Disabled 9-Year-Old Girl Found Partially Submerged in River Was Killed by Foster Mom

The custodial guardian of a 9-year-old Pennsylvania girl allegedly overdosed on Friday, a day after the girl’s body was recovered from a river.

District Attorney Michael Aubele informed WTAE that Renesmay Eutsey’s custodial parent survived an overdose at their Dunbar Township home where the child disappeared on Thursday. This parent and Kourtney Eutsey, 31, reported the child missing before Kourtney Eutsey reportedly took officers 20 miles to where the child’s body was found in the Youghiogheny River.

It’s important to highlight that Renesmay Eutsey’s legal guardian has not faced any criminal charges regarding her disappearance and passing. Nonetheless, Aubele indicated that further charges are anticipated as they suspect the child was frequently subject to abuse.

Aubele previously mentioned that the woman, whom Crime Online is withholding the name of since she hasn’t been charged, was Renesmay Eutsey’s court-appointed guardian and had a relationship with Kourtney Eutsey.

“Kourtney Eutsey served as the live-in caregiver… [She] had adopted at least one other child residing in the household. [Eutsey and the guardian] had a relationship where the children referred to Kourtney Eutsey as Mom and Sarah Shipley as Dad,” the prosecutor elaborated.

Reports suggest that Kourtney Eutsey directed police to her adoptive daughter’s body after some children in the home claimed they saw her kill Renesmay. One girl reportedly told officers she overheard Kourtney and another adult discuss taking Renesmay to a river “far, far away.” She recounted hearing the child’s cries followed by Kourtney and the other adult yelling at her and kicking her in the stomach.

Renesmay Eutsey allegedly weighed 45 pounds and bore evidence of abuse or neglect. Her injuries, such as cigarette burns, matched descriptions of the events that occurred at home, according to Aubele.

Kourtney Eutsey was charged with homicide, abuse of a corpse, endangering the welfare of children, aggravated assault, tampering with evidence, and concealing the death of a child.

Aubele said the other three children were removed from the home amid the ongoing criminal investigation.

[Feature Photo: Pennsylvania State Police]

You May Also Like

High-Stakes Border Pursuit: Fugitives Open Fire in Dramatic Cross-Border Chase

More than ten years after an intense cross-border pursuit marked by car…

Police Discover Man in Distress with Blanket Stuck to Injuries

Share An Indiana couple is facing serious allegations after they reportedly left…

Prominent Media Executive to Appear in Court Over Assault Allegations

Antony Catalano, a prominent figure in the media industry, is set to…

Mother Tragically Killed After Spotting Ex-Partner Watching Her, Police Report

Left: Joshua Thompson (Floyd County Jail). Right: Kaitlynn Lee (obituary). In a…

Tragic Incident: Husband Fatally Shoots Wife Over Dispute on Back Pain, Police Report

Inset: Jose Romero and Yanira Marin de Romero (Facebook). Background: The home…

Fox News Prevails in Court: Defamation Lawsuit Dismissed as ‘Conclusory

Left: Ray Epps is seen talking with accused Jan. 6 rioter and…

Fast Food Frenzy: Employee Arrested for Unauthorized Discounts Sparks Controversy

In Gainesville, Florida, a 27-year-old man named Jamel Earl Dennis was taken…

Florida Judge Reverses Previous Trump Administration Decision in Surprising Legal Turnaround

President Donald Trump stands outside the White House, Monday, Aug. 18, 2025,…

Gated Community Settles Lawsuit Following Tragic Alligator Attack on Grandmother

Inset: Holly Jenkins (Legacy.com/The Island Packet). Background: The area in South Carolina…

Fort White Woman Charged Following I-75 Road Rage Confrontation

In a concerning road rage incident on I-75 in Alachua County, Florida,…