The Nations Championship has added a welcome competitive edge to the summer and autumn internationals, but the new format has also left coaches with less room to experiment.
Every Test in the tournament, which brings together teams from the northern and southern hemispheres, now carries greater significance. Results feed into the standings, with nations battling to secure the strongest possible position before the finals weekend in London.
With a prize at stake in every fixture, and the traditional one-sided meeting with a developing side such as the USA or Portugal removed from the schedule, head coaches have understandably been cautious about straying too far from their best combinations.
With the World Cup less than a year away, squads are beginning to take shape. For younger players and those still on the fringes, the opportunities to force their way into the 33-man group heading to Australia next October and November are becoming increasingly limited.
That makes Saturday’s final pool match against Japan particularly important for Scotland. It offers Gregor Townsend the chance to widen his selection pool and gives players who have not featured this autumn — or have only made brief appearances — an opportunity to demonstrate their value.
Japan, coached by Eddie Jones and ranked 12th in the world, should not be underestimated. However, after defeats by Wales and a heavy loss to England last weekend, they appear less formidable than New Zealand were a fortnight ago or Australia proved to be last Saturday. Townsend is unlikely to have a better opportunity to rotate his squad.
Ollie Leatherbarrow makes his first Scotland start after debuting against Australia
The head coach has made 11 changes to the XV that edged past the Wallabies. Several switches have been forced by injuries, with Sione Tuipulotu, Scott Cummings, Ben White, Jack Dempsey, Fergus Burke, Alex Craig and Pierre Schoeman all unavailable. Others, however, are deliberate selections.
It may be premature to label anyone a World Cup bolter, but Ollie Leatherbarrow has clearly been handed an opportunity to make an impression. Townsend’s decision to promote a Newcastle Red Bulls player could invite scrutiny because of the coach’s consultancy links with Red Bull, although Leatherbarrow must still prove he merits his selection.
The only uncapped player in the squad, the back-rower came off the bench for his debut last weekend. He now starts at No 8 in place of the injured Dempsey.
Leatherbarrow is joined in the back row by Liam McConnell, who has impressed during Edinburgh’s excellent start to the season, particularly with his ability to win turnovers at the lineout. Rory Hutchinson partners Stafford McDowall in a new midfield combination, while veteran lock Jonny Gray returns partly because of Scotland’s injury problems in the second row.
Although the changes represent a significant reshuffle, the team could arguably have been altered even further. Josh McKay’s anticipated international switch will have to wait at least another week after the Glasgow full-back, now eligible through residency, was left out of the matchday 23. Instead, Ollie Smith, a player Townsend knows well, starts at full-back.
‘Josh wasn’t able to train fully, or really at all, during the first week of camp because of a calf injury,’ said Townsend. ‘That was a factor because he still hadn’t completed a full training week by the middle of last week. Now he’s ready to play.
‘We know we have one more game and Josh could be involved next week. But if he isn’t, it wouldn’t alter our view of him, and I hope it wouldn’t affect his motivation to push for a place in the Six Nations or World Cup squads. He is in contention for next week.’
Townsend has made 11 changes to the side that faced Australia
A minor injury has prevented Josh Bayliss from moving from impact substitute to starter, while renowned jackal specialist Freddy Douglas has also been omitted. Townsend has opted instead for the greater versatility of Magnus Bradbury on the bench.
Duhan van der Merwe’s omission is another notable talking point. Once Scotland’s leading all-time try scorer before Darcy Graham surpassed him, the winger has now been left out of the matchday squad for Japan. His decline has been influenced by inconsistent form and fitness issues in recent seasons, but Townsend insists his international career is far from over.
‘The back three is a position where we don’t have any injuries, and we felt this was the combination that trained best, so they have earned the opportunity to start,’ the coach explained.
‘Duhan knows he has to put the work in. I also think he needs a bit of luck. He had injuries coming into this year.
‘What we have seen from him, particularly this week, is someone highly motivated to give something back to the team. At his best, he is one of the finest wingers in the world.’
Liam McConnell has been selected alongside Stafford McDowall in the new-look midfield
Townsend has rested Finn Russell, Huw Jones and Ewan Ashman, although several of his regulars have been asked to continue. Rory Darge captains the side despite a heavy recent workload, while Zander Fagerson retains the No 3 jersey despite struggling to rediscover his best form.
‘Zander has played a lot of rugby, but we manage the front row’s minutes carefully,’ Townsend added. ‘He is in the best condition I have seen him in for several years. His training has been excellent and his conditioning is outstanding.
‘Rory is an exceptional person and player. What he produces week after week is phenomenal. We know we are asking a lot of these players by selecting them for four consecutive Tests, but we believe both of them are capable of delivering.’