Pat Cummins said more than a dozen times that he could not remember specific details of the 2018 ball-tampering scandal. Cameron Bancroft’s detailed essay, however, has offered a markedly fuller account of what happened.
During a 68-minute press conference on Friday, Cummins used phrases such as “I can’t remember” and “I can’t recall” 15 times across 11 answers.
Asked whether he remembered a player using sandpaper on the ball in the Port Elizabeth dressing room, the Australian Test captain replied: “I don’t have a recollection exactly of that.”
When questioned about an alleged meeting after a player complained that the ball was moving too much, Cummins said: “Look, I don’t remember that but I don’t doubt that it would happen.”
Responding to Usman Khawaja’s claim that he had wanted the players to accept collective responsibility, Cummins said: “I don’t remember any team meeting where he stood up and said let’s all own this as a team.”
But in a 4,497-word essay published by The West on Wednesday, Bancroft gave a detailed account of the episode. He identified the tea break when the plan was discussed, named those present and revealed which member of the touring party objected before walking out.
Cameron Bancroft, pictured with former girlfriend Caitlin Paris in 2020, has written a 4,497-word essay about the 2018 ball-tampering scandal
Bancroft said the use of sandpaper was discussed during tea on the second day in Port Elizabeth, before he was caught tampering with the ball in Cape Town
Bancroft’s version of events contrasts with Pat Cummins’ account. The Australian captain said he could not remember specific details 15 times during last week’s press conference
The latest debate over the scandal was triggered by Khawaja’s autobiography, Sabr. In the book, he claimed the ball-tampering plan was first discussed during the second Test at Port Elizabeth, now known as Gqeberha, in 2018.
“It was all of us. Not the batters, not the bowlers, not the staff. All of us,” Khawaja said when describing the scandal.
Last week, Cummins called Khawaja “100 per cent wrong” for suggesting that the entire team knew about the plan.
He said players regularly discussed how they might respond when the ball began reversing.
However, later in the same answer, he again said he could not recall the specific conversation in question.
Bancroft said the “final straw” that led him to write the essay was Cummins using the press conference to dismiss Khawaja’s version of the scandal as “complete and utter nonsense”.
“It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone,” Bancroft wrote.
“What I saw, experienced and lived with—not only him, but everyone else on that tour in South Africa—is not the public account he gave in his press conference and in the years previously when he has spoken on this time.”
David Warner, Steve Smith and Cameron Bancroft were all sanctioned by Cricket Australia
Bancroft said the team was under considerable pressure when the plan was developed.
“It was in that environment that David Warner raised the possibility of using sandpaper to roughen one side of the ball,” he wrote.
“Dave explained that he could not carry out the task himself because of the attention television cameras were directing at him throughout the series.
“This was widely recognised by our entire touring party during the series. It was why we joked about it and why Dave began writing funny words on his finger tape. He had been under intense scrutiny and knew the cameras were watching him closely.
“I don’t believe Dave was acting purely for himself. I understood his suggestion as an attempt to help the team regain control of the match.
“That does not excuse his involvement or mine. But I believe it matters that the conversation took place in a wider team environment in which we were collectively desperate to make something happen.”
Bancroft said he had asked Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh whether the ball was reversing sufficiently.
In 2021, Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon said in a joint statement that they first realised a foreign substance had been taken onto the field when footage appeared on the big screen at Newlands.
Usman Khawaja wrote in his autobiography, Sabr, that the entire Australian team knew about the ball-tampering plan during the Test
Join the discussion
Should more players speak up about what really happened during cricket’s darkest scandal?
Bancroft wrote that revisiting the episode was painful because he remembered conversations on the field, feedback about the ball and celebrations shared during both Tests.
He was banned for nine months after being caught at Newlands. Warner and then-captain Steve Smith were each suspended for 12 months.
Bancroft also claimed that the team’s media manager, Kate Hutchison, was one of the few people to oppose the plan at the time.
“I recall her making it clear that she believed it was wrong, that she wanted nothing to do with it, and walking away from the discussion,” he wrote.
“I will never forget that. Somebody had spoken up.”
Neil Maxwell, Cummins’ manager, said on Thursday that the Test captain remained comfortable with the position he had held since 2018.
“Pat’s position hasn’t changed in eight years. He’s been consistent and adamant from day one,” Maxwell said.
“Pat feels for Cam, of course. He has been through a lot.
“We would urge people to read Pat’s interview transcript again. There is nothing he has not answered, including the points raised by Cam.
“Pat has rebuilt the Australian cricket team. That 24-year-old in Cape Town resolved to fix the team and spent eight years doing it.”
Darren Lehmann, who was Australia’s coach at the time, has promised to respond to the “allegations” in the coming days.
Cricket Australia said on Wednesday night that it also needed time to assess Bancroft’s claims.
“We respect that Cameron Bancroft has told his story, and we will take time to consider his comments,” the organisation said in a statement.
“We expect that there will be many dimensions to the events of 2018, which is why we have established the forum for individuals to give their version of events.”
The independent forum was created to provide players and staff from the tour with a confidential setting in which to share their accounts.
After receiving independent advice, the board will decide what information can be made public. Bancroft has said he is willing to take part.