconsin’s…
California's Prop 40 headed for defeat in early election results

California Prop. 40 Appears Headed for Defeat in Early Results

California’s fiercely contested billionaire tax appeared headed for defeat Tuesday night after…
‘DEI is back!’ screams California Dem Ro Khanna after losing Prop 40 tax vote he backed

California Rep. Ro Khanna Says ‘DEI Is Back’ After Prop 40 Loss

California Rep. Ro Khanna celebrated what he described as a resurgence of…
MICHAEL RUIZ: Charlie Kirk's accused assassin Tyler Robinson blames Trump's judge post in push for camera ban

Accused Assassin Tyler Robinson Cites Trump Judge Post in Camera Ban Push

Attorneys for Tyler Robinson, who is accused of assassinating Charlie Kirk, are…
10 alleged noncitizens indicted in massive California voter fraud investigation

10 Alleged Noncitizens Indicted in Massive California Voter Fraud Case

Ten alleged noncitizens were indicted Wednesday on federal election fraud charges, marking…
Thune: GOP Will Not Watch Dems Unwind Accomplishments of Senate

Thune: Senate Republicans Won’t Let Democrats Undo GOP Accomplishments

Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R-S.D.) vowed that Senate Republicans would not…
Test with lighter believed to have sparked Palisades fire fails to ignite brush

Test of Lighter Linked to Palisades Fire Fails to Ignite Brush

A lighter that prosecutors believe was used to start the Palisades Fire…