Asking Eric: Informal music group marred by tone-deaf participant


Discord in Harmony: Tone-Deaf Member Challenges Cohesion of Informal Music Group 'Asking Eric

Dear Eric: Our circle of friends regularly gathers to enjoy making music together. This casual ensemble meets in a public setting and prides itself on being inclusive, inviting musicians of all abilities to join in and play.

Nevertheless, we face a dilemma with one particular participant. She attends with her husband, who is a talented musician, yet her skills are lacking, resulting in random sounds that disrupt the harmony.

We’ve received feedback from others who appreciate our musical talents but express that her contribution detracts from the overall sound. While we share this sentiment, we also care deeply for her and want to avoid causing any hurt. Additionally, her husband is a key member and leader within our group, and maintaining a good relationship with him is important.

Do you have any advice on how we might gently encourage her to improve her skills or suggest she refrain from playing?

– Not in the Band

Dear Band: You’ve defined your gathering as an inclusive space, open to all, yet you’re considering imposing restrictions on one individual. This raises the question: is it truly open and welcoming or selectively so?

Now, I’m not unsympathetic to what you’re experiencing. You play music for the joy of making and the joy of performing. So, someone who isn’t playing in harmony (pun slightly intended) with the rest of the group can be disruptive or change the experience.

On the other hand, it’s likely that she has a completely different expectation of the group, namely that it’s a place where you can come as you are and play however you’d like. So, you could ask her if she’s open to feedback about her playing. She could say “no, thank you,” of course. But if she has an interest in improving, you should come prepared with actual steps she can take, be it switching instruments or taking lessons or something else.

More broadly, the group needs to decide whether it has different rules or not. Your relationship with this woman and her husband will continue to be fraught if you’re thinking of this group as “for everyone” but “everyone” comes with an asterisk.

Dear Eric: I became a widow two years ago after a long and happy marriage. I have one surviving son who is married and lives about 80 miles away in another state.

I rarely see my son, when I do see him, it is always just for the holidays. We talk on the phone frequently and he asks for money even though he receives an allowance from our family trust.

They often change plans last minute around the holidays which I go to great lengths to prepare for, shopping, cooking, decorating. I am never invited to their home. Our visits are cordial but brief.

This past Christmas they canceled due to illness and came the weekend after. I had cooked his favorite holiday dishes. When they did come, we went out to a restaurant. During the meal we made small talk and the rest of the time he was scrolling on his phone.

At one point I asked him very nicely to please put the phone away and engage with me. That lasted for a few minutes and then he continued scrolling.

I miss him, I miss seeing his face and getting a warm hug. I thought we had formed a strong familial bond. Should I just accept the status quo or try to have a meaningful conversation with him? I don’t want to push him away.

– Lonely Mother

Dear Mother: Try to have a meaningful conversation. It can be a real gift to ask for what you need from loved ones. It tells them where you are and how they can show their love more effectively to you.

When you do, lead with “I” statements, just as you did here: I miss you, I’d like to be closer, would it be possible to… (and then make a specific suggestion about something you’d like to change).

It would also be helpful for you to think about what you’re expecting from your relationship with your son. I don’t think what you want is unreasonable by any means, but from your description his actions read as dismissive and disrespectful. One way to counteract dismissive behavior is to set an internal boundary. You can, for instance, decide that you won’t make his favorite foods for the next holiday because he has a habit of canceling. And it’s fine to tell him that, too. If he wants the food, he can adjust his behavior and then you can decide if that change motivates you to start making dinner again.

You don’t have to settle for the crumbs of your son’s attention. Indeed, by asking for more, you might be able to get more.

(Send questions to R. Eric Thomas at eric@askingeric.com or P.O. Box 22474, Philadelphia, PA 19110. Follow him on Instagram and sign up for his weekly newsletter at rericthomas.com.)

©2026 Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

You May Also Like

Mamdani guts elite NYPD tactical unit, backs 'civilian-led approach' to responding to protests

NYC Mayor Mamdani Cuts Elite NYPD Unit, Backs Civilian Protest Plan

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced Monday that the NYPD’s Strategic…
Charlamagne tha God blasts Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez for ‘beating around the bush,’ presses progressives on backing Hakeem Jeffries

Charlamagne tha God Blasts AOC Over Hakeem Jeffries Support

Radio personality Charlamagne tha God criticized Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., on Friday,…
Lindsay Clancy prosecutors come across as 'tone deaf,' 'uncaring' and 'snarky,' defense attorney says

Massachusetts Mom Lindsay Clancy Faces New Murder Trial

A Massachusetts judge has scheduled March 29 for the start of Lindsay…
'Finance bros' torturing NYC residents with wild Chelsea rooftop parties featuring dozens of revelers

Chelsea Rooftop Parties by ‘Finance Bros’ Spark Noise Complaints From NYC Residents

Rambunctious groups of “finance bros” have turned a quiet Chelsea block into…
Florida man sends letter filled with peanut butter to allergic ex-wife's friend: cops

Florida Man Accused of Peanut Butter Letter to Ex’s Allergic Friend

He’s nuts! A Florida man allegedly filled a card with peanut butter…
Two public safety officers shot at NYC housing complex; suspect dead

2 Public Safety Officers Shot at NYC Housing Complex; Suspect Dead

Two public safety officers were shot Monday at a New York City…
Fire outside MetLife Stadium sends smoke billowing over empty field after Jets' fifth straight loss

Fire Outside MetLife Stadium Sends Smoke Over Field After Jets’ Fifth Straight Loss

A fire erupted in an empty tent outside New Jersey’s MetLife Stadium…
Pentagon ignored warnings before Iran drone killed 6 US service members in Kuwait, whistleblower claims

Pentagon Ignored Iran Drone Warnings Before 6 US Troops Died

US military officials dismissed warnings that a command post in Kuwait lacked…
Spain's Canary Islands flooded by thousands of migrants as country declares emergency

Canary Islands Declare Emergency as Thousands of Migrants Arrive

Thousands of migrants arrived in Spain’s Canary Islands over the weekend as…
Emergency crews responding to vessel collision near Port of New Orleans on Mississippi River

Emergency Crews Respond to Mississippi River Vessel Collision

NEW ORLEANS — More than 30 people were injured Friday when a…
Murder suspect in 'Purge' mask identified -- after student killed on Halloween

Purge-Mask Murder Suspect Identified After Student Killed on Halloween

Colorado authorities have identified everyone shown in security footage released after a…
FBI investigates who placed bomb near Illinois ethanol plant

FBI Investigates Bomb Found Near Illinois Ethanol Plant

The FBI’s Springfield, Illinois, office is directing the investigation and search for…