Convicted 'Ten Most Wanted’ fugitive faked bloody death, resurfaced as student before capture: authorities

A notorious sex offender, once listed among Oklahoma’s Ten Most Wanted fugitives, has been apprehended after allegedly orchestrating an elaborate scheme to fake his own death. Anthony Lennon reportedly evaded capture for nearly 13 years by enrolling in a university in New York.

The U.S. Marshals Service announced that Lennon was arrested last week in Canton, New York. His capture marks the end of a lengthy pursuit dating back to his initial conviction in 2008 for child pornography, which resulted in a 20-year suspended sentence.

Despite his conviction, Lennon found himself back under criminal scrutiny in 2012 when authorities uncovered new allegations. Officials discovered that he was allegedly in possession of additional child pornography, with evidence including disturbing chat logs, external drives, and explicit videos involving minors found at his residence.

A photo of Anthony Lennon's arrest in New York

As law enforcement officers prepared to arrest Lennon at a Super 8 Motel in Moore, Oklahoma, they encountered a scene designed to mislead them. According to reports, Lennon had staged a fake abduction and robbery, complete with falsified evidence, in a bid to make it appear as if he had been forcibly taken.

His elaborate ruse, however, ultimately failed to prevent his capture. Now, after years of eluding justice, Lennon faces the consequences of his actions as he returns to face charges stemming from his alleged crimes in Oklahoma.

As authorities closed in on the Super 8 Motel in Moore, Oklahoma, to arrest Lennon on additional charges, they realized that he had “staged an elaborate and bloody abduction and robbery scene, leaving behind falsified evidence to make it appear he had been abducted,” according to officials.

After successfully evading arrest, Lennon remained on the run for 13 years.

Anthony Lennon's mugshot in Oklahoma

Anthony Lennon was previously convicted of numerous child pornography charges in Oklahoma, and was one of the state’s “Ten Most Wanted” fugitives. (U.S. Marshals Service )

“He went to extremes, and we did determine that the large amount of blood at the staged crime scene actually was his,” Moore Poli​​ce Chief Todd Gibson said in a news conference, according to People.

While on the run, Lennon allegedly adopted the alias “Justin Phillips,” and was enrolled in college at the State University of New York at Canton at the time of his arrest, NNY360 reported. According to the U.S. Marshals Service, Lennon had previously earned a master’s degree in computer science and was working to obtain a doctorate at the time of his disappearance.

Detectives subsequently interviewed Lennon under his alias and used fingerprint analysis to confirm his identity, police said. He was taken into custody in New York and is awaiting extradition to Oklahoma, People reported.

A photo of Anthony Lennon's arrest in New York

Anthony Lennon was allegedly living in New York under the alias “Justin Phillips” at the time of his capture, according to authorities. (U.S. Marshals Service )

Authorities are also working to determine if Lennon committed any additional crimes while on the run, according to 7News.

“This case remains active and under investigation,” the U.S. Marshals Service said in a statement. “But with his capture we can now begin the process of holding Lennon accountable for the crimes he committed against children in our community.”

The U.S. Marshals Service did not immediately respond to Fox News Digital’s request for comment. 

You May Also Like
Wife speaks out after husband allegedly strangles disabled daughter to death in New Jersey

New Jersey Wife Breaks Silence After Husband Allegedly Strangles Disabled Daughter to Death

FRANKLIN TWP., N.J. — The family of Devin Hall is now preparing…
U.S. Southern Command strike

US Military Kills Three Suspected Narco-Terrorists in Latest Eastern Pacific Vessel Strike

The U.S. military said it carried out a deadly strike Thursday against…
From bear hugs to handshakes: How India lost its edge with Trump while Pakistan quietly gained ground

India’s Trump Reset Falters as Pakistan Quietly Gains Ground in US Ties

President Donald Trump and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi met in person…
Luigi Mangione battles to block key evidence a year after CEO assassination — experts say it’s a long shot

Luigi Mangione’s Emotional Disturbance Defense Could Reshape His Other Case, Lawyer Says

Attorneys for Luigi Mangione, the 28-year-old former Ivy Leaguer charged in the…
Austin Metcalf’s dad supported Karmelo Anthony judge’s hard line on cameras

Jeff Metcalf Breaks His Silence on Son Austin’s Death—How His Family Is Finding Strength and Moving Forward

FRISCO, Texas — Jeff Metcalf, whose son Austin Metcalf was killed in…
US and Iran sign initial deal to end war, ease sanctions and open strait as nuclear talks continue

US-Iran Initial Deal Signals Path to Ending Conflict, Easing Sanctions and Reopening Strait

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump on Wednesday signed an accord with Iran…
Stacey King funeral: Celebration of life honors Chicago Bulls legend, 3-time NBA champion, broadcaster, who died at 59

Stacey King Remembered: Chicago Bulls Champion and Broadcaster Honored at Celebration of Life

OAKBROOK TERRACE, Ill. (WLS) — Family, friends and former colleagues gathered Thursday…
Palisades Fire suspect allegedly driven by 'societal revenge,' behavioral analyst testifies in court

Behavioral Analyst Says Palisades Fire Suspect Was Motivated by ‘Societal Revenge,’ Court Hears

Palisades arson trial begins Testimony in the federal arson trial of Jonathan…
Less than half of Americans can afford quality healthcare, Gallup finds

Gallup: Fewer Than Half of Americans Can Afford Quality Healthcare

Fewer than half of Americans were able to afford medical bills and…
Evanston's Juneteenth parade to honor legacy of Opal Lee with granddaughter, Dione Sims, as grand marshal

Evanston’s Juneteenth Parade to Honor Opal Lee’s Legacy, with Granddaughter Dione Sims Named Grand Marshal

EVANSTON, Ill. (WLS) — Evanston’s yearly Juneteenth parade is set to start…
Hollywood Is Having An Inflection Moment As Established Properties Are Getting Hammered by the Upstarts

Hollywood Inflection Point: New Upstarts Overtake Established Franchises at the Box Office

Through this point in 2026, the domestic box office has posted an…
Streator, Illinois City Council approves emergency declaration as tornado recovery continues

Streator City Council Approves Emergency Declaration as Tornado Recovery Efforts Continue

Streator city leaders have unanimously approved an emergency declaration as the community…