Alleged stalker detained then released after girls’ hit-and-run deaths, arrested days later: officials

EXCLUSIVE: New Jersey authorities have unveiled 911 call recordings linked to a tragic alleged hit-and-run incident that claimed the lives of two teenage girls.

Isabella Salas and Maria Niotis lost their lives on September 29 while riding an electric bike. A 17-year-old male is accused of striking them with his vehicle around 5:26 p.m. in Cranford, New Jersey, according to the Union County Prosecutor’s Office. Both girls, aged 17, were declared dead shortly thereafter. The suspect’s identity remains confidential as he has not been tried as an adult.

Investigators report the suspect was behind the wheel of a 2021 black Jeep Compass during the incident. He faces charges including two counts of first-degree murder, alongside several traffic-related offenses.

Fox News Digital accessed the 911 audio and police documentation through a FOIA request, revealing that the suspect was released to his father following the alleged crimes. Additionally, records indicate that the father reached out to law enforcement after the hit-and-run took place.

Maria Niotis and Isabella Salas pictured in an edit in front of the crime scene

Following the fatal incident, authorities have accused a 17-year-old boy of being responsible for the deaths of the two teens.

One 911 caller described the suspect’s black SUV as having “flew down the road and hit people,” noting that one victim was found unresponsive.

The same person said there was “someone underneath a car,” adding, “This is really bad.”

“Nobody’s conscious,” said another caller. “Everyone’s stunned, not moving.”

“There’s a girl on the road, and there’s a car! Oh my god, please hurry!” another person said.

A separate caller, asked about the victim who was under the car, said it was “not looking good.”

Memorial for Maria Niotis and Isabella Salas.

A memorial for Maria Niotis and Isabella Salas. (FOX 5)

One of the callers told the 911 operator the suspect “took off” after the incident, headed toward the downtown area.

“It was flying, it was black. That’s all I know,” the caller could be heard saying.

“The car looks like it’s about to catch fire,” another 911 caller said.

In a statement to Fox News Digital, Union County Prosecutor’s Office Public Information Officer Lauren Farinas said the suspect was detained after the incident for questioning and released.

“Shortly after the incident on Monday, Sept. 29, the suspect was detained and questioned by law enforcement officers. The suspect was subsequently released pending further investigation. Officers then arrested the suspect on Wednesday morning, Oct. 1, after complaints were approved for two counts of first-degree murder,” Farinas wrote.

The 17-year-old is currently in custody, she said.

Niotis’ mother, Foulla Niotis, told Fox News in a previous interview that the suspect “planned” the attack and thought he was “untouchable” because he had relatives working in law enforcement.

She said local police didn’t take action when the family reported the suspect to law enforcement after he was allegedly stalking her daughter.

Foulla Niotis cries during an exclusive interview.

Foulla Niotis becomes emotional while speaking about her daughter’s death.  (Fox News)

“They should have done a lot. They didn’t do anything,” Niotis said of local law enforcement. “They didn’t do anything to help my baby.

“I want justice for Maria and Isabella. That’s what I want.”

You May Also Like
Alex Murdaugh's lawyers withdraw request for civilian clothes, accuse prosecutors of creating a 'spectacle'

Alex Murdaugh’s Attorneys Drop Civilian Clothes Request, Accuse Prosecutors of Creating a Spectacle

Attorneys for Alex Murdaugh argue that prosecutors are attempting to make his…
Trump says Venezuela earthquakes left 'devastating number of deaths' as US readies aid

Trump Cites Devastating Death Toll From Venezuela Earthquakes as U.S. Prepares Aid

President Donald Trump said late Wednesday that a pair of powerful earthquakes…
Scottish World Cup Fan Hangs Out With Ron DeSantis—And Gives Haters a Master Class in Civility, Discourse

Scottish World Cup Fan Meets Ron DeSantis and Urges Civil Debate Amid Backlash

There has been plenty of buzz around Freddy from Germany and his…
Gavin Newsom fails to stop California billionaire tax as measure heads to November ballot

Gavin Newsom Loses Bid to Keep California Billionaire Tax Off November Ballot

Gov. Gavin Newsom was unable to strike an eleventh-hour agreement to keep…
Experts urge extreme caution on Iran's 'crown jewel' Hezbollah — terror group with US blood on its hands

Experts Warn Against Underestimating Hezbollah, Iran’s Key Proxy With a Deadly History Against Americans

Sen Sheehy warns of Iran’s ‘murderous regime’ as nuclear deal sparks debate…
NY girl, 3, dies from lice infestation, severe neglect after hoarding parents subjected her to 'horrific' conditions

NY Parents Accused in Daughter’s Lice-Infestation Death Sought Donations the Next Day

The upstate New York parents convicted after the appalling death of their…
Jets super fan who attempted 100K field goal returning to MetLife with World Cup tickets

Jets Superfan Returns to MetLife Stadium After $100K Field Goal Attempt to Score World Cup Tickets

Ashley Castanio-Gervasi had every reason to smile over this soccer surprise. The…
UN agency pauses evacuation of ships through the Strait of Hormuz after attack on vessel

UN Halts Strait of Hormuz Ship Evacuations After Vessel Attack Sparks Security Fears

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates — A United Nations agency halted a ship…
Maniac who set Virginia city councilman on fire in jealous rage learns his fate

Man Sentenced for Setting Virginia City Councilman on Fire in Jealous Attack

A Virginia man who set a city council member on fire in…
Harlem lawyer shares her American dream

Harlem Lawyer Reveals Her Inspiring Journey to the American Dream

Through July 4, The Post, in partnership with the Milken Center for…
Florida executes 74-year-old for wife's murder, becoming oldest inmate put to death in state's modern history

Florida Executes 74-Year-Old Man for Wife’s Murder, Oldest Inmate Put to Death in State’s Modern Era

A 74-year-old Florida man was put to death Thursday for the 1992…
United flight from Shanghai to San Francisco diverted to Tokyo due to passenger disturbance

United Shanghai to San Francisco Flight Diverts to Tokyo After Midair Passenger Disturbance

A United Airlines flight headed to San Francisco made an unexpected stop…