Billionaire tax author says California measure may not be temporary

This week, a leading figure behind California’s contentious billionaire tax admitted that what is initially proposed as a one-time charge might ultimately become a lasting measure.

Emmanuel Saez, an economics professor, disclosed this possibility during a debate on Tuesday at the University of California, Berkeley. He was debating Arthur Laffer, known as the creator of trickle-down economics.

The proposed tax, backed by the Service Employees International Union–United Healthcare Workers West, aims to impose a single 5% tax on Californians whose assets exceed $1 billion.

Proponents argue that this tax is critical to bridging healthcare funding gaps, which have widened due to last year’s cuts to Medicaid and other federal programs.

Although the measure has not yet officially made it to the November ballot, supporters recently announced they had gathered the necessary signatures for it to qualify.

During the debate, the moderator questioned Saez about the tax’s potential permanence, referencing how taxes in California, introduced as temporary measures following the Great Recession, have often been extended.

The debate’s moderator pressed Saez about the possibility of the levy being more than a one-off, noting that previous California taxes initially deemed temporary after the Great Recession ended up getting extended.

“There’s been discussions of having another proposition to make it permanent,” said the moderator, who asked what would make the billionaire tax different.

Saez responded that the current proposal is focused on an “emergency funding need” for health care.

“It’s going to be an experiment. We see the results, and then we decide whether that experiment works, is promising,” he explained.

“If there is another one, I don’t think it’s going to be a one-time tax. You can’t surprise billionaires more than once.”

If the measure is adopted, the conversation could shift to establishing a permanent billionaire tax at a lower rate that lasts for several years, Saez said. The public will see whether other governments adopt California’s proposal or similar wealth tax initiatives, he added.

“It is true, I’m not there to pretend that it’s one, once, and never again — no wealth tax will ever happen after that one. You can’t commit to that,” he noted.

Laffer argued that billionaires who have already fled the state — including notable tech figures like Google co-founder Sergey Brin — may not return to California after the one-time tax expires over fears the state would do it again.

The proposed tax has sparked an election year fight with campaign ads and competing ballot initiatives. Many Democrats, including Gov. Gavin Newsom, also are against the billionaires tax, arguing it would hurt the state’s economy.

Billionaire gubernatorial candidate Tom Steyer, a Democrat, said at Wednesday night’s debate that he would vote for the proposed one-time tax, but “it doesn’t go far enough.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

FBI’s Groundbreaking DNA Technology Solves Decade-Long Serial Rape Case, A Major Win Against Illegal Immigration

An undocumented immigrant now faces 30 charges in connection with a series…

Saudi Arabia Halts ‘Project Freedom’: U.S. Military Access to Key Bases Denied

Two anonymous U.S. officials revealed to NBC News on Wednesday that President…

Teen Arrested in Times Square Stabbing After Turnstile Jump Catches Police Attention

In an unexpected turn of events, a teenager has been apprehended in…

Miami Instagram Trap: Woman and Accomplices Accused of Robbing Man in Luxury Condo Heist

A Florida woman has been taken into custody after allegedly luring a…

Alleged Assassin Luigi Mangione Inspires Surge in Crime Suspect Defenses

The individual apprehended on charges of igniting the devastating Palisades Fire early…

Texas Man Arrested for Shooting Incident Near Vance Motorcade in Washington D.C.

A suspect accused of firing shots in downtown Washington, D.C., on Tuesday,…

Heartwarming Baseball Bond: Cubs Fan Receives Kidney from Generous White Sox Supporter, Throws First Pitch at Wrigley

CHICAGO — At the Healthcare Workers Appreciation event held at Wrigley Field…

Governor Hochul’s Groundbreaking NYS Budget Deal: Boosting Support for Mamdani and NYC

Governor Kathy Hochul is set to reveal the major components of New…

Florida Man Reportedly Caught Driving at 101 mph Offers Unusual Explanation to Deputies

A Florida man’s urgent journey to attend a wedding took an unexpected…

Dutch Authorities Confirm Early Disembarkation of Approximately 40 Passengers from Ship Amid Hantavirus Outbreak

A Dutch cruise company has now confirmed that several passengers disembarked on…

DHS Criticizes Minnesota Board for Pardoning Immigrant with Assault Convictions

FOX FIRST: The U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is sharply criticizing…

Oklahoma Party Shooting: Suspect Apprehended in Tragic Incident Leaving 1 Dead, 22 Injured, Police Report

Authorities revealed on Wednesday that they have apprehended an 18-year-old in connection…