No one could say for certain why Cole Palmer stormed down the tunnel after the final whistle while several of his Chelsea team-mates stayed behind to applaud the supporters who remained at Stamford Bridge.
Perhaps he was angry with himself after a subdued display in which he failed to score, create a goal or even force Leeds United goalkeeper James Trafford into a meaningful save. Perhaps he had little interest in acknowledging fans who had booed as Chelsea fell 4-1 behind. Or perhaps, quite simply, he hates losing.
Most elite players share that competitive streak, and many are capable of revealing an irritable side when a match begins to slip away.
Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes is an extreme example. Supporters at Old Trafford have long tolerated his reputation as one of the Premier League’s most volatile figures because of the numbers he can deliver, even if his complaints have produced less this season during United’s struggles.
Star players can usually afford a degree of petulance when their performances justify it. Palmer, however, has little cover at present. The 24-year-old England international delivered another largely anonymous 90 minutes, which was particularly damaging for Chelsea.
His frustration had been visible before the final whistle. As Chelsea chased the game, he repeatedly appeared to play simple passes backwards in an exaggerated manner, almost as though he wanted to make clear that he had no better option. It is a reaction we have seen from him during other Chelsea defeats, but it does little to ease the pressure on the manager. Instead, it suggests that Palmer is unhappy with the tactical structure around him.
Cole Palmer and Joao Pedro were involved in a frosty exchange following Chelsea’s 4-1 home defeat by Leeds. Source: Instagram/farihaxchels
As the most recognisable player in the Chelsea squad, and the one whose profile extends far beyond that of his team-mates, Palmer inevitably becomes the central figure whenever the club is struggling.
When he is at his best, the praise is relentless. Every drop of the shoulder, every twist past a defender and every moment of invention is celebrated as evidence of his remarkable talent. His extraordinary 2023-24 statistics remain the benchmark against which he is still judged, even though they were almost absurdly impressive.
But poor performances bring responsibility as well as applause. When Palmer is struggling, he must also accept criticism, including the wave of boos directed at the Chelsea players inside Stamford Bridge.
Leeds had not won at this stadium since 1999. They ended that run in emphatic fashion, and then Palmer added to the unease with his reaction at full-time.
It was not the response Chelsea would have wanted from a player who was supposed to embody the cultural change the club sought over the summer. After years of youthful squads, they added experience to the dressing room in the form of Danny Welbeck, the 35-year-old Palmer has nicknamed their new ‘Unc’ following Tosin Adarabioyo’s departure, and 36-year-old Jordan Henderson.
Cole Palmer
For a player now in his fourth season at the club that gave him his opportunity after paying Manchester City £42.5million for him in 2023, it was an underwhelming display. Palmer should be establishing himself as a leader by now, not appearing to retreat from the responsibility.
He remains, most likely, undroppable. Alonso would invite a major problem by suddenly leaving his No 10 on the bench for next week’s meeting with Nottingham Forest. Yet the fact that such a possibility can even be discussed is a warning sign, particularly when Palmer should be pushing to earn a recall to Thomas Tuchel’s England squad.
Both Palmer and Levi Colwill are reportedly eager to return to international football, but neither has been performing at that level recently. Colwill looks short of confidence, second-guessing himself and making costly errors. During this dispiriting defeat by Leeds, he sent a long pass directly out of play before visibly berating himself.
There is no question Colwill can produce excellent performances. Bayern Munich and several other major clubs would not have shown interest in him if they did not view him as an elite defender. This is a difficult spell, but, like Palmer, he has the ability to recover.
Sack Alonso? Patience is the name of the game
Predictably, some supporters on social media immediately called for Alonso to be dismissed.
To be clear, there is no indication that Chelsea’s hierarchy is preparing to sack him. He is only 11 Premier League matches into his tenure and plainly deserves more time to build his team.
Alonso must accept responsibility for the tactics, but he is also working around problems beyond his control, including weaknesses in the squad and a growing injury list. Chelsea were dealt another blow in this match when influential vice-captain Moises Caicedo was forced off after just 22 minutes.
Xabi Alonso has made errors but was rightly considered a huge coup when Chelsea landed him
When Alonso took charge of Bayer Leverkusen in October 2022, his early Bundesliga results were far from consistent. He began with a 4-0 victory over Schalke, then failed to win any of his next three games.
Leverkusen responded with five consecutive victories, only to win once in their following five matches. Another five-game winning run followed, before a miserable sequence in which they claimed just one victory from seven.
The next season, however, Alonso guided Leverkusen to the Bundesliga title without suffering a single defeat. Chelsea knew they had secured a major appointment in the summer, and patience is warranted from my perspective, even amid this miserable run of form.
It’s not worth it for Gusto
It is increasingly difficult to imagine Malo Gusto having a long-term future at Chelsea.
The French full-back was effectively priced out of a summer transfer when Chelsea demanded £75million. Liverpool, Manchester City and several European clubs had expressed interest in signing him during that window.
Malo Gusto cut a lonely figure after being beaten for Leeds’s fourth goal
Yet the 23-year-old has offered little evidence as the season has progressed that he is worth such a valuation.
Gusto started five of Alonso’s first six matches in all competitions at the beginning of the campaign.
Since then, he has made only one start in eight games, and that came in the Carabao Cup against Liverpool. Introduced from the bench against Leeds, he attempted to catch Brenden Aaronson offside, failed, and was then beaten by the forward as the visitors scored their fourth goal.
With the January transfer window approaching, more clarity on Gusto’s Chelsea future is likely to follow.