The horse Bobby Flay couldn't sell has long-shot Belmont Stakes dream

The Unsellable Horse Owned by Bobby Flay Aims for a Surprise Victory at Belmont Stakes

SARATOGA SPRINGS — With 15-1 odds, Crudo is unlikely to beat Kentucky Derby victor Sovereignty and Preakness winner Journalism in Saturday’s Belmont Stakes at Saratoga.

However, one might suggest that this result would be no more unexpected than the series of events that brought Crudo into the Triple Crown competition initially for his owners Bobby Flay and Jimmy Ventura along with Hall of Fame trainer Todd Pletcher.

“Jimmy and I initially intended to purchase him as a pinhook investment — we acquired him as a weanling with plans to sell him as a yearling. We brought him to the Saratoga [Fasig-Tipton] auction, but he didn’t sell, so we ended up keeping him,” said Flay, the chef, restaurant mogul, and Food Network celebrity to The Post early on Friday morning before checking on Crudo.

“I don’t usually race colts. I usually race fillies only. But I have him, so he’s racing, and he’s turned out to have talent,” Flay continued. “The Belmont Stakes is New York’s most important race and as a New Yorker, it’s clearly important to me.”

Flay, 60, says he’s been watching horse racing since his teenage years when he and his friends from the Yorkville neighborhood in upper Manhattan would cut school and take the A train to Aqueduct.

The Belmont Stakes has long been a staple of Flay’s social calendar.

“I go to the Belmont every year. I usually take 20-30 people to Belmont Park and make a day out of it,” Flay said. “It’s become a tradition where I have people over to my house for brunch, everyone comes dressed in their racing gear — suits, summer dresses, hats. I feed them in the morning and then put everyone in cars and we go to Belmont and we have a day.”

He said those nights usually end with a group dinner at Wolfgang’s Steakhouse on 33rd Street.

But Saturday, the stakes will be much higher.

On Preakness Day at Pimlico, in his third career start, Crudo won the Sir Barton Stakes by 7¹/₂ lengths.

Pletcher, a four-time winner in the Belmont, gave the son of 2018 Triple Crown champion Justify a few weeks to breeze, considered other options and decided to give it a go in the $2 million race.

“The horse is here, he’s doing well, I don’t see a whole lot of pace in the race, we’ve got [jockey] John Velazquez available,” Pletcher said. “I couldn’t come up with a reason not to give it a try.”

Crudo’s name, not surprisingly, has ties to the culinary world.

“I came up with the name,” Flay said, explaining he acknowledged raw talent, though on menus everywhere the word means raw fish. “It’s so hard to name these horses. I liked the fact that it meant raw because he was such a young horse when we bought him and he had talent.

“I told Jimmy what I named him and he was like, ‘Really?’ He wasn’t impressed,” Flay added about his partner, who is in commercial real estate and has been involved in horse racing for more than 30 years. “Naming horses and naming restaurants. If they turn out to be good, the name makes perfect sense. It couldn’t be anything else.”

Flay spent much of his spring rooting on his beloved Knicks from the first few rows at Madison Square Garden.

Like most fans, he reveled in the team’s longest playoff run in 25 years and still is feeling the disappointment.

“I remember all the playoff seasons when we ran into Michael Jordan,” said Flay, who lists the Knicks and Yankees as his biggest sports passions. “We were good then, but we kind of couldn’t get past it. It was fun to watch those guys play this year. They’re a really good team and, unfortunately, they lost to Indiana.”

Flay said he was surprised at the firing of coach Tom Thibodeau.

“I am. I thought he did a good job. I mean, we beat the world champions. We beat the Celtics soundly,” he said. “A couple things go different ways and you’re in the Finals. I don’t always think that new is a good idea, but it’s not my team.”

His team on Saturday is Crudo-Flay-Ventura-Pletcher.

“Both Bobby and Jimmy love horse racing. Bobby’s been terrific to train for, for a number of years,” Pletcher said. “He’s knowledgeable and also always says, ‘You can make the decision.’ We’ve had some success together and these guys are fun to train for.”

You May Also Like

The Aftermath of the Blue Tsunami of 2026: 'Donald Trump Is the Devil'

2026 Blue Tsunami Aftermath: ‘Donald Trump Is the Devil’

In his 1951 book “The True Believer: Thoughts on the Nature of…
Fugitive charged with leaking intel to ex-Olympian’s drug cartel

Fugitive Charged With Leaking Intel to Ex-Olympian’s Drug Cartel

Roberto Gomez, an alleged South Los Angeles gang member with ties to…
Dems launch sexual harassment probe against newly elected Brian Poindexter -- who ousted GOP Rep. Max Miller 

Dems Open Sexual Harassment Probe Into New Rep. Brian Poindexter

Brian Poindexter, the Bernie Sanders-backed Democrat who defeated embattled Republican Rep. Max…
Undefeated New York high school football team kicked out of playoffs

Undefeated New York High School Football Team Ousted From Playoffs

It took just 53 seconds to derail an otherwise perfect season. Middletown…
Alex Murdaugh wants murder indictments dismissed, saying agent lied to grand jury

Alex Murdaugh Seeks Dismissal of Murder Indictments, Claims Agent Lied to Grand Jury

Attorneys for Alex Murdaugh are expected to appear in court Friday and…
LAPD chief and Nithya Raman agree on mental health 911 response

LAPD Chief, Councilmember Nithya Raman Agree on Mental Health 911 Response Plan

LAPD Chief Jim McDonnell says the department needs more mental-health professionals to…
Massachusetts lunatic allegedly stabs sister to death -- and claims she was possessed by demons

Massachusetts Woman Charged With Killing Sister, Claims Demons

A Massachusetts man allegedly stabbed his sister to death before calling 911…
Veteran Dem strategist unleashes super PAC to block DSA in NY: 'They're not Democrats'

Veteran Democratic Strategist Launches Super PAC to Counter DSA Candidates in New York

Veteran campaign strategist Hank Sheinkopf is refashioning his super PAC into an…
Illinois bomb threat at Peoria ethanol plant prompts mile wide evacuation

Bomb Threat at Peoria Ethanol Plant Triggers Mile-Wide Evacuation

A bomb threat at an ethanol plant triggered a large-scale evacuation in…
MICHAEL RUIZ: JonBenet Ramsey investigators are retesting evidence with newer technology, police chief says

JonBenet Ramsey Investigators Retest Evidence With New Technology, Police Chief Says

Investigators in Boulder are reexamining and retesting evidence collected decades ago in…
School investigating after viral video shows 10th-grade girl punched, put in chokehold on Ohio school bus

Ohio School Investigates Viral Video of 10th-Grader Punched, Choked on Bus

An Ohio school board is investigating an assault involving a 10th-grade girl…
NY education boss demands state fork over massive funding increase to replace Regents

New York Education Chief Seeks Major Funding Boost to Replace Regents

New York’s education commissioner is urging Gov. Kathy Hochul and state lawmakers…