Devil’s Den ‘Killer’ Probed in Unsolved Devil’s Lake Murder of John Schmutzer
Share this @internewscast.com

In Wisconsin, authorities are reexamining the case of a 24-year-old hiker’s murder at Devil’s Lake after the arrest of an individual suspected of murdering a couple at Devil’s Den State Park in Arkansas.

According to KARK, Sauk County Sheriff’s Office investigators in Wisconsin are looking into a possible connection between the 2020 murder of John Schmutzer, and the July murders of Clinton Brink, 43, and Cristen Brink, 41.

Police found Schmutzer stabbed to death on the Grottos Trail at Devil’s Lake State Park, a little after 11:30 a.m., on October 14, 2020.

As CrimeOnline previously reported, police in Arkansas arrested Andrew James McGann, 28, several days after the July 26 murders of the Brinks couple. They were found stabbed to death on a walking trail at the park in West Fork.

A week after McGann’s arrest, the Sauk County Sheriff’s Office began receiving tips on the Arkansas case, with requests to analyze DNA, which could rule McGann out or determine that he’s a suspect in Schmutzer’s death.

Spectrum News reports that Sauk County Sheriff’s Office detective sergeant Drew Bulin stated that the tips came in from people in both states. He said the sheriff’s office has requested information from Arkansas and will compare information.

Tipsters in Schmutzer’s death described the suspect as a white male around 5 feet, 10 inches to 6 feet tall, dressed in dark-colored clothing, with a dark-colored mask and backpack.

The man, who, according to witnesses, had been acting erratic, fled the scene, according to TMJ4. No arrests have been made.

In the Arkansas case, the accused killer was also dressed in dark-colored clothing while wearing sunglasses, a baseball cap, and fingerless gloves. He also had a black backpack.

Schmutzer had been hiking alone, while in the Brink case, the couple had been hiking together with their two young daughters.

Both children escaped unharmed and are now with family members.

Anyone with information about the Devil’s Lake case is urged to contact Detective Drew Bulin at drew.bulin@saukcountygov.gov.

Check back for updates.

[Feature Photos: John Schmutzer/Sauk County SO; James Andrew McGann/Washington County Detention Center]

Share this @internewscast.com
You May Also Like

WSU Professor Feared Kohberger Could Pose a Threat to Students if Promoted to Faculty

Recently disclosed documents from the Idaho State Police have brought to light…

Woman Fatally Stabbed in Suspected Domestic Violence Incident

A woman in her 30s has been stabbed to death in a…

DOJ Reports Woman’s Threat to Harm Trump

President Donald Trump stands outside the White House, Monday, Aug. 18, 2025,…

Video footage reveals murder of 94-year-old by son-in-law: Police

Sy Van Nguyen was suffocated by his son-in-law at his Santa Rosa,…

Police: Man Fatally Shoots Driver for ‘Driving Very Slowly’

Left inset: Jaden Harris (Seminole County). Right inset: Joseph Hall Jr. (Sailors…

Atlanta Resident Arrested for Ingenious Plot to Take Over Home Ownership

Staff report GAINESVILLE, Fla. – Edward Luke Chappel, 45, of Atlanta, was…

Court Reveals Reality TV Star Provided $10,000 to Family of Injured Pilot

Reality TV star Matt Wright offered $10,000 to the family of a…

Father Allegedly Gave Newborn Lethal Amount of Alcohol and Meth, Authorities Report

Inset: Robert Jenkins Jr. (Altoona Police Dept.). Background: The area in Pennsylvania…

Woman Kills Husband Following Argument About Open Relationship

Left: Cheryl Coe (Coweta County Sheriff”s Office). Right: Luther “Luke” Coe III…

Surveillance Footage of Sydney Salon Attacks Made Public

New CCTV has been released as police investigate two attacks on a…

Woman Accused of Setting House on Fire with Mother and Boyfriend Inside: Police Report

Inset: Sarah Shelburne (Nelson County Detention Center). Background: The home Shelburne allegedly…

Bryan Kohberger Alleges Sexual Harassment by Fellow Inmates in Prison

The individual who admitted to killing four University of Idaho students at…