Two South Carolina men have been charged with murder in the road-rage shooting that killed a North Carolina man after his sister uncovered evidence challenging their original claim of self-defense. Two former police officers who participated in the investigation are also accused of official misconduct.
Scott Spivey, a 33-year-old insurance adjuster, died Sept. 9, 2023, following a car chase on Highway 9 in Horry County. The confrontation ended with Spivey being shot on Camp Swamp Road, roughly nine miles away.
Charles “Weldon” Boyd and Kenneth “Bradley” Williams initially invoked South Carolina’s “stand your ground” law, maintaining that they had been protecting themselves from a driver behaving irrationally.
Both men were arrested Wednesday, more than three years after the deadly encounter.
Brandon Strickland and Paul Vescovi, a former deputy chief and sergeant with the Horry County Police Department, also face charges that include misconduct in office and obstruction of justice, according to local reports.
Strickland, who allegedly spoke with Boyd by phone after the shooting, was additionally charged with criminal conspiracy.
All four defendants appeared in criminal court for an initial hearing Thursday afternoon.
After the roughly two-hour proceeding, the judge had not decided whether to grant their bond requests, Myrtle Beach-based WMBF-TV reported.
Separate bond rulings were expected to be posted later.
Court documents state that Spivey, Boyd and Williams were all carrying guns when the shooting occurred. Spivey eventually stopped, stepped out of his vehicle and shouted at Boyd and Williams to stop pursuing him.
The two men allegedly opened fire, killing Spivey in what an attorney for his sister later called “a hail of gunfire” in a wrongful death lawsuit.
Jennifer Spivey Foley, Spivey’s sister, found recordings from Boyd’s phone hidden in the police case file. The material had not previously been made public or incorporated into the investigation. The Wall Street Journal published the recordings last year, drawing national attention to the case.
Foley attended Thursday’s hearing and urged the judge to deny bond to Boyd and Williams. She also asked that Boyd undergo a mental health evaluation.
According to filings in the Spivey family’s wrongful death lawsuit, the recordings show Boyd telling a 911 dispatcher that Spivey was “trying to get away” while indicating that he was still prepared for a gunfight.
“If I see the gun again, I’m going to take the motherf—– down,” Boyd allegedly told the dispatcher, according to a 2024 civil complaint filed in the wrongful death case.
The lawsuit says Boyd stayed on the phone with the dispatcher until the shooting occurred.
He later allegedly called a friend who was serving as Horry County’s deputy police chief at the time, according to The Wall Street Journal.
Defense attorneys in the civil case contend that Spivey pointed a pistol at Williams’ head and forced Boyd’s truck off the road at the beginning of the confrontation. In a 911 call, a man identified as Boyd told the dispatcher that the other driver had fired first.
O’Bryan Martin, an attorney for Williams, rejected the suggestion that the shooting was anything other than an act of self-defense.
Attorneys for Boyd and Williams have argued in court filings that Spivey initiated the confrontation by pointing a gun through the window at Williams without provocation.
Martin also said other motorists had called 911 to report similar erratic driving before Spivey collided with Boyd’s truck on the highway.
“When you’re claiming self-defense, we always have to analyze, first and foremost: Well, who brought on the difficulty? Who caused this to start? Who started the fight, to boil it down? And if you’ve got any part in starting the fight, you can’t then turn around and claim self-defense,” Martin told Fox News Digital. “In this particular case, Scott Spivey set all this into motion.”
Martin further cited autopsy results showing that Spivey’s blood alcohol content was 0.13.
Circuit Court Judge Eugene Griffith, who is presiding over the family’s wrongful death lawsuit against Boyd and Williams, previously questioned Boyd’s credibility and allowed the civil case to continue in February.
Fox News Digital contacted attorneys for Boyd and the Spivey family for comment.
Court records show that attorneys for Boyd and Williams asked on Nov. 5 for the civil proceedings to be paused while a grand jury investigation was pending. Their clients were indicted within days.
“For over three years, Scott Spivey’s family has fought for something that should never have required a fight — the truth about how and why Scott was killed,” Mark Tinsley, the family’s attorney, said in a statement posted to Facebook.
“From the beginning, this family has believed that Scott’s death was not justified.”
A special prosecutor is handling the criminal case after local prosecutors previously declined to bring charges.
“The tragedy of this case is not just that Scott Spivey lost his life,” Tinsley added. “It is that his family had to fight the very system that was supposed to investigate his death to get to the truth.”
Spivey’s mother, Deborah Spivey, told “The Will Cain Show” last year that she rejected the “stand your ground” defense because her son was allegedly followed for nearly 10 miles before the fatal encounter.
“It does not fit the ‘stand your ground’ [law], when someone tries to de-escalate, tries to leave the scene,” she said. “It doesn’t fit that.”